10 Peacock Original Series That Are So Good You Have to Watch Them Twice

Peacock has carved out a unique spot in the streaming world with its bold original series. From laugh-out-loud comedies to gripping thrillers, these shows pack a punch with fresh stories and stellar casts.

We’ve rounded up ten Peacock originals that are so captivating you’ll want to watch them twice. Each series brings something special, whether it’s clever writing, unforgettable characters, or twists that keep you hooked. Dive into these must-see shows that demand a rewatch to catch every detail.

MacGruber (2021)

Will Forte brings his wild Saturday Night Live character to life in ‘MacGruber’, a chaotic action-comedy series. After a decade in prison, the self-proclaimed hero teams up with Vicki (Kristen Wiig) and Dixon (Ryan Phillippe) to stop a villainous plot by Enos Queeth (Billy Zane).

The show’s absurd humor and over-the-top action make it a riot. Forte’s unhinged performance, paired with sharp gags and a nod to ‘80s action flicks, keeps you laughing. Rewatch it to catch the subtle jokes and ridiculous one-liners you missed the first time.

Girls5eva (2021-2022, 2024)

‘Girls5eva’ follows a ‘90s girl group reuniting for a comeback, led by Sara Bareilles, Renée Elise Goldsberry, Busy Philipps, and Paula Pell. Tina Fey’s executive production adds sharp wit to this musical comedy about second chances.

The catchy songs and heartfelt moments blend perfectly with the group’s messy, hilarious dynamic. Each episode packs clever pop culture jabs and emotional depth. A second viewing reveals the layered humor and character arcs that make this show a gem.

We Are Lady Parts (2021-present)

This British comedy follows an all-female Muslim punk band navigating life, love, and music in the UK. Led by Anjana Vasan as the shy Amina, the band delivers raw energy and bold humor.

‘We Are Lady Parts’ shines with its authentic voice and vibrant characters. The mix of punk rock rebellion and cultural commentary feels fresh and moving. Rewatch it to appreciate the sharp writing and the band’s infectious chemistry.

Poker Face (2023-present)

Natasha Lyonne stars as Charlie Cale in ‘Poker Face’, a mystery-of-the-week series created by Rian Johnson. Charlie’s knack for spotting lies leads her to solve crimes across the US, with guest stars like Adrien Brody and Chloë Sevigny.

The show’s retro vibe and clever cases make it addictive. Lyonne’s charm carries each episode, blending humor with suspense. A second watch lets you spot the clues and enjoy the guest-star surprises all over again.

The Traitors (2023-present)

Hosted by Alan Cumming, ‘The Traitors’ is a reality competition where contestants, including reality TV veterans and newcomers, play a high-stakes game of deception in a Scottish castle. Traitors scheme while faithfuls try to uncover them.

The tension and betrayals keep you glued to the screen. Cumming’s sly hosting adds flair to the drama. Rewatching reveals the subtle strategies and alliances that make this game a thrilling puzzle.

Dr. Death (2021-2023)

‘Dr. Death’ is a chilling anthology series based on true crimes. Season one follows neurosurgeon Christopher Duntsch (Joshua Jackson), whose botched surgeries ruin lives, while season two tracks Paolo Macchiarini’s (Édgar Ramírez) deadly experiments.

The intense storytelling and strong performances grip you from start to finish. It’s a haunting look at trust and betrayal in medicine. A rewatch uncovers the intricate details of each doctor’s downfall.

The Tattooist of Auschwitz (2024)

This six-part series tells the true story of Lali Sokolov, a Holocaust survivor who becomes a tattooist at Auschwitz and falls in love with Gita. The emotional drama stars Jonah Hauer-King and Anna Próchniak.

The show balances heartbreak with hope, showing resilience amid horror. Its powerful performances and historical weight hit hard. Watch it again to absorb the quiet moments and the love story’s depth.

Ted (2024-present)

‘Ted’ is a prequel series to Seth MacFarlane’s films, set in the ‘90s with a foul-mouthed teddy bear living with teen John Bennett. MacFarlane voices Ted, bringing his signature humor to this wild comedy.

The show’s mix of crude jokes and family chaos is pure fun. Nostalgic ‘90s references and absurd gags keep it lively. Rewatch to catch the quick cutaways and hilarious one-liners that fly by fast.

Twisted Metal (2023-present)

Based on the video game, ‘Twisted Metal’ stars Anthony Mackie as John Doe, a delivery driver in a post-apocalyptic wasteland. With Stephanie Beatriz and Will Arnett’s villainous Sweet Tooth, it’s a high-octane action-comedy.

The show nails the game’s chaotic vibe with wild stunts and quirky characters. Its lighthearted take on a dark world is refreshing. A second viewing highlights the action’s creativity and the cast’s chemistry.

Hysteria! (2024)

Set during the 1980s Satanic Panic, ‘Hysteria!’ follows a high school metal band caught in a town’s witch hunt after a teen’s disappearance. The horror-comedy blends scares with dark humor, starring Julie Bowen and Anna Camp.

The show’s retro setting and creepy vibe make it a standout. It balances campy fun with tense moments. Rewatch to enjoy the ‘80s nostalgia and spot the clever horror references woven throughout.

Which Peacock original series is your favorite, or did we miss one you love? Drop your thoughts in the comments!