12 Underrated Netflix Originals You Might’ve Skipped

Netflix churns out countless shows, with splashy hits often stealing the spotlight. But tucked away in its vast library are lesser-known gems that pack bold stories, fresh ideas, and unforgettable characters, quietly waiting for their moment.

From quirky comedies to gripping thrillers, these underrated originals showcase the platform’s knack for diverse storytelling. Below, I list my top 12 overlooked Netflix series, each a hidden treasure worth your next binge.

12. ‘I Think You Should Leave with Tim Robinson’ (2019-2023)

This sketch comedy dives into absurd, awkward moments, from bad job interviews to bizarre hot dog mishaps. Its offbeat humor lands hard for fans of cringe comedy.

Tim Robinson’s manic energy drives the short, punchy sketches. Despite three seasons, its niche vibe keeps it under the radar, but it’s a laugh-out-loud gem.

11. ‘The OA’ (2016-2019)

A woman returns after years missing, sharing a wild tale of near-death experiences and alternate dimensions. This mind-bending mystery blends sci-fi with raw emotion.

Brit Marling stars and co-creates, delivering a haunting performance. Canceled after two seasons, its ambitious story deserved more time to unravel.

10. ‘Russian Doll’ (2019-2022)

Nadia, a wisecracking New Yorker, keeps dying and reliving her 36th birthday in a time loop. This dark comedy explores trauma and redemption with sharp wit.

Natasha Lyonne shines as the sardonic lead, with Greta Lee adding spark. Its two seasons were praised but often overshadowed by Netflix’s bigger hits.

9. ‘Godless’ (2017)

In a 1880s Western town run by women, an outlaw seeks refuge from his vengeful former gang. This gritty miniseries blends tense action with rich character drama.

Michelle Dockery and Merritt Wever lead a stellar cast. Its single season was a quiet triumph, but it never got the buzz it deserved.

8. ‘Unbelievable’ (2019)

A young woman is doubted after reporting a sexual assault, while two detectives hunt a serial predator. This miniseries tackles heavy themes with empathy and grit.

Kaitlyn Dever and Toni Collette deliver powerhouse performances. Its single season was critically acclaimed but slipped past many viewers.

7. ‘American Vandal’ (2017-2018)

A mockumentary dives into high school pranks—like obscene graffiti—unraveling absurd yet surprisingly deep teen drama. Its satirical take on true crime is genius.

Tyler Alvarez and Griffin Gluck anchor the sharp comedy. Canceled after two seasons, its clever humor deserved a bigger audience.

6. ‘On My Block’ (2018-2021)

A group of teens navigates friendships, love, and gang tensions in a tough LA neighborhood. This coming-of-age dramedy balances humor with heartfelt stakes.

Sierra Capri and Jason Genao shine in a vibrant cast. Its four seasons were a cult hit, but it never broke into mainstream chatter.

5. ‘GLOW’ (2017-2019)

A group of women join a quirky 1980s wrestling show, finding empowerment amid personal struggles. This comedy-drama sparkles with heart and retro flair.

Alison Brie and Betty Gilpin lead with charm and grit. Canceled after three seasons, its vibrant energy was cut short too soon.

4. ‘The Get Down’ (2016-2017)

In 1970s New York, teens chase music dreams amid the rise of hip-hop and disco. This vibrant musical drama bursts with style and soul.

Justice Smith and Shameik Moore anchor a dynamic cast. Its single season was a bold experiment that deserved more time to shine.

3. ‘Mindhunter’ (2017-2019)

FBI agents in the 1970s interview serial killers to pioneer criminal profiling, diving into dark minds. This chilling thriller is meticulous and gripping.

Jonathan Groff and Holt McCallany deliver intense performances. Its two seasons were a critical darling, but a third never materialized.

2. ‘Anne with an E’ (2017-2019)

A spirited orphan, Anne, finds her place in a 19th-century Canadian town, reimagining the classic Anne of Green Gables. Its lush visuals and heart steal the show.

Amybeth McNulty shines as the imaginative Anne. Canceled after three seasons, its loyal fans still mourn its untimely end.

1. ‘The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance’ (2019)

In a fantasy world, Gelflings fight a dark force threatening their land, using stunning puppetry. This prequel to the 1982 film is a visual and emotional masterpiece.

Taron Egerton and Anya Taylor-Joy lead a stellar voice cast. Its single season was a triumph, but its niche appeal kept it from wider fame.

Which Netflix gem do you love that flew under the radar, or is there one I missed? Drop your faves in the comments!