The 20 Best Hallmark Channel Stars of All Time, Ranked

Hallmark Channel stars have a unique knack for bringing warmth and charm to every story, making them the heart of the network’s beloved movies. From romantic leads to cozy holiday heroes, these actors and actresses create moments that linger long after the credits roll.

Below, I’ve ranked the 20 best Hallmark Channel stars of all time, based on their impact, versatility, and ability to capture the network’s signature feel-good spirit. Each has left a mark on Hallmark’s legacy, delivering performances that keep us coming back. Let’s meet these fan favorites.

20. Jonathan Bennett

Bennett burst onto Hallmark with ‘Elevator Girl’ (2010) and made history as the network’s first gay lead in ‘The Holiday Sitter’ (2022). His upbeat energy shines in holiday rom-coms.

I love his infectious enthusiasm, especially in ‘The Christmas House’ series. His ability to blend humor with heart makes him a rising star, though he’s newer to the network.

19. Taylor Cole

Cole brings poise to films like ‘Christmas in Homestead’ (2016) and the ‘Ruby Herring Mysteries.’ Her organized, fearless characters add depth to Hallmark’s romance formula.

Her subtle strength keeps me engaged, though her roles can feel similar. She’s a reliable pick for fans of classic Hallmark stories.

18. Jesse Metcalfe

Known for ‘Desperate Housewives,’ Metcalfe joined Hallmark with ‘Christmas Next Door’ (2017) and starred in ‘Chesapeake Shores.’ His brooding charm fits the network’s romantic leads.

I enjoy his intensity, especially in holiday films, but his Hallmark run is shorter than some. He’s a solid fit for small-town love stories.

17. Jessica Lowndes

Lowndes, a ‘90210’ alum, sparkles in Christmas hits like ‘A December Bride’ (2016). Her joyful performances and singing add flair to Hallmark’s holiday lineup.

I’m drawn to her radiant energy, though her move to GAC Family cut her Hallmark tenure short. Her films remain fan favorites.

16. Wes Brown

Brown’s rugged charm shines in ‘Christmas at Graceland’ (2018) and ‘Wedding at Graceland’ (2019). His down-to-earth roles, often with a Southern twang, feel authentic.

His easygoing vibe makes him a great fit for Hallmark’s cozy stories. I like his versatility, though he’s less prolific than others.

15. Alicia Witt

Witt’s enchanting presence elevates ‘A Very Merry Mix-Up’ (2013) and ‘Christmas List’ (2016). Her natural charisma makes her a go-to for holiday rom-coms.

I love her ability to blend wit and warmth, though her nine Hallmark films are fewer than some. She’s a delightful staple.

14. Danica McKellar

A former child star, McKellar starred in 16 Hallmark films, including ‘You, Me, & the Christmas Trees’ (2021). Her girl-next-door charm defined her roles.

Her chemistry with co-stars keeps me hooked, but her shift to GAC Family limits her ranking. She’s a nostalgic favorite.

13. Paul Campbell

Campbell’s comedic timing shines in ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’ (2022), a Hallmark hit. He also co-wrote the film, showing his creative range.

I enjoy his lovable goofball roles, especially in holiday comedies. His growing presence makes him a standout, though he’s less seasoned than others.

12. Kristoffer Polaha

Polaha’s Golden-era charm lights up ‘A Biltmore Christmas’ (2023) and ‘Dater’s Handbook’ (2016). His roles blend romance and depth, often with a historical twist.

His performances feel cinematic, and I’m drawn to his warm energy. He’s a rising star but has fewer films than veterans.

11. Holly Robinson Peete

Peete, a Hollywood powerhouse, stars in ‘Our Christmas Journey’ (2021) and often produces her films. Her heartfelt roles reflect her advocacy for autism awareness.

I admire her ability to balance warmth and strength. Her executive producing adds impact, though her film count is modest.

10. Luke Macfarlane

Macfarlane’s 14 films, like ‘Catch Me If You Claus’ (2023), focus on holiday charm. His role in ‘The Mistletoe Promise’ (2016) showcases his likable persona.

His cello-playing in ‘Chateau Christmas’ (2020) adds a unique touch. I love his cool-guy vibe, though he sticks mostly to Christmas stories.

9. Niall Matter

Matter’s journey from oil rig worker to Hallmark star includes ‘Aurora Teagarden Mysteries’ and ‘Christmas at Dollywood’ (2019). His rugged appeal shines through.

I’m drawn to his grounded performances, especially in mysteries. His diverse roles boost his rank, though he’s not the top lead.

8. Brennan Elliott

Elliott’s 20 films, including the ‘All of My Heart’ trilogy, showcase his humor and leading-man looks. He’s a fan favorite in ‘Ms. Christmas Comes to Town’ (2023).

His knack for both romance and comedy keeps me watching. He’s a reliable star, though not quite at the top tier.

7. Alison Sweeney

Sweeney’s ‘Murder, She Baked’ and ‘Hannah Swensen Mysteries’ films highlight her as podcaster Alex McPherson. Her rom-coms like ‘Open by Christmas’ (2021) add variety.

Her detective roles are my favorite, blending charm and smarts. Her long tenure and versatility earn her a high spot.

6. Ryan Paevey

Paevey, a ‘General Hospital’ alum, stars in ‘Unleashing Mr. Darcy’ (2016) and ‘A Timeless Christmas’ (2020). His blue-eyed charm softens his initially snooty characters.

I love how he wins over audiences by the end. His consistent roles make him a Hallmark heartthrob, though he’s slightly less prolific.

5. Kimberly Williams-Paisley

Williams-Paisley shines in ‘Darrow & Darrow’ and ‘The Christmas Train’ (2017). Her legal dramas and holiday films show her range as a strong, witty lead.

Her dynamic performances keep me engaged, especially in mysteries. Her growing Hallmark presence secures her high rank.

4. Kevin McGarry

McGarry’s versatility spans ‘When Calls the Heart’ and films like ‘The Wedding Veil’ (2022). His everyman charm shines in ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’ (2022).

I’m hooked by his relatable roles and chemistry with co-stars. His active Hallmark career makes him a top contender.

3. Autumn Reeser

Reeser, known from ‘The O.C.,’ stars in ‘The Wedding Veil’ (2022) and ‘A Bramble House Christmas’ (2017). Her bubbly, creative characters light up the screen.

Her early start and diverse roles make her a Hallmark mainstay. I love her heartfelt performances, though she’s just shy of the top.

2. Andrew W. Walker

Walker’s 27 films, like ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’ (2022), cement him as Hallmark royalty. His entrepreneurial spirit and charm shine in ‘Jingle Bell Run’ (2024).

His laugh-out-loud roles and consistent output make him a fan favorite. I’m drawn to his natural charisma, nearly topping the list.

1. Lacey Chabert

Chabert, with 32 films like ‘The Wedding Veil’ (2022) and ‘All of My Heart’ (2015), is Hallmark’s queen. Her wholesome charm shines across holiday and mystery genres.

Her unmatched film count and emotional depth make her number one. I love how she embodies Hallmark’s heart, from rom-coms to thrillers.

Which Hallmark star is your favorite, or did I miss a standout? Share your thoughts in the comments!