10 Paramount+ Original Series That Are So Good You Have to Watch Them Twice

Paramount+ has carved out a unique space in the streaming world with a lineup of original series that hook you from the first episode. From gripping dramas to laugh-out-loud comedies, these shows deliver stories and characters that stick with you long after the credits roll.

Whether you’re into sci-fi adventures, gritty crime tales, or heartfelt family sagas, there’s something on this list that’ll make you hit replay. We’ve rounded up ten Paramount+ originals that are so good, you’ll want to watch them twice to catch every detail.

10. ‘Tulsa King’ (2022-present)

Sylvester Stallone stars as Dwight Manfredi, a mafia capo exiled to Tulsa, Oklahoma, after a long prison stint. He builds a new criminal empire in an unfamiliar city, blending tough-guy grit with fish-out-of-water humor.

The show’s charm lies in its mix of action, wit, and Stallone’s magnetic performance. You’ll want to rewatch to catch the subtle character moments and clever dialogue that make this crime drama a standout.

9. ‘Evil’ (2019-2024)

This psychological thriller follows a skeptical psychologist, a priest-in-training, and a tech expert as they investigate supernatural cases. Each episode dives into eerie mysteries, from demonic possessions to unexplained phenomena.

‘Evil’ balances creepy suspense with sharp humor, making it addictive. A second watch lets you pick up on the layered clues and moral questions woven into each case, keeping you hooked.

8. ‘Star Trek: Discovery’ (2017-2024)

Set a decade before the original ‘Star Trek,’ this sci-fi epic follows Michael Burnham and the USS Discovery crew on galaxy-spanning missions. It’s packed with bold visuals and deep emotional stakes.

The intricate plot and character arcs reward rewatching. You’ll catch new details in the sprawling universe and relationships, especially Burnham’s journey from outcast to leader.

7. ‘The Good Fight’ (2017-2022)

A spin-off of ‘The Good Wife,’ this legal drama tracks Diane Lockhart as she navigates a new law firm and a chaotic world. Christine Baranski shines with sharp wit and fierce determination.

The show’s timely storylines and clever courtroom battles make it a must-rewatch. You’ll want to revisit the biting satire and standout performances from its stellar ensemble.

6. ‘1883’ (2021-2022)

This ‘Yellowstone’ prequel follows the Dutton family’s 19th-century journey across the Great Plains to settle in Montana. It’s a gritty, emotional Western with stunning cinematography.

The raw performances by Tim McGraw and Faith Hill, plus the harrowing stakes, demand a second viewing. You’ll spot new details in the family’s struggles and the brutal frontier life.

5. ‘Star Trek: Strange New Worlds’ (2022-present)

This ‘Star Trek’ series follows Captain Pike and the USS Enterprise on episodic adventures. It blends classic Trek optimism with modern storytelling, featuring a tight-knit crew.

Its mix of humor, heart, and bold missions makes it endlessly rewatchable. You’ll want to revisit the clever nods to the original series and the crew’s growing bonds.

4. ‘1923’ (2022-2023)

Another ‘Yellowstone’ prequel, ‘1923’ dives into the Dutton family’s struggles during Prohibition and the Great Depression. Helen Mirren and Harrison Ford lead a tale of ranch life and survival.

The sweeping drama and rich historical backdrop make it worth a second watch. You’ll catch subtle character motivations and the intense family dynamics that drive the story.

3. ‘Halo’ (2022-2024)

Based on the iconic video game, ‘Halo’ follows Master Chief, a super-soldier, in a futuristic war against an alien threat. The show delivers epic battles and deep world-building.

Its action-packed episodes and layered character arcs beg for a rewatch. You’ll want to dive back into the stunning visuals and unravel the complex sci-fi lore.

2. ‘Mayor of Kingstown’ (2021-present)

Jeremy Renner stars as Mike McLusky, a power broker in a prison-town where crime and corruption rule. This gritty drama explores family, loyalty, and moral gray areas.

The intense pacing and nuanced characters make it a gripping rewatch. You’ll notice new layers in Mike’s decisions and the town’s dark, interconnected web.

1. ‘Dexter: Original Sin’ (2024)

This prequel to ‘Dexter’ follows a young Dexter Morgan as he joins the Miami Metro Police and hones his killer instincts. Patrick Gibson delivers a chilling yet human performance.

The psychological depth and nods to the original series make it a must-rewatch. You’ll want to revisit the tense cat-and-mouse games and Dexter’s dark evolution.

Which Paramount+ original series is your favorite, or did we miss one you love? Drop your thoughts in the comments!