15 Hulu Shows That Were Quietly Canceled

Hulu has a knack for delivering fresh and exciting stories, from quirky comedies to gripping dramas. But not every show gets the chance to shine, and some slip away without much noise.

I’ve pulled together a list of 15 Hulu originals that were canceled too soon, leaving viewers like me wanting more. These shows, ranging from heartfelt tales to bold adventures, deserved better. Let’s dive into what made them special and why their endings stung.

The Great (2020-2023)

This sharp comedy reimagines Catherine the Great’s rise to power with wit and flair. Elle Fanning and Nicholas Hoult spark as Catherine and Emperor Peter III, blending humor with chaotic court drama.

The show’s bold take on history and clever writing won it praise, but Hulu ended it after three seasons. Fans were left hanging, craving more of its wild energy. I’m still annoyed we didn’t get a proper finale.

How I Met Your Father (2022-2023)

A spin-off of the beloved ‘How I Met Your Mother,’ this sitcom follows Sophie as she narrates her journey to find love. Hilary Duff leads a charming cast through modern dating mishaps.

Despite a solid fanbase, Hulu axed it after two seasons, leaving the father’s identity a mystery. It felt like a punch to the gut. I was rooting for Sophie to get her happy ending.

Dollface (2019-2022)

This quirky comedy stars Kat Dennings as Jules, a woman rebuilding friendships after a breakup. The show’s surreal humor and heartfelt moments made it a gem.

Hulu pulled the plug after two seasons, just as it was hitting its stride. The abrupt end left me wanting more of Jules’ journey. It’s a shame such a fresh show didn’t get a fair shot.

PEN15 (2019-2021)

Maya Erskine and Anna Konkle star as awkward teens in this cringe-worthy yet touching comedy. They play younger versions of themselves, navigating middle school with painful realism.

The show’s unique blend of humor and heart earned raves, but Hulu stopped it after two seasons. I loved its raw honesty. It deserved at least one more go to wrap things up.

UnPrisoned (2023-2024)

Kerry Washington shines as Paige, a therapist dealing with her father’s return after prison. This mix of comedy and drama tackles family and healing with warmth.

Hulu canceled it after two seasons, despite its strong cast and story. I felt cheated out of more heartfelt moments. It’s a loss for fans of character-driven shows.

This Fool (2022-2023)

Chris Estrada’s comedy dives into South Central LA, following Julio as he navigates life and family. Its sharp humor and take on community life were refreshing.

Hulu ended it after two seasons, even with critical love. I enjoyed its grounded vibe and real laughs. It could’ve grown into something even bigger.

Black Cake (2023)

This mystery drama follows a family unraveling secrets after their mother’s death. Its rich storytelling and twists kept me hooked from the start.

Hulu canceled it after one season, leaving many questions unanswered. I was invested in the emotional depth. It’s frustrating to lose such a promising story so soon.

Life & Beth (2022-2024)

Amy Schumer stars as Beth, a woman rethinking her life after loss. The show blends comedy with raw emotion, thanks to Schumer and Michael Cera’s chemistry.

Hulu axed it after two seasons, despite its loyal fans. I appreciated its honest look at grief. It deserved more time to explore Beth’s growth.

The Other Black Girl (2023)

Based on Zakiya Dalila Harris’ novel, this thriller follows Nella, a Black editorial assistant facing workplace tension. Its mix of suspense and social commentary was gripping.

Hulu ended it after one season, citing mixed reviews. I found its take on race and ambition compelling. A second season could’ve deepened the story.

Love, Victor (2020-2022)

A spin-off of ‘Love, Simon,’ this heartfelt drama follows Victor’s journey of self-discovery as a gay teen. It’s warm, relatable, and full of heart.

Hulu stopped it after three seasons, saying the story felt complete. I disagree—Victor’s arc had more to give. Fans like me wanted to see his next chapter.

Maggie (2022)

Rebecca Rittenhouse plays Maggie, a psychic juggling her gift and chaotic life. The sitcom’s light humor and charm made it an easy watch.

Hulu canceled it after one season, likely due to low buzz. I enjoyed its breezy vibe. It had potential to grow into a fan favorite with more time.

Death and Other Details (2024)

This murder mystery unfolds on a lavish cruise ship, with Violett Beane as a suspect teaming up with a detective. Its twists and style were engaging.

Hulu axed it after one season due to mixed reception. I liked its old-school mystery feel. A second season could’ve ironed out the kinks.

Reboot (2022)

Keegan-Michael Key leads this clever comedy about reviving a fictional sitcom. It pokes fun at Hollywood reboots with sharp humor and a great cast.

Hulu ended it after one season, despite strong reviews. I loved its meta take on TV. It’s a bummer we didn’t get more of its witty charm.

Kindred (2022)

Based on Octavia Butler’s novel, this sci-fi drama follows Dana, a woman time-traveling to 1800s Maryland. It tackles history and race with bold storytelling.

Hulu canceled it after one season, leaving its potential untapped. I was gripped by its intensity. It deserved a chance to fully explore its themes.

High Fidelity (2020)

Zoë Kravitz stars in this gender-swapped remake of the classic film, playing a record store owner navigating love. Its music and heart made it a standout.

Hulu axed it after one season, despite critical love. I was drawn to its vibe and diversity. It’s a shame this gem didn’t get another spin.

Which of these canceled Hulu shows do you wish had another season, or did I miss one you loved? Drop your thoughts in the comments!