Peacock’s 2025 Cancellations: Shows That Didn’t Make the Cut

Peacock has been shaking things up in 2025, trimming its lineup to focus on new directions. The streaming service, known for bold originals, made some tough calls this year, ending several series that had captured our attention.

From gritty dramas to quirky comedies, the cancelled shows each brought something unique to the table. Let’s take a closer look at the six Peacock originals that won’t be returning and why they left a mark.

Teacup (2024)

This chilling horror series, based on Robert R. McCammon’s novel ‘Stinger,’ centered on a rural Georgia community battling an eerie, unknown threat. With Yvonne Strahovski and Scott Speedman leading the cast, it delivered tense, emotional storytelling.

Peacock ended ‘Teacup’ after one season, despite its gripping narrative. The show’s atmospheric dread and strong performances made it a fan favorite, but low viewership sealed its fate. We’re bummed we won’t see more of this haunting tale.

Hysteria! (2024)

Set in the 1980s during the Satanic Panic, ‘Hysteria!’ was a horror-comedy about teens caught in a supernatural mystery. Starring Julie Bowen and Bruce Campbell, it earned a 91% on Rotten Tomatoes for its clever mix of scares and laughs.

Cancelled after its debut season, the show didn’t get the audience it deserved. Its nostalgic vibe and sharp writing were highlights, and we’re sad to say goodbye to this spooky gem.

Laid (2024)

This dark comedy followed Ruby, a woman whose past relationships take a deadly turn as her exes start dying mysteriously. Stephanie Hsu’s vibrant performance carried the show’s quirky exploration of love and loss.

Peacock pulled the plug after one season, leaving Ruby’s story unresolved. The show’s fresh spin on romance and dark humor had us hooked, making its cancellation a tough pill to swallow.

Bupkis (2023)

A semi-autobiographical comedy about Pete Davidson’s life, ‘Bupkis’ mixed raw humor with personal struggles. With Edie Falco and Joe Pesci, plus cameos from stars like John Mulaney, it offered a unique look at fame.

Despite a renewal, Peacock axed it after one season. The show’s bold tone and heartfelt moments made it stand out, and we’re disappointed we won’t see more of Pete’s chaotic life.

Bel-Air (2022-2025)

This modern take on ‘The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air’ followed Will’s journey from Philadelphia to the upscale world of Bel-Air. Jabari Banks and a strong cast, including Cassandra Freeman, brought depth to this dramatic reimagining.

After four seasons, Peacock decided to end the series. Its blend of cultural commentary and family drama kept us engaged, and we’ll miss watching Will navigate his new world.

Based on a True Story (2023-2024)

This dark comedy-thriller starred Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina as a couple diving into the true-crime world by partnering with a killer for a podcast. Its sharp humor and twists kept viewers guessing.

Cancelled after two seasons, the show couldn’t secure a third, despite a 79% Rotten Tomatoes score. Its clever satire and wild plot made it a standout, and we’re sorry to see it go.

Which Peacock show are you most upset about losing, or is there one you think deserved another shot? Share your take in the comments!