‘Wednesday’ (2022- ) hooked me with its dark charm and quirky take on the Addams Family universe, blending teen drama with supernatural mystery. Jenna Ortega’s deadpan delivery as Wednesday Addams anchors the show, set in the eerie Nevermore Academy, where outcasts hone their peculiar gifts.

The series balances clever storytelling with moments that left me scratching my head. Below, I dive into five things that felt utterly baffling and five that clicked perfectly, exploring what made this show both puzzling and brilliant.

Things That Made No Sense

Principal Weems’ Untapped Power

Larissa Weems, played by Gwendoline Christie, is a shapeshifter running Nevermore Academy. Her ability to transform into anyone seems like a game-changer, yet she barely uses it, even when investigating dangerous mysteries.

This choice feels odd. A shapeshifter could impersonate suspects or spy unnoticed, but Weems sticks to paperwork and stern looks, making her power seem wasted and her role less dynamic than it could’ve been.

The Hyde’s Convenient Timing

The Hyde, a monstrous creature tied to a student, pops up at the worst possible moments, attacking with uncanny precision. Its appearances often feel too perfectly timed to push the plot forward.

How does it always know when to strike? The lack of explanation for its near-omniscient attacks stretches believability, leaving me wondering if it’s just a plot device with no clear rules.

Wednesday’s Sudden Social Skills

Wednesday starts as a loner who despises small talk and connections. Yet, she quickly forms alliances with classmates like Enid and Eugene, navigating social dynamics with surprising ease.

This shift feels jarring. Her transformation into a team player happens too fast, clashing with her core personality and making her newfound friendships seem more convenient than earned.

The Prophecy’s Vague Rules

A prophecy drives much of the story, hinting at Wednesday’s role in a looming disaster. But its details are murky, with cryptic clues that characters accept without questioning.

This vagueness frustrates. A prophecy should have clear stakes or logic, but this one feels like a loose thread, leaving me unsure why everyone trusts it so blindly.

Tyler’s Motives Flip-Flop

Tyler, a seemingly normal barista, reveals hidden depths tied to the central mystery. His motivations swing wildly between loyalty and betrayal, with little explanation for his choices.

This inconsistency bugs me. Without a clear reason for his shifting allegiances, his arc feels like a puzzle missing pieces, undermining the emotional weight of his actions.

Things That Made Perfect Sense

Wednesday’s Razor-Sharp Wit

Jenna Ortega’s Wednesday delivers biting one-liners with a deadpan stare, perfectly capturing the character’s morbid humor. Her quips, like dismissing normies with a smirk, feel true to the Addams legacy.

This consistency shines. Her sharp tongue grounds the show, making every scene she’s in a delight, whether she’s solving mysteries or roasting classmates.

Nevermore’s Outcast Haven

Nevermore Academy, a school for werewolves, vampires, and other oddities, feels like the ideal setting for Wednesday’s story. Its gothic halls and quirky students create a world where she fits right in.

This makes sense. A place that celebrates weirdness lets Wednesday thrive, and the school’s mix of cliques and secrets drives the drama naturally.

Enid’s Sunny Contrast

Enid Sinclair, Wednesday’s bubbly werewolf roommate, played by Emma Myers, is her polar opposite. Her bright energy and colorful style clash with Wednesday’s gloom, creating instant chemistry.

This dynamic works. Enid’s warmth balances Wednesday’s coldness, making their friendship a highlight and giving the show heart without losing its edge.

The Addams Family Cameos

Gomez and Morticia, portrayed by Luis Guzmán and Catherine Zeta-Jones, appear just enough to tie the show to its roots. Their over-the-top love and quirky parenting ground Wednesday’s backstory.

This feels right. Their brief but memorable scenes honor the Addams legacy while keeping the focus on Wednesday’s journey, striking a perfect balance.

The Monster Mystery Arc

The central plot revolves around a monster terrorizing Jericho, with Wednesday piecing together clues. The mystery unfolds with twists that tie into Nevermore’s history and her own abilities.

This clicks beautifully. The investigation keeps the pace tight, blending detective work with supernatural flair, and Wednesday’s sleuthing feels like a natural extension of her cunning.

What’s your take on ‘Wednesday’ – which moments baffled you or felt spot-on? Drop your thoughts in the comments!