Netflix’s ‘Wednesday’ burst onto screens in 2022, bringing a fresh spin to the iconic Addams Family. With Jenna Ortega as the sharp-witted Wednesday Addams, the show blended teen drama, gothic vibes, and a murder mystery, all under Tim Burton’s eerie touch. It hooked millions, becoming a cultural hit with viral dances and memes galore.

Looking back in 2025, some parts of ‘Wednesday’ still shine bright, while others feel a bit stuck in time. I’ve rewatched it and noticed what holds up and what doesn’t. Below, I break down five ways the show hasn’t aged well and five ways it remains a gem.

5 Ways ‘Wednesday’ (2022– ) Aged Poorly

Predictable Plot Twists

The mystery at Nevermore Academy, where Wednesday digs into a killing spree, feels flat on rewatch. The clues are too obvious, and the big reveals, like the true villain’s identity, don’t surprise as much as they should. Modern shows lean on tighter, more layered mysteries, and ‘Wednesday’ can feel basic in comparison.

This lack of depth makes the suspense fizzle out. I wanted more clever hints to keep me guessing, but the straightforward story doesn’t hold the same thrill years later.

Clunky Teen Tropes

The show leans hard into high school clichés—think love triangles and mean-girl drama. These feel dated, like they’re pulled from early 2000s teen shows. Wednesday’s cool detachment clashes with these overdone plots, making them feel forced.

I cringed at moments like the awkward romance arcs. They don’t mesh well with the Addams Family’s quirky vibe, and today’s audiences often want fresher takes on teen stories.

Underused Supporting Cast

Characters like Gomez (Luis Guzmán) and Morticia (Catherine Zeta-Jones) get little screen time. Their brief appearances don’t capture the Addams Family charm fans love. Uncle Fester, played by Fred Armisen, feels more like a cameo than a key player.

This makes the show feel thin outside Wednesday’s story. I wished for more family moments to ground the gothic world, but they’re sidelined for less interesting sidekicks.

Overreliance on CGI

The supernatural elements, like monsters and psychic visions, often lean on flashy CGI. Some effects, especially in big action scenes, look dated now. They pull you out of the story, feeling more like a video game than a creepy tale.

In 2025, with slicker visuals in newer shows, these moments don’t impress. I wanted more practical effects to match Burton’s spooky style, but the CGI feels like a shortcut.

Uneven Tone

‘Wednesday’ juggles dark humor, horror, and teen drama, but the mix doesn’t always work. Goofy moments, like Thing’s antics, can clash with grim murder scenes. This tonal whiplash feels jarring on rewatch.

I found myself wanting a steadier vibe. The show’s charm is in its darkness, but the lighter bits sometimes feel like they belong in a different series.

5 Ways ‘Wednesday’ (2022– ) Aged Masterfully

Iconic Soundtrack

The music, with Danny Elfman’s haunting score, still gives chills. Tracks like the viral ‘Goo Goo Muck’ dance scene perfectly match the show’s moody vibe. The soundtrack feels timeless, tying every scene together.

I still hum those eerie tunes. They make ‘Wednesday’ stand out, keeping its gothic heart alive years later.

Nevermore’s Gothic World

The setting of Nevermore Academy, with its dark halls and creepy forests, remains stunning. Burton’s touch makes every frame feel like a gothic painting. The school’s cliques—vampires, werewolves, gorgons—add a rich, Harry Potter-like vibe.

I love getting lost in this world. Its spooky charm feels fresh and draws you in, even on a third watch.

Cultural Impact

‘Wednesday’ became a pop culture storm, with Jenna Ortega’s dance sparking TikTok trends and Lady Gaga remixing the music. Its influence, from Halloween costumes to memes, still lingers in 2025. The show tapped into a love for dark, quirky teens.

I see its mark everywhere, from fan art to fashion. That lasting buzz proves its power to connect.

Strong Supporting Dynamics

Wednesday’s bond with Enid Sinclair (Emma Myers), her bubbly werewolf roommate, is a highlight. Their opposites-attract friendship feels real and grows naturally. Enid’s warmth balances Wednesday’s chill, creating heartfelt moments.

I smiled at their scenes every time. This dynamic keeps the show grounded and endlessly rewatchable.

Jenna Ortega’s Star Power

Jenna Ortega’s Wednesday is the show’s soul. Her deadpan delivery, sharp glares, and subtle growth make the character iconic. She nails the balance of staying true to Wednesday’s grim roots while adding teen depth.

I can’t imagine anyone else in the role. Ortega’s performance keeps ‘Wednesday’ a must-watch, even years later.

What’s your take on ‘Wednesday’—which moments still hook you, or what feels off now? Drop your thoughts in the comments!