15 Supernatural Series You’ll Love If You Grew Up on ‘Supernatural’
If you spent your nights gripped by the Winchester brothers’ monster-hunting adventures in Supernatural, you’re probably chasing that same mix of spooky thrills, heartfelt bonds, and witty banter. The show’s blend of horror, humor, and family drama set a high bar, but there are other series out there that capture a similar vibe.
I’ve picked 15 shows that deliver paranormal mysteries, epic battles, and tight-knit character dynamics to keep you hooked. From gritty demon hunts to quirky ghost stories, these series offer something for every Supernatural fan looking to dive back into the unknown.
The Winchesters (2022-2023)
John and Mary, the parents of Sam and Dean, take center stage in this prequel set in the 1970s. It follows their early days as hunters, unraveling mysteries about their families while battling demons and monsters in a world that feels both familiar and fresh.
The show keeps the Supernatural spirit with its mix of action and heart, plus the iconic Impala. While it only ran for one season, the chemistry between Drake Rodger and Meg Donnelly makes it a must-watch for fans craving more of the Winchester legacy.
Grimm (2011-2017)
Nick Burkhardt, a Portland detective, discovers he’s a Grimm, a guardian who can see and fight mythological creatures living among humans. Each episode brings new monsters, blending police work with fairy-tale lore.
Like Supernatural, it balances episodic creature hunts with a deeper myth arc. The show’s creative take on folklore and David Giuntoli’s grounded performance make it a gripping ride for fans of monster-of-the-week stories.
The X-Files (1993-2018)
FBI agents Mulder and Scully investigate unexplained cases involving aliens, ghosts, and other paranormal phenomena. Their dynamic—his belief, her skepticism—drives the show through creepy standalone episodes and a sprawling conspiracy.
It’s a cornerstone for Supernatural fans, with a similar blend of horror and humor. David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson’s chemistry keeps you invested, whether you’re in for the scares or the slow-burn mythology.
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1997-2003)
Buffy Summers, a high schooler turned vampire slayer, battles demons, vampires, and the struggles of youth with her loyal friends. The show mixes campy humor, horror, and heartfelt moments.
It’s got the same monster-hunting energy as Supernatural, with a strong focus on chosen family. Sarah Michelle Gellar’s iconic performance and the show’s witty writing make it a timeless pick for fans of the Winchesters.
Angel (1999-2004)
A spin-off from Buffy, this follows Angel, a vampire with a soul, as he runs a supernatural detective agency in Los Angeles. He helps humans and demons alike while wrestling with his own dark past.
It echoes Supernatural with its gritty urban setting and moral dilemmas. David Boreanaz’s brooding lead, paired with the show’s mix of noir and horror, makes it a great fit for fans of darker paranormal tales.
Lucifer (2016-2021)
The Devil himself, Lucifer Morningstar, ditches Hell to run a nightclub in Los Angeles and ends up solving crimes with a detective. His charm and supernatural flair drive this blend of comedy and drama.
Like Supernatural, it leans on witty dialogue and a charismatic lead, played by Tom Ellis. The mix of celestial stakes and grounded character arcs makes it a fun, addictive watch for fans of angelic lore.
Charmed (1998-2006)
Three sisters discover they’re powerful witches destined to fight evil forces. From demons to warlocks, they tackle supernatural threats while juggling personal lives in San Francisco.
Its focus on sibling bonds and monster battles feels like Supernatural with a magical twist. The chemistry among Holly Marie Combs, Alyssa Milano, and Shannen Doherty keeps the show engaging through its long run.
Teen Wolf (2011-2017)
Scott McCall, a high schooler, becomes a werewolf after a bite and must protect his town from supernatural threats. His friendship with Stiles anchors the show through action-packed seasons.
It captures Supernatural’s blend of teen drama and monster hunts. Tyler Posey and Dylan O’Brien’s dynamic mirrors Sam and Dean’s brotherhood, making it a great pick for fans of heartfelt heroics.
The Vampire Diaries (2009-2017)
In Mystic Falls, brothers Stefan and Damon Salvatore, both vampires, vie for Elena’s love while facing witches, werewolves, and ancient curses. The show dives deep into supernatural lore.
Its mix of romance, horror, and family drama aligns with Supernatural’s emotional stakes. The intense performances and twisty plots keep you glued, especially if you love rich mythologies.
The Originals (2013-2018)
A Vampire Diaries spin-off, this follows the Mikaelson siblings, the first vampires, as they fight for control of New Orleans. Power struggles and family loyalty drive the dark, stylish drama.
It’s got Supernatural’s knack for blending epic stakes with personal conflicts. Joseph Morgan’s commanding role as Klaus makes it a standout for fans of morally complex characters.
Penny Dreadful (2014-2016)
In Victorian London, a team including a gunslinger, a medium, and Victor Frankenstein battles supernatural threats like vampires and witches. The show weaves classic horror with gothic drama.
Its dark tone and literary roots echo Supernatural’s early seasons. Eva Green’s haunting performance as Vanessa Ives anchors this beautifully crafted series, perfect for fans of moody horror.
Warehouse 13 (2009-2014)
Secret Service agents Pete and Myka hunt magical artifacts stored in a mysterious warehouse. Each episode brings a new object with dangerous powers, blending adventure and humor.
It’s like Supernatural but with artifacts instead of monsters, plus a quirky team dynamic. The show’s lighthearted vibe and Eddie McClintock’s charm make it a fun, bingeable choice.
Sleepy Hollow (2013-2017)
Ichabod Crane, resurrected in modern times, teams with a cop to stop the Headless Horseman and other apocalyptic threats. It mixes folklore, history, and supernatural action.
The show’s monster-hunting setup and witty banter feel straight out of Supernatural. Tom Mison’s fish-out-of-time performance adds a unique flavor to this thrilling ride.
Dead Boy Detectives (2024)
Two teenage ghosts run a detective agency, solving supernatural mysteries for the dead. Set in the Sandman universe, it blends spooky cases with emotional depth.
Its focus on friendship and episodic mysteries mirrors Supernatural’s early vibe. The charming leads, George Rexstrew and Jayden Revri, make it a fresh, heartfelt pick for fans.
What We Do in the Shadows (2019-2024)
Four vampires living together in modern-day New York navigate daily life, rivalries, and supernatural antics. This mockumentary-style comedy is packed with absurd humor.
It’s Supernatural’s lighter side amplified, with a paranormal twist. The hilarious ensemble, led by Matt Berry and Kayvan Novak, makes it a perfect escape for fans who loved the Winchesters’ wit.
Which of these supernatural series is your go-to after Supernatural, or is there another spooky gem I missed? Share your faves in the comments!