5 Ways ‘Star Wars Episode VIII: The Last Jedi’ Aged Poorly (And 5 Ways It Aged Masterfully)

I’ve revisited ‘Star Wars Episode VIII: The Last Jedi’ (2017) plenty of times since its release, and it’s a film that still sparks heated debates. Rian Johnson’s take on the saga shook things up, diving into bold choices that thrilled some and frustrated others.

As the years pass, certain parts of the movie feel less fresh, while others shine brighter than ever. Let’s break down five ways this chapter in the Skywalker saga hasn’t held up and five ways it remains a standout, alternating between the two.

Aged Poorly: Luke Skywalker’s Character Shift

Luke Skywalker’s arc in ‘The Last Jedi’ feels jarring to me now. Mark Hamill’s portrayal of a bitter, exiled Jedi Master strays far from the hopeful hero of ‘Return of the Jedi’ (1983).

His moment of doubt, nearly striking down a young Ben Solo, seems out of character for someone who once believed in Darth Vader’s redemption. While Hamill delivers a heartfelt performance, the cynical Luke doesn’t fully mesh with the trilogy’s legacy, leaving a sour taste for many.

Aged Masterfully: Rey and Kylo Ren’s Connection

The Force bond between Rey and Kylo Ren is a highlight that gets better with time. Daisy Ridley and Adam Driver share electric chemistry as their characters communicate across the galaxy.

These scenes deepen both characters, showing Rey’s hope and Kylo’s inner conflict. The raw emotion and fresh take on Force powers make their dynamic a gripping cornerstone of the sequel trilogy.

Aged Poorly: The Canto Bight Subplot

The side trip to Canto Bight with Finn and Rose Tico feels like a detour that doesn’t land anymore. John Boyega and Kelly Marie Tran do their best, but the casino planet’s glitz feels disconnected from the main story.

The chase with fathiers and the codebreaker hunt add little to the Resistance’s fight. It’s a well-meaning critique of war profiteering, but the execution drags and feels like filler.

Aged Masterfully: Stunning Visual Craft

The visuals in ‘The Last Jedi’ remain jaw-dropping. From the crimson salt flats of Crait to the silent hyperspace sacrifice, Rian Johnson’s direction crafts unforgettable imagery.

Every frame, like Luke facing the First Order alone, feels painterly. The blend of practical effects and CGI holds up, making the film a visual feast that rivals any modern blockbuster.

Aged Poorly: Underused Characters

Characters like Captain Phasma and Supreme Leader Snoke feel wasted now. Gwendoline Christie’s Phasma gets a brief duel with Finn before a quick exit, despite her commanding presence.

Andy Serkis’ Snoke, built up as a major threat, meets an abrupt end without much backstory. These missed opportunities leave the First Order’s ranks feeling thin and less menacing.

Aged Masterfully: Thematic Depth

The film’s exploration of failure and legacy grows richer with each viewing. Luke’s struggle, Poe’s reckless heroism, and Rey’s search for identity all tie into learning from mistakes.

Johnson challenges the idea of hero worship, suggesting anyone can rise to greatness. This bold theme feels timeless, resonating in a world grappling with complex leadership and change.

Aged Poorly: Humor That Falls Flat

Some of the humor in ‘The Last Jedi’ feels forced today. Poe’s prank call to General Hux, played by Domhnall Gleeson, aims for laughs but feels out of place in a tense space battle.

Other gags, like Luke’s over-the-top milk-drinking scene, lean too quirky. The comedic tone clashes with the saga’s gravitas, making certain moments feel less authentic.

Aged Masterfully: Carrie Fisher’s Final Role

Carrie Fisher’s performance as Leia Organa is a treasure that shines brighter now. Her scenes carry emotional weight, blending strength and warmth as the Resistance’s leader.

Leia’s use of the Force to survive in space, while divisive, feels poetic given Fisher’s passing. Her final bow is a heartfelt tribute to an icon, cementing her legacy.

Aged Poorly: Inconsistent Force Logic

The film’s handling of the Force feels shaky at times. Rey’s rapid mastery, like lifting boulders with ease, stretches believability without clear training.

Meanwhile, Luke’s projection across the galaxy is awe-inspiring but drains him fatally, which feels arbitrary. These inconsistencies make the Force’s rules seem less grounded than in earlier films.

Aged Masterfully: Throne Room Showdown

The throne room battle is a masterpiece that still thrills. Rey and Kylo teaming up against Snoke’s guards delivers heart-pounding action with flawless choreography.

The red backdrop and shifting alliances keep you glued to the screen. It’s a bold twist that redefines the stakes, proving the film’s knack for delivering iconic moments.

What’s your take on ‘The Last Jedi’—which scenes still hit hard, or which ones miss the mark? Drop your thoughts in the comments!