5 Things About ‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1’ That Made Zero Sense and 5 Things That Made Perfect Sense

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1 is a key chapter in the beloved wizarding saga. Fans were thrilled to see Harry, Ron, and Hermione take on the hunt for Horcruxes, but the movie left some scratching their heads. Certain moments felt confusing or poorly explained, while others clicked perfectly with the story’s emotional and narrative arcs.

This list dives into five things in the film that didn’t add up and five that hit the mark. By alternating between what baffled fans and what worked seamlessly, we’ll unpack the highs and lows of this pivotal installment.

The Tent Dance Scene (Zero Sense)

Harry and Hermione’s slow dance in the tent comes out of nowhere. After Ron leaves, they’re grieving, yet they share this awkward, wordless moment to a random radio song. It feels forced and doesn’t fit their dynamic or the story’s tone. The scene tries to show their bond but ends up feeling like filler.

It also confuses fans because it hints at romance that never existed in the books. The movie spends precious time on this instead of developing more pressing plot points, leaving viewers puzzled.

The Horcrux Hunt’s Urgency (Perfect Sense)

The film captures the desperate stakes of hunting Horcruxes. Harry, Ron, and Hermione are on the run, with Voldemort’s forces closing in, and the constant tension feels real. Every decision they make carries weight, from decoding clues to surviving ambushes.

The pacing mirrors their isolation and fear, making their mission feel critical. This focus on their struggle grounds the story and keeps viewers invested in their fight against impossible odds.

The Shard of Mirror (Zero Sense)

Harry’s obsession with the mirror shard is never properly explained. He keeps staring at it, seeing flashes of Dumbledore, but the movie doesn’t clarify its purpose until much later. It feels random and distracts from the main plot.

The lack of context frustrates viewers who haven’t read the books. Even when its significance is revealed in Part 2, the buildup in Part 1 feels vague and disconnected from the story’s flow.

Dobby’s Sacrifice (Perfect Sense)

Dobby’s death is heartbreaking and perfectly executed. His loyalty to Harry shines through as he saves them from Malfoy Manor, only to die at Bellatrix’s hand. The emotional weight lands hard because the film builds up his courage and love for his friends.

The scene’s simplicity—Harry digging Dobby’s grave without magic—adds raw humanity. It’s a moment that honors Dobby’s arc and reminds viewers of the war’s real cost.

The Snatcher Chase Logic (Zero Sense)

The Snatcher chase in the forest raises questions. The trio is supposed to be hidden under protective charms, yet Snatchers find them almost instantly after they say Voldemort’s name. The movie doesn’t explain why the name suddenly breaks their defenses.

This plot device feels convenient to push the story forward. It leaves viewers wondering why the trio didn’t avoid saying the name when they knew it was dangerous.

The Trio’s Emotional Fracture (Perfect Sense)

Ron’s departure after a fight with Harry and Hermione feels painfully real. The Horcrux’s influence amplifies his insecurities, showing how fear and jealousy can tear even close friends apart. The film nails this conflict by letting each character’s flaws shine.

Their reconciliation later carries weight because of this raw portrayal. It’s a reminder that even heroes struggle with doubt, making their bond stronger when they reunite.

The Elder Wand’s Introduction (Zero Sense)

The Elder Wand’s backstory is rushed and confusing. The film briefly mentions it through Xenophilius Lovegood’s tale, but it feels like an afterthought. Non-book readers are left clueless about its significance or why it matters to Voldemort.

This lack of clarity undermines the wand’s role in the story. A little more explanation could have made its power feel as legendary as the movie wants it to be.

Bill and Fleur’s Wedding (Perfect Sense)

The wedding at the Burrow is a bright spot before the darkness. It shows a moment of joy and love amidst the war, with the Weasley family’s warmth shining through. The sudden Death Eater attack heightens the stakes, blending celebration with dread.

The scene sets up the trio’s isolation perfectly. It’s a brief glimpse of what they’re fighting for, making their journey feel even more urgent.

The Polyjuice Potion Plan (Zero Sense)

The plan to move Harry from Privet Drive using Polyjuice Potion is chaotic and hard to follow. Seven people disguise themselves as Harry, but the logistics—how they all get wands or act convincingly—aren’t clear. The scene feels more flashy than practical.

It also raises questions about why the Order took such a risky approach. The plan’s holes make it hard to believe this was their best shot at keeping Harry safe.

The Locket’s Destruction (Perfect Sense)

Ron destroying the locket Horcrux is a standout moment. The Horcrux taunts him with visions of his worst fears, pushing his insecurities to the surface. His triumph, with Harry’s support, feels earned and shows his growth.

The scene balances action and emotion, making it a turning point for Ron’s character. It’s a powerful reminder of why the trio’s friendship is the heart of the story.

What’s your take on these moments from Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1—share your thoughts in the comments!