LGBTQ+ Actors Who Deserve More Respect From Critics

The entertainment industry has seen a significant rise in the visibility of LGBTQ+ actors over the last decade. Many of these performers have moved beyond typecast roles to deliver powerful and nuanced performances in major film and television projects. Despite their growing presence and acclaimed work, some critics still overlook the full depth of their range and artistic contributions. This list highlights talented male actors who consistently deliver exceptional work and merit greater recognition for their craft.

Colman Domingo

Colman Domingo has established himself as a powerful force in both theater and film with his commanding screen presence. He gained widespread recognition for his role in the hit series ‘Euphoria’ and received critical acclaim for ‘Rustin’. His career spans decades with significant performances in movies like ‘Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom’ and ‘The Color Purple’. Critics often praise his ability to convey deep emotion and maintain dignity in complex roles. He remains a vital figure in advocating for diverse storytelling within Hollywood.

Andrew Scott

This Irish actor captured global attention as the villainous Moriarty in ‘Sherlock’ and the charismatic priest in ‘Fleabag’. His extensive theater background includes award-winning performances in major London productions of ‘Hamlet’ and ‘Vanya’. He recently delivered a critically adoring performance in the emotional drama ‘All of Us Strangers’. Scott consistently chooses roles that challenge traditional archetypes of masculinity and vulnerability. His work demonstrates a profound range that transitions seamlessly between menace and warmth.

Ben Whishaw

Ben Whishaw is a distinguished British actor known for voicing the title character in ‘Paddington’ and playing Q in the James Bond franchise. He won a Golden Globe for his portrayal of Norman Scott in the limited series ‘A Very English Scandal’. His stage work includes accolades for playing major Shakespearean roles like Hamlet and Julius Caesar. Whishaw often brings a unique sensitivity and intensity to his character portrayals across various genres. He continues to balance high-profile blockbusters with smaller independent projects that showcase his versatility.

Matt Bomer

Matt Bomer gained initial fame as the charming con artist in ‘White Collar’ before taking on heavier dramatic roles. He won a Golden Globe for his supporting performance in the television movie ‘The Normal Heart’. His recent work in ‘Fellow Travelers’ demonstrated his capability to handle decades-spanning romantic narratives with subtlety. Bomer frequently balances stage work with his television and film projects. He continues to prove that he is more than just a leading man with classic good looks.

Jonathan Bailey

Jonathan Bailey saw his international profile rise significantly with his role as Anthony Bridgerton in the period drama ‘Bridgerton’. He previously won a Laurence Olivier Award for his supporting role in the London revival of ‘Company’. His performance in the limited series ‘Fellow Travelers’ showcased his ability to tackle complex emotional arcs. Bailey successfully navigates both musical theater and serious television drama. He is quickly becoming one of the most sought-after actors of his generation.

Lee Pace

Lee Pace has delivered memorable performances in visually stunning projects like ‘The Fall’ and the ‘Hobbit’ trilogy. His portrayal of Joe MacMillan in ‘Halt and Catch Fire’ showcased his ability to lead a complex drama series over multiple seasons. He recently played the formidable Empire in the expansive sci-fi series ‘Foundation’. Critics acknowledge his commanding physical presence and his range in both fantasy and dramatic roles. He maintains a steady and impressive career in both television and major film franchises.

Luke Evans

Luke Evans has built a robust career playing action heroes and dramatic leads in blockbusters like ‘Dracula Untold’ and ‘Beauty and the Beast’. He began his career in London theater before transitioning to Hollywood films. His performance in the limited series ‘The Pembrokeshire Murders’ displayed his skill in gritty crime dramas. Evans often performs his own stunts and brings a intense physicality to his roles. He remains a consistent box office draw who can carry major studio productions.

Zachary Quinto

Zachary Quinto broke through as the villain Sylar in ‘Heroes’ and later portrayed Spock in the rebooted ‘Star Trek’ films. He earned an Emmy nomination for his disturbing performance in ‘American Horror Story: Asylum’. His stage career includes significant roles in plays like ‘The Boys in the Band’ and ‘Angels in America’. Quinto is known for his intelligence and ability to play articulate but often unsettling characters. He also produces independent films that highlight marginalized voices.

Jim Parsons

Jim Parsons became a household name and won four Emmy Awards for playing Sheldon Cooper in ‘The Big Bang Theory’. He later demonstrated his dramatic range in the film adaptation of ‘The Boys in the Band’ and the miniseries ‘Hollywood’. His work in the spoiler-filled drama ‘Spoiler Alert’ showed a softer and more romantic side to his acting. Parsons has successfully transitioned from a singular iconic sitcom role to a variety of complex characters. He continues to work extensively in both theater and film production.

Neil Patrick Harris

Neil Patrick Harris successfully shed his child actor image to play the womanizing Barney Stinson in ‘How I Met Your Mother’. He won a Tony Award for his starring role in the rock musical ‘Hedwig and the Angry Inch’. His film roles range from the thriller ‘Gone Girl’ to the sci-fi action of ‘The Matrix Resurrections’. Harris is a versatile entertainer who sings, dances, and acts with equal proficiency. He remains a prominent figure in entertainment with a career that spans decades.

Ian McKellen

Sir Ian McKellen is a legend of stage and screen who reached new generations as Gandalf in ‘The Lord of the Rings’. He is equally revered for his portrayal of Magneto in the ‘X-Men’ film series. His Shakespearean career is unparalleled and includes acclaimed performances as Macbeth and King Lear. McKellen brings gravitas and wit to every role he inhabits regardless of the genre. He serves as an inspiration to younger actors for his longevity and openness about his identity.

Rupert Everett

Rupert Everett gained fame in the 1990s with breakout roles in ‘My Best Friend’s Wedding’ and ‘An Ideal Husband’. He later wrote, directed, and starred in ‘The Happy Prince’ as Oscar Wilde. His career has seen him excel in both comedic and tragic roles across film and theater. Everett is known for his dry wit and sophisticated screen persona. He continues to take on challenging roles that explore historical LGBTQ+ figures.

Alan Cumming

Alan Cumming is a dynamic Scottish actor known for his Tony-winning performance as the Emcee in ‘Cabaret’. On screen he is recognized for roles in ‘The Good Wife’ and ‘X2’. He brings a mischievous energy and emotional depth to his characters. Cumming is also a prolific author and host who engages with audiences across multiple mediums. His fearlessness in performance makes him a standout talent in the industry.

Billy Porter

Billy Porter achieved superstar status with his Emmy-winning role as Pray Tell in the drama series ‘Pose’. He is a veteran of Broadway with a Tony Award for his performance in ‘Kinky Boots’. His work often explores themes of identity, fashion, and resilience. Porter commands attention with his powerful voice and expressive acting style. He has become a cultural icon who challenges gender norms through his art.

Russell Tovey

Russell Tovey has built a diverse resume with roles in ‘Being Human’ and ‘Looking’. He delivered a standout performance in the dystopian drama ‘Years and Years’. His stage work includes the original production and film adaptation of ‘The History Boys’. Tovey specializes in playing grounded and relatable characters often dealing with extraordinary circumstances. He is a consistent performer who brings authenticity to British and American productions alike.

Murray Bartlett

Murray Bartlett experienced a career resurgence with his Emmy-winning role in the first season of ‘The White Lotus’. He followed this with a widely praised performance in the post-apocalyptic drama ‘The Last of Us’. His earlier work includes the series ‘Looking’ and ‘Tales of the City’. Bartlett acts with a raw vulnerability that critics and audiences find deeply compelling. He has quickly become a favorite for casting directors seeking complex character actors.

Harvey Guillén

Harvey Guillén stole scenes as the familiar Guillermo de la Cruz in the comedy series ‘What We Do in the Shadows’. He voices characters in major animated films like ‘Puss in Boots: The Last Wish’. His work highlights the importance of body positivity and representation in genre television. Guillén balances perfect comedic timing with genuine emotional beats. He is expanding his range with roles in thrillers and action projects.

BD Wong

BD Wong won a Tony Award for his Broadway debut in ‘M. Butterfly’ and is known for his role in ‘Jurassic Park’. He played Dr. George Huang for many years on ‘Law & Order: Special Victims Unit’. His recent role in ‘Mr. Robot’ allowed him to portray a complex transgender character with significant influence. Wong brings intelligence and precision to every character he plays. He remains a steadfast presence in television and film.

Nathan Lane

Nathan Lane is a comedic giant known for his voice work in ‘The Lion King’ and his role in ‘The Birdcage’. He holds three Tony Awards for his extensive work on Broadway. Recently he has taken on more dramatic television roles in shows like ‘Penny Dreadful: City of Angels’ and ‘Only Murders in the Building’. Lane possesses a rare ability to switch between slapstick comedy and serious drama. His timing and delivery are considered among the best in the business.

Cheyenne Jackson

Cheyenne Jackson transitioned from Broadway leading man to television star with roles in ’30 Rock’ and ‘American Horror Story’. He showcased his vocal talents in the musical film ‘Descendants 3’. His sitcom work includes the series ‘Call Me Kat’ where he played a charming love interest. Jackson brings a classic Hollywood quality to his modern roles. He is a versatile performer who works consistently across different mediums.

Denis O’Hare

Denis O’Hare is a prolific character actor known for his multiple distinct roles in the ‘American Horror Story’ anthology. He earned a Tony Award for his performance in the play ‘Take Me Out’. His television credits include significant arcs on ‘True Blood’ and ‘The Good Wife’. O’Hare disappears into his characters often using makeup and voice work to transform completely. He is highly respected by peers for his commitment to eccentricity and truth.

Robin de Jesús

Robin de Jesús has received three Tony Award nominations for his work in musicals like ‘In the Heights’. He gained film recognition for his spirited performance in ‘Tick, Tick… Boom!’ alongside Andrew Garfield. His role in ‘The Boys in the Band’ showcased his ability to handle rapid-fire dialogue and emotional breakdowns. De Jesús brings an electric energy to every scene he is in. He is a celebrated talent in the New York theater community transitioning successfully to screen.

Jeremy Pope

Jeremy Pope earned two Tony nominations in the same year for his work in ‘Choir Boy’ and ‘Ain’t Too Proud’. He received critical acclaim for his leading role in the film ‘The Inspection’. His television work includes a stylized performance in the miniseries ‘Hollywood’. Pope acts with a quiet intensity that draws the audience in. He is considered one of the most promising young actors working today.

Justice Smith

Justice Smith has led major films like ‘Detective Pikachu’ and ‘Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves’. He showed his dramatic chops in the romantic drama ‘All the Bright Places’. His role in ‘The Get Down’ highlighted his musical and lyrical abilities. Smith brings a natural charm and relatable anxiety to his younger roles. He is steadily building a filmography of diverse and high-profile projects.

Bowen Yang

Bowen Yang made history as a cast member on ‘Saturday Night Live’ where he is known for his scene-stealing characters. He starred in the romantic comedy ‘Fire Island’ which he also helped produce. His role in ‘Awkwafina Is Nora from Queens’ displays his dry comedic sensibility. Yang is a breakout star who brings a fresh and specifically queer perspective to mainstream comedy. He continues to push boundaries in sketch and narrative comedy.

Joel Kim Booster

Joel Kim Booster wrote and starred in the modern adaptation of Pride and Prejudice titled ‘Fire Island’. He is a stand-up comedian who acts in series like ‘Loot’ alongside Maya Rudolph. His writing and acting often dissect contemporary gay culture with sharp wit. Booster acts with a confident and relaxed energy that works well in ensembles. He is emerging as a significant voice in comedy and screenwriting.

Ben Platt

Ben Platt achieved massive success with his Tony-winning performance in ‘Dear Evan Hansen’. He reprised the role for the film adaptation and starred in the series ‘The Politician’. His vocal ability is central to many of his projects including the comedy ‘Theater Camp’. Platt plays anxious and ambitious characters with great specificity. He continues to release original music while pursuing acting roles.

Troye Sivan

Troye Sivan transitioned from a successful music career to acting with roles in ‘Boy Erased’ and ‘Three Months’. He recently appeared in the controversial series ‘The Idol’. His performance in ‘Boy Erased’ was praised for its quiet and heartbreaking realism. Sivan brings a naturalistic quality to his acting that complements his musical persona. He is effectively carving out a space for himself in independent cinema.

Ncuti Gatwa

Ncuti Gatwa became a global star with his role as Eric Effiong in the series ‘Sex Education’. He was recently cast as the lead in the long-running sci-fi series ‘Doctor Who’. His performance in ‘Sex Education’ earned him multiple BAFTA nominations for its humor and heart. Gatwa radiates charisma and joy in his performances. He is breaking barriers as one of the few black actors to lead a major British franchise.

Kit Connor

Kit Connor captured hearts as Nick Nelson in the hit series ‘Heartstopper’. He previously played a younger version of Elton John in ‘Rocketman’. His performance in ‘Heartstopper’ is praised for its sensitive portrayal of bisexual self-discovery. Connor acts with a maturity beyond his years. He has become a role model for young audiences navigating their own identities.

Joe Locke

Joe Locke made his professional acting debut as Charlie Spring in ‘Heartstopper’. He earned a leading role in the Marvel series ‘Agatha All Along’ shortly after his breakout. His chemistry with co-stars and natural vulnerability are his acting trademarks. Locke represents a new wave of talent that found success through streaming platforms. He is quickly proving his range beyond high school dramas.

Brian J. Smith

Brian J. Smith is best known for his role as Will Gorski in the sci-fi series ‘Sense8’. He earned a Tony nomination for his performance in ‘The Glass Menagerie’. His recent work includes roles in ‘Class of ’09’ and ‘Matrix Resurrections’. Smith brings an All-American toughness combined with emotional openness to his roles. He is a reliable actor for physical and demanding roles.

Michael Urie

Michael Urie is beloved for his role as Marc St. James in ‘Ugly Betty’. He is a staple of the New York theater scene with roles in ‘Torch Song’ and ‘Spamalot’. His recent film ‘Single All the Way’ was a popular holiday romantic comedy. Urie excels at fast-paced dialogue and physical comedy. He continues to be a favorite in both sitcoms and stage productions.

Dan Levy

Dan Levy created and starred in the cultural phenomenon ‘Schitt’s Creek’. He won multiple Emmy Awards for writing, directing, and acting in the series. His recent film ‘Good Grief’ showcased his ability to handle more somber material. Levy brings a distinct comedic voice and sartorial flair to his characters. He has established himself as a major creative force in television.

Charlie Carver

Charlie Carver often appears alongside his twin brother in projects like ‘Teen Wolf’ and ‘Desperate Housewives’. He delivered a strong solo performance in the film ‘The Boys in the Band’ and the series ‘Ratched’. His role in ‘The Batman’ allowed him to participate in a gritty superhero narrative. Carver acts with a quiet strength and intensity. He uses his platform to advocate for LGBTQ+ rights.

Luke Macfarlane

Luke Macfarlane was a regular on the drama ‘Brothers & Sisters’ and the sci-fi series ‘Killjoys’. He starred as the romantic lead in the major studio comedy ‘Bros’. His career includes numerous leading roles in Hallmark Channel movies. Macfarlane has a classic leading man charm that works in both drama and comedy. He is one of the few out actors consistently playing romantic leads in mainstream projects.

Andrew Rannells

Andrew Rannells broke out as a star in the original Broadway cast of ‘The Book of Mormon’. He became a television regular with his role in ‘Girls’ and ‘Black Monday’. His voice work includes the popular character Matthew in ‘Big Mouth’. Rannells is known for his sharp delivery and ability to play high-strung characters. He moves effortlessly between musical theater and television comedy.

Tituss Burgess

Tituss Burgess became a fan favorite as Titus Andromedon in ‘Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt’. He possesses a unique high tenor voice that he utilizes in both comedy and animation. His theater credits include roles in ‘The Little Mermaid’ and ‘Guys and Dolls’. Burgess brings a larger-than-life energy to his comedic roles. He is a standout performer who can elevate any scene he is in.

Guillermo Díaz

Guillermo Díaz is well known for his role as Huck in the political thriller ‘Scandal’. He played a memorable character in the cult classic film ‘Half Baked’. His recent work includes the sitcom ‘United We Fall’. Díaz excels at playing intense and sometimes dangerous characters who harbor deep loyalty. He is a versatile actor with a long list of credits in film and television.

Raúl Esparza

Raúl Esparza is a four-time Tony Award nominee known for his work in Sondheim musicals. He gained a wider audience as Rafael Barba in ‘Law & Order: Special Victims Unit’. His performance in ‘Hannibal’ showed his ability to play darker and more cynical roles. Esparza brings a cerebral and intense quality to his acting. He is regarded as one of the finest stage actors of his generation.

Victor Garber

Victor Garber is a veteran actor with a career spanning ‘Titanic’ to ‘Alias’. He played Dr. Martin Stein in the ‘Legends of Tomorrow’ superhero series. His stage work includes original roles in ‘Sweeney Todd’ and ‘Assassins’. Garber projects an air of authority and intelligence in his roles. He remains a highly respected figure in the industry with constant work.

Sean Hayes

Sean Hayes created the iconic character Jack McFarland in ‘Will & Grace’. He won a Tony Award for his lead performance in the play ‘Good Night, Oscar’. His producing credits include ‘Grimm’ and ‘Hot in Cleveland’. Hayes is a master of physical comedy and piano performance. He continues to challenge himself with dramatic stage roles while maintaining his comedic legacy.

John Benjamin Hickey

John Benjamin Hickey won a Tony Award for ‘The Normal Heart’ and starred in the series ‘The Big C’. He appeared in the recent horror film ‘Salem’s Lot’. His directing credits include the Broadway revival of ‘Plaza Suite’. Hickey brings a grounded and intellectual presence to his characters. He is a trusted character actor in both film and theater.

Wentworth Miller

Wentworth Miller became a global star as Michael Scofield in ‘Prison Break’. He later wrote the screenplay for the thriller ‘Stoker’ and appeared as Captain Cold in the Arrowverse. His recent work includes episodes of ‘Law & Order: Special Victims Unit’. Miller acts with a quiet intensity and intelligence. He has been open about his mental health and decision to stop playing straight characters.

Please leave a comment discussing which performance by these actors you believe is the most underrated.