The 35 Most Underrated Actresses of the 21st Century

The film and television industry is full of incredible talent but some performers do not always receive the widespread recognition they deserve despite their consistent excellence. These actresses have built impressive resumes by taking on challenging roles in both massive blockbusters and intimate independent features. While they may not always be the first names mentioned during award season they are often the most reliable part of any production they join. This list highlights those who have consistently delivered powerhouse performances throughout the twenty-first century without becoming household names for everyone.

Judy Greer

Judy Greer has appeared in dozens of films and television shows throughout her prolific career. She is frequently recognized for her work in popular comedies like ’13 Going on 30′ and ’27 Dresses’. Her voice acting skills are showcased in the animated series ‘Archer’ where she plays a major character. She has also taken on roles in blockbuster movies such as ‘Jurassic World’ and ‘Ant-Man’. Her ability to play both comedic sidekicks and dramatic characters makes her a staple of modern cinema.

Linda Cardellini

Linda Cardellini first gained recognition for her leading role in the cult classic series ‘Freaks and Geeks’. She later joined the cast of ‘ER’ and played a significant role in that medical drama for several seasons. Many fans also know her as Velma in the live action ‘Scooby-Doo’ movies. More recently she starred in the dark comedy series ‘Dead to Me’ alongside Christina Applegate. Her career spans multiple genres including superhero films where she appeared in ‘Avengers Age of Ultron’.

Juno Temple

Juno Temple has developed a reputation for taking on eccentric and diverse roles in both film and television. She gained widespread popularity for her role as Keeley Jones in the comedy series ‘Ted Lasso’. Her film credits include intense dramas such as ‘Killer Joe’ and ‘Atonement’. She has also appeared in large scale productions like ‘The Dark Knight Rises’ and ‘Maleficent’. Her unique energy and range allow her to disappear into every character she plays.

Kelly Macdonald

Kelly Macdonald first appeared in the classic film ‘Trainspotting’ before moving on to major international projects. She played a significant role in the historical drama ‘Boardwalk Empire’ for several years. Many viewers recognize her voice as the lead character in the animated movie ‘Brave’. She also starred in the acclaimed crime series ‘Line of Duty’ during its sixth season. Her career is marked by her quiet intensity and ability to ground even the most fantastical stories.

Gaby Hoffmann

Gaby Hoffmann was a prominent child actress before making a successful transition to adult roles in independent cinema. She received praise for her raw performance in the film ‘Crystal Fairy and the Magical Cactus’. Television audiences know her best for her roles in the series ‘Girls’ and ‘Transparent’. She has also appeared in the drama film ‘C’mon C’mon’ alongside Joaquin Phoenix. Her career is defined by her preference for challenging projects and unconventional characters.

Rosemarie DeWitt

Rosemarie DeWitt delivered a breakout performance in the independent film ‘Rachel Getting Married’. She has appeared in several acclaimed television series including ‘United States of Tara’ and ‘Mad Men’. Her film work includes a role in the remake of ‘Poltergeist’ as well as the drama ‘The Professor’. She often works in character-driven stories that emphasize emotional depth and realism. Her presence in a project often signals a high level of quality and thoughtful storytelling.

Melanie Lynskey

Melanie Lynskey began her career with a haunting performance in the film ‘Heavenly Creatures’. She became a household name for many through her long running role on the sitcom ‘Two and a Half Men’. Recently she has received significant praise for her leading role in the survival drama ‘Yellowjackets’. She also appeared in the film ‘I Don’t Feel at Home in This World Anymore’ which won a major festival award. Her career is defined by her ability to bring a unique vulnerability to every character she portrays.

Kathryn Hahn

Kathryn Hahn spent years as a reliable supporting actress before becoming a lead in major productions. She is well known for her comedic work in films like ‘Step Brothers’ and ‘Bad Moms’. Her performance in the series ‘WandaVision’ earned her widespread critical acclaim and a massive new following. She has also starred in more intimate projects like ‘Private Life’ and the series ‘Tiny Beautiful Things’. Her range allows her to shift from broad physical comedy to devastating emotional drama effortlessly.

Lake Bell

Lake Bell is a talented performer who has also made a name for herself as a writer and director. She wrote and starred in the film ‘In a World’ which explores the competitive industry of voice over acting. Many audiences recognize her from her work in the comedy series ‘Childrens Hospital’ and ‘Bless This Mess’. She has also lent her voice to animated projects like ‘The Secret Life of Pets’ and ‘Harley Quinn’. Her dedication to original storytelling has made her a unique voice in the entertainment industry.

Ruth Negga

Ruth Negga earned an Academy Award nomination for her role as Mildred Loving in the film ‘Loving’. She is also well known for playing Tulip O’Hare in the supernatural series ‘Preacher’. Her work in the film ‘Passing’ received praise for its subtlety and emotional depth. She has appeared in massive projects like ‘World War Z’ and ‘Ad Astra’ alongside major movie stars. Her stage and screen presence remains a powerful force in contemporary acting.

Riley Keough

Riley Keough has consistently chosen daring and artistic roles since the beginning of her career. She gained recognition for her leading role in the first season of the series ‘The Girlfriend Experience’. Her film credits include the vibrant road movie ‘American Honey’ and the psychological thriller ‘The Lodge’. Recently she starred as a rock singer in the miniseries ‘Daisy Jones and the Six’. Her ability to choose projects that challenge audience expectations has established her as a major talent.

Haley Bennett

Haley Bennett has appeared in a wide variety of films ranging from thrillers to period dramas. She played a significant role in ‘The Girl on the Train’ and starred in the western ‘The Magnificent Seven’. Her performance in the psychological drama ‘Swallow’ was highly praised for its intensity and restraint. She also appeared in the musical ‘Cyrano’ where she showcased her singing abilities. Her diverse filmography proves that she can handle lead roles in any genre.

Mary Elizabeth Winstead

Mary Elizabeth Winstead is often called a modern scream queen due to her roles in ‘Final Destination 3′ and ’10 Cloverfield Lane’. She gained a cult following for playing Ramona Flowers in ‘Scott Pilgrim vs. the World’. Her dramatic talent was highlighted in the independent film ‘Smashed’ and the third season of ‘Fargo’. Recently she joined the ‘Star Wars’ universe with a role in the series ‘Ahsoka’. She continues to be a favorite among fans of both genre films and prestige television.

Rebecca Hall

Rebecca Hall has built a career on intelligent and sophisticated performances in both blockbusters and independent films. She appeared in the psychological thriller ‘The Prestige’ and the superhero film ‘Iron Man 3’. In recent years she has taken on challenging roles in ‘Resurrection’ and ‘The Night House’. She also made her directorial debut with the film ‘Passing’ which received significant critical attention. Her range allows her to move seamlessly between intimate character studies and large scale entertainment.

Imogen Poots

Imogen Poots is a versatile actress who has appeared in everything from horror movies to Shakespearean adaptations. She caught the eye of audiences in the survival horror film ’28 Weeks Later’ and the thriller ‘Green Room’. Her work in ‘Vivarium’ and ‘The Art of Self-Defense’ showcased her talent for dark and surreal stories. She also had a recurring role in the series ‘Outer Range’ which blends western themes with science fiction. Her presence adds a layer of intelligence and grit to any project she joins.

Betty Gilpin

Betty Gilpin is perhaps best known for her role as Debbie Eagan in the wrestling series ‘GLOW’. She received multiple award nominations for her work on the show and showcased incredible physical and emotional range. She starred in the controversial thriller ‘The Hunt’ where she played a highly capable survivalist. Her work in the series ‘Mrs. Davis’ further cemented her reputation for playing strong and complex leads. She is frequently cited by critics as one of the most exciting performers of her generation.

Vicky Krieps

Vicky Krieps gained international recognition for her breakout performance in the film ‘Phantom Thread’. She held her own against veteran actors and received widespread praise for her subtle acting style. Since then she has starred in the historical drama ‘Corsage’ where she played the Empress of Austria. She also appeared in the mystery film ‘Old’ and the war drama ‘The Survivor’. Her career highlights her ability to bring depth to complex historical and modern figures.

Mackenzie Davis

Mackenzie Davis first caught the attention of critics in the technology drama series ‘Halt and Catch Fire’. She played a pivotal role in the science fiction sequel ‘Blade Runner 2049’ and the action film ‘Terminator Dark Fate’. Many fans recognize her from the celebrated ‘San Junipero’ episode of the anthology series ‘Black Mirror’. She also starred in the post apocalyptic miniseries ‘Station Eleven’ which highlighted her dramatic range. Her filmography shows a consistent interest in high concept storytelling and complex characters.

Carrie Coon

Carrie Coon is widely regarded as one of the most talented actresses working in television and theater today. She delivered a legendary performance in the series ‘The Leftovers’ and starred in the third season of ‘Fargo’. Her film work includes roles in ‘Gone Girl’ and ‘Ghostbusters Afterlife’. She currently plays a leading role in the period drama ‘The Gilded Age’ where she portrays a social climber. Her ability to convey deep emotion with minimal dialogue makes her a standout in every scene.

Cristin Milioti

Cristin Milioti became famous for her role as the mother in the long running sitcom ‘How I Met Your Mother’. She proved her leading lady status in the innovative romantic comedy ‘Palm Springs’. Her work in the dark comedy series ‘Made for Love’ and the thriller ‘The Resort’ showed her ability to balance humor and tension. She also earned praise for her role in the ‘USS Callister’ episode of ‘Black Mirror’. Her career is marked by her charm and her knack for choosing clever and high concept projects.

Jessie Buckley

Jessie Buckley has rapidly become one of the most sought after actresses in independent film. She delivered a breakthrough performance in ‘Wild Rose’ where she played a country singer from Scotland. Her roles in ‘I’m Thinking of Ending Things’ and ‘The Lost Daughter’ earned her widespread critical acclaim. She also starred in the horror film ‘Men’ and the historical drama series ‘Chernobyl’. Her raw talent and willingness to take on difficult roles have made her a favorite of many top directors.

Merritt Wever

Merritt Wever has won multiple Emmy Awards for her supporting roles in major television series. She delivered a memorable performance as the quirky Zoey Barkow in ‘Nurse Jackie’. In the miniseries ‘Unbelievable’ she played a dedicated detective investigating a complex case. She also appeared in the drama series ‘Godless’ where she portrayed a tough resident of a frontier town. Her ability to bring nuance and realism to every scene has made her a favorite among critics.

Katherine Waterston

Katherine Waterston first gained major attention for her role in the neo-noir film ‘Inherent Vice’. She transitioned to major franchises with roles in ‘Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them’ and ‘Alien Covenant’. Her work in independent films like ‘The World to Come’ has been praised for its emotional resonance. She also appeared in the series ‘Perry Mason’ and the historical epic ‘Babylon’. Her tall stature and expressive face make her a captivating presence on the big screen.

Bel Powley

Bel Powley gave a legendary performance in the coming of age film ‘The Diary of a Teenage Girl’. She has since appeared in various projects including the film ‘The King of Staten Island’ and the series ‘The Morning Show’. Her work in the miniseries ‘A Small Light’ as Miep Gies received significant praise for its historical weight. She often plays characters who are searching for their identity in complex social landscapes. Her career continues to grow as she takes on more diverse and leading roles.

Hong Chau

Hong Chau became a standout performer after her role in the science fiction film ‘Downsizing’. She received an Academy Award nomination for her performance in ‘The Whale’ where she played a supportive friend. Many viewers also recognize her from ‘The Menu’ and her role in the series ‘Watchmen’. Recently she appeared in the action thriller series ‘The Night Agent’ and the film ‘Asteroid City’. Her ability to command attention with a calm and precise delivery is a hallmark of her work.

Noomi Rapace

Noomi Rapace achieved international stardom for her role as Lisbeth Salander in ‘The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo’. She transitioned to Hollywood with major roles in ‘Sherlock Holmes A Game of Shadows’ and ‘Prometheus’. Her performance in the folk horror movie ‘Lamb’ showcased her ability to lead unique and unsettling stories. She often takes on physically demanding roles and has appeared in the action series ‘Jack Ryan’. Her commitment to intense character work has defined her diverse career.

Olivia Cooke

Olivia Cooke first made an impression on audiences in the psychological horror series ‘Bates Motel’. She played a leading role in the film ‘Me and Earl and the Dying Girl’ which won top honors at film festivals. Her career continued to grow with major roles in the science fiction movie ‘Ready Player One’ and the drama ‘Sound of Metal’. She currently stars as a central figure in the fantasy epic ‘House of the Dragon’. Her versatility has allowed her to move from independent dramas to massive television franchises seamlessly.

Mia Wasikowska

Mia Wasikowska became a global name after starring in the live action ‘Alice in Wonderland’ films. She has spent much of her career working with acclaimed directors on projects like ‘Stoker’ and ‘Crimson Peak’. Her performance in the film ‘Tracks’ showed her ability to carry a movie with very little dialogue. She also appeared in the gothic drama ‘Jane Eyre’ and the thriller ‘The Devil All the Time’. Her choice of roles often reflects an interest in dark and atmospheric storytelling.

Samantha Morton

Samantha Morton has been a powerhouse in the industry for years with two Academy Award nominations to her name. She appeared in the science fiction film ‘Minority Report’ and the musical ‘Sweet and Lowdown’. Television fans know her for playing the formidable villain Alpha in ‘The Walking Dead’. She also starred in the series ‘The Serpent Queen’ where she portrayed Catherine de Medici. Her career is a testament to her longevity and her ability to play both heroes and villains with equal conviction.

Tatiana Maslany

Tatiana Maslany became a critical darling for her work in the science fiction series ‘Orphan Black’. She played over a dozen different clones with distinct personalities and accents throughout the show. Her performance earned her an Emmy Award and multiple nominations from various organizations. She recently entered the superhero genre as the lead character in ‘She-Hulk Attorney at Law’. Her ability to embody multiple people within the same project remains a high point of modern television acting.

Regina Hall

Regina Hall is often associated with her comedic timing in films like ‘Girls Trip’ and the ‘Scary Movie’ franchise. She has recently expanded her career with powerful dramatic performances in films such as ‘Support the Girls’. Her work in the thriller ‘Master’ showcased her ability to lead a tense and atmospheric narrative. She also starred in the television series ‘Black Monday’ which highlighted her versatility in period pieces. Her talent for balancing comedy and drama ensures that she remains a prominent figure in the industry.

Andrea Riseborough

Andrea Riseborough is known for her complete physical and vocal transformations in every role she takes. She received an Academy Award nomination for her performance in the independent drama ‘To Leslie’. Her filmography includes a wide range of projects like the horror film ‘Mandy’ and the historical comedy ‘The Death of Stalin’. She also appeared in ‘Birdman’ and the series ‘ZeroZeroZero’. Her dedication to the craft of acting has earned her the respect of her peers and critics alike.

Rhea Seehorn

Rhea Seehorn earned critical acclaim for her portrayal of Kim Wexler in the series ‘Better Call Saul’. She spent several seasons developing one of the most complex and beloved characters on television. Her film work includes roles in the thriller ‘Linoleum’ and the horror movie ‘Things Heard and Seen’. She has also directed episodes of television and appeared in the comedy series ‘Veep’. Her dedicated fan base and industry respect reflect her status as a powerhouse performer.

Shohreh Aghdashloo

Shohreh Aghdashloo received an Academy Award nomination for her performance in the film ‘House of Sand and Fog’. She is perhaps best known for playing the powerful politician Chrisjen Avasarala in ‘The Expanse’. Her voice is recognizable in major projects like the animated series ‘Arcane’ and the ‘Mass Effect’ video games. She has also appeared in high profile films such as ‘Star Trek Beyond’ and ‘Renfield’. Her long career continues to bridge the gap between international cinema and Hollywood blockbusters.

Toni Collette

Toni Collette is frequently cited as one of the most versatile actresses of her generation. She gained international fame for her role in ‘The Sixth Sense’ and later starred in ‘Little Miss Sunshine’. Her performance in the horror film ‘Hereditary’ was widely praised for its emotional intensity. She has also found success on television in series like ‘United States of Tara’ and ‘The Staircase’. Her ability to transform into vastly different characters across genres is truly remarkable.

Tell us which actress you think deserves more time in the spotlight in the comments below!