Fans Slam Disney as Dwayne Johnson in ‘Moana’ Live Action Sparks Debate
The debut of the full trailer for the live-action reimagining of Moana on March 23 has sparked a wave of intense debate across social media. While many were excited to see the vibrant world of Motunui brought to life, a significant number of fans expressed immediate disappointment with Dwayne Johnson’s physical appearance as the demigod Maui.
Critics were particularly focused on the actor’s hair and the perceived lack of realism in his overall transformation for the role. Much of the online chatter centered on the wig chosen for Johnson, with fans accustomed to the actor’s signature bald look finding the change jarring.
“A non-bald Dwayne Johnson feels so wrong,” one social media user remarked shortly after the trailer’s release. Others felt the production quality was lacking, with another commentator adding, “It’s not that he isn’t bald. It’s that they made no effort to make that wig look good.”
New look at Dwayne Johnson as Maui on the set of Disney’s new live-action ‘Moana’ film. pic.twitter.com/9nneGbVhxe
— Creepy.org (@creepydotorg) November 21, 2024
The criticism didn’t stop at the hair, as some viewers questioned the very necessity of the live-action translation. One frustrated fan described the look as “a cosplay gone wrong,” while others pointed out a perceived lack of resemblance to the original animated character.
“Besides the tattoo, where is the resemblance?” asked one critic while comparing side-by-side images of the 2016 version and the new footage. A major point of contention involved the reveal that Johnson utilized a bodysuit to achieve Maui’s massive, god-like proportions rather than gaining the weight naturally.
Paparazzi photos from the Hawaii set previously hinted at a “visible zip” near the actor’s neckline, leading to accusations that he had not fully committed to the physical demands of the part. “The neckline at the necklace is a giveaway,” a observer noted, suggesting the “borrowed muscles” were too obvious to ignore.
Animation ➡️ Live-Action.
— Nexus Point News (@NexusPointNews) March 23, 2026
Dwayne Johnson as Maui in the live-action ‘MOANA’.
In theaters July 10. pic.twitter.com/KTEAxi4FBv
Johnson, however, has defended the work of Oscar-winning makeup artist Joel Harlow, who designed the intricate suit. The actor previously shared that the transformation process was lengthy and expressed pride that the suit was convincing enough to fool some onlookers.
“That’s a suit that took a long time to put on. I’m so happy that you said, ‘You bulked up,’ because when you said, ‘You bulked up,’ that means you couldn’t tell,” Johnson explained in a previous interview. The film’s titular star, Catherine Laga‘aia, has also faced scrutiny since her casting was first teased in late 2024.
Fans of the original animated masterpiece observed that the new actress’s hair appeared much straighter and more polished than the natural, salt-water curls seen in the 2016 film.
“How do they think someone who lives on an island with saltwater and no electricity would have hair that looks blow-dried like that?” one skeptic asked, questioning Disney’s commitment to authentic representation. Despite the backlash, the live-action Moana remains one of the most anticipated releases for the summer of this year, with a scheduled debut on July 10.
The film is directed by Thomas Kail and features a screenplay that aims to expand on the beloved mythology while maintaining the musical spirit of the original. Catherine Laga‘aia, daughter of Jay Laga‘aia, steps into the role previously voiced by Auli‘i Cravalho, who serves as an executive producer on the project.
Dwayne Johnson remains incredibly busy outside of his journey across the sea, as he recently starred in The Smashing Machine. In that A24 biographical drama, he portrays MMA legend Mark Kerr, a role that required a complete physical overhaul and the use of facial prosthetics.
As the July release date approaches, the production team will likely be keeping a close eye on audience feedback regarding the visual effects and character designs. Whether the film can overcome its early “cringe” labels and capture the magic of the original remains to be seen.
Have something to add? Share your thoughts in the comments.