‘Treasure Island’ Season 2 Odds Look Uncertain as the MGM+ Series Reaches Its Finale
The MGM+ adaptation of ‘Treasure Island’ reaches its finale on Sunday at 10pm, with David Oyelowo, Hayley Atwell, Jack Huston, Tomer Capone and Tom Sweet leading the cast. The series premiered on October 11 and has released new episodes on Sundays since then. With the final chapter arriving, attention turns to what comes next for the production.
The question of a ‘Treasure Island’ second season is not a simple one. The reporting around the show points toward a defined run, and my searches turned up no renewal announcement from MGM+ or Paramount+. What follows looks at what has been confirmed, what the format suggests and what a return could realistically involve.
‘Treasure Island’ Renewal Status and What Has Been Announced
As of this finale, no renewal announcement has surfaced in the sources reviewed for this piece. Neither MGM+ nor Paramount+ has publicly committed to further episodes, and nothing found points to a production schedule. That absence matters, since networks tend to announce a return before or shortly after a finale airs.
The language used around the finale is mixed. BroadwayWorld described the final episodes as a series finale and noted that they air Sundays at 10:00 pm ET/PT on MGM+. Stay Tuned also listed the Sunday episode as a series finale. A Forbes weekend viewing guide, by contrast, lists it as a season finale.
The business structure also complicates any decision. Deadline reported that the show is a Paramount+ original series in association with MGM+ and Fifth Season, with Playground producing. Variety added that Fifth Season handles global distribution outside the United States, the United Kingdom and Ireland. Any further episodes would need several partners to agree.
Why the Six Episode Format Suggests a Limited Series
Variety reported in an exclusive that MGM+ and Paramount+ commissioned the production as a six part series inspired by Robert Louis Stevenson’s epic. That framing from the outset suggests the creative team planned a contained story rather than the opening chapter of a multi season saga. It is a reading of the commissioning language, not a confirmed statement of intent.
The series consists of six episodes, premiering on MGM+ in the United States on October 11 and on Paramount+ in the United Kingdom and Ireland the following day, with weekly releases running through November 15 and 16. The release pattern matches a single, tightly scheduled run. Nothing in that schedule hints at a split season or a planned continuation.
The official synopsis centers on teenager Jim Hawkins and his mother Bess being pulled into a deadly race for Captain Flint’s treasure, with Long John Silver and the revolutionary spy Aaron Graham battling for control. The story is set in 1788 across Cornwall, the sea and a jungle island. A treasure hunt with stakes that clear tends to resolve within one run, which makes a straightforward sequel harder to build.
Critical Reception and Its Effect on a Possible Return
Early reception has not helped the case for more episodes. A Forbes weekend guide said the series is faring poorly with critics and audiences. The same writer found some enjoyable pirate material but called it a show many viewers could skip.
A good deal of that criticism centers on a single creative choice. The Forbes writer questioned the decision to make Jim’s mother a main protagonist. Atwell has described that as the biggest difference from the book, arguing that her character’s screen time helps explain Jim’s origin story.
One review is not a verdict, and the coverage reviewed includes no viewership figures. That leaves the commercial case for a return unclear. Without public numbers, any claim that the show is succeeding or failing financially would be speculation.
Where a Long John Silver Story Could Go Next
If the creators did return, the strongest material may be the reimagined Long John Silver. In an interview with ScreenRant, Oyelowo explained that his formerly enslaved version of the character sees the treasure as freedom and empowerment rather than greed. That idea gives the character a motivation that could carry beyond a single voyage.
The competition is also worth noting. A separate feature film from Ridley Scott is set to star Hugh Jackman as Long John Silver, and the MGM+ series arrives ahead of it. Two adaptations of the same novel in a short window could shape how much appetite exists for further episodes of this version.
MGM+ global head Michael Wright called the adaptation a perfect expression of the network’s brand when it was announced. That enthusiasm is on record, though it does not amount to a renewal. For now, a second season remains possible but unconfirmed, so do you want to see Oyelowo’s Long John Silver and Atwell’s Bess Hawkins sail again, or does this ‘Treasure Island’ work best as a single voyage, and what would you want a second season to explore?
