Movies Like Netflix’s ‘Guarding Stars’ for Fans of Fake Dating Romance
Netflix’s ‘Guarding Stars’ arrived on November 18 as a holiday romantic comedy starring Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki. Meester plays Hannah Brooks, a bodyguard assigned to protect a star named Jack Stapleton, played by Padalecki. The film was directed by Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum and adapted from a novel by Katherine Center.
The story sends a bodyguard to a Montana ranch with the famous actor she is protecting, where posing as a couple for Christmas sparks a real romance. That fake dating plot flips the script on the typical bodyguard romance. Viewers looking for movies like Netflix ‘Guarding Stars’ have plenty to choose from, since the fake relationship trope never seems to get old.
‘The Decoy Bride’

This British romantic comedy follows an American movie star, played by Alice Eve, who plans a perfect wedding to an English author played by David Tennant. Paparazzi keep hounding the couple, so their manager has a local assistant, played by Kelly Macdonald, pose as a decoy bride. Things shift when the author and the decoy bride begin to fall for one another, and the chemistry between Tennant and Macdonald lifts the film into a hidden gem. The fame angle makes it the closest match to Jack’s world in ‘Guarding Stars’.
‘Picture Perfect’

Jennifer Aniston plays a young advertising executive who pretends to be engaged to a man she just met, played by Jay Mohr, in order to impress her boss. The plan grows complicated when Sam, played by Kevin Bacon, starts to see through the scheme. Bacon’s presence as a wild card gives the film its edge and stakes.
‘Blended’

Drew Barrymore and Adam Sandler play Lauren and Jim, who meet on a blind date that goes horribly wrong. When they and their kids end up at the same resort in Africa, they fake a relationship to get the last remaining suite. The film also adds a fake family, and the history between its leads gives their banter an easy, natural feel.
‘Failure to Launch’

Parents hire a specialist named Paula, played by Sarah Jessica Parker, to date their thirty something son Tripp, played by Matthew McConaughey, so he will finally move out. Plans go sideways as each person foils the other’s plotting, which complicates the one sided setup. The chemistry between McConaughey and Parker is undeniable even when it begins in frustration.
‘No Hard Feelings’

Parents hire a woman to push their socially awkward son Percy, played by Andrew Barth Feldman, toward independence. Maddie, played by Jennifer Lawrence, is not a professional and simply needs a car for work. Coming of age elements give the story heart and balance the crude, absurd comedy.
‘Easy A’

Emma Stone plays Olive, a straight A student whose little white lie gets out of hand. She ends up building a business around fake relationships, and Stone’s performance grows more vulnerable as the consequences land. The film is treated as a staple of the genre and one of its more ingenious takes on the trope.
‘The Perfect Date’

Noah Centineo plays Brooks, a high school senior who cannot afford Yale. He agrees to pretend to be Celia’s boyfriend, played by Laura Marano, and then develops an app that lets him be a plus one for other girls. When Celia and Brooks plan one last date to make their crushes jealous, they realize their affections may have found a new focus.
‘Moonshot’

This film gives the fake dating concept a science fiction twist. Two college students who both want to travel to Mars sneak aboard a space shuttle to reunite with their significant others, and they must pose as lovers on the way. The awkward complications begin when they start to fall for one another.
‘Dating Amber’

This film takes a friendship oriented approach to the idea. Social outcasts Eddie and Amber stage a relationship to squash rumors about their sexuality, but Amber soon notices Eddie’s denial and feels she has to act. What starts as a quirky coming of age romance becomes a story about self acceptance and being one’s authentic self. Anyone who watched Hannah and Jack sell a Christmas romance to a Montana ranch might tell us in the comments which of these pretend couples made their story the most believable.
