Luke Grimes Admits He Couldn’t Picture ‘Marshals’ Without Kelsey Asbille’s Monica
Luke Grimes has spent years as Kayce Dutton, and taking the character into the ‘Yellowstone’ spinoff ‘Marshals’ meant making one very big adjustment. The new series moved Kayce into a different chapter of his life without his on-screen wife at his side. Now Grimes is being candid about how difficult that change was for him.
The spinoff gave Kayce a fresh start. ‘Marshals’ follows Kayce Dutton, the youngest son of the Dutton family, as he leaves ranch life behind and becomes a U.S. Marshal in rural Montana after the events of ‘Yellowstone’. But that new beginning came with a heartbreaking twist. At the start of the series, which takes place chronologically after ‘Yellowstone’ Season 5, Kayce reveals that he lost his wife, Monica, played by Asbille, to illness.
Grimes didn’t hold back about how much that decision weighed on him. “The thing I was most worried about doing ‘Marshals’ was doing it without Kelsey. That’s legitimate. Like I just couldn’t wrap my head around Kayce without Monica. That was the story,” Grimes told Screen Rant.
He also explained why Monica mattered so much to his version of the character. “The rest of ‘Yellowstone’ was about people fighting over land, and I just loved my wife,” he said. That sums up why Monica’s absence feels so significant to fans of the original series.
Over time, though, Grimes came to see the change differently. “But then once I sort of, you know, could wrap my head around the fact that that was going to open up all these new storylines, like, we just have to make sure we do honor that and don’t try to skip over it or pretend it didn’t happen,” he continued.
The series has tried to give Monica a proper goodbye. A season 1 ceremony honored Monica, and Grimes says Kayce can now “lay that to rest.” Even so, the grief hasn’t disappeared overnight. Kayce still wears his ring, and Grimes and the showrunner are still deciding when it comes off.
From the world of Yellowstone. Watch the official trailer for #Marshals. Premieres March 1 on CBS and streaming on Paramount+. https://t.co/nfCAfteGjt
— Movie Coverage (@MovieCoverage_) January 26, 2026
It’s a family story as well. ‘Marshals’ picks up after the events of ‘Yellowstone’, with Kayce and his son, Tate, grieving Monica’s death. Brecken Merrill, Mo Brings Plenty, and Gil Birmingham reprise their ‘Yellowstone’ roles alongside Grimes.
Fans have started looking at Kayce’s future, and much of the attention has fallen on his fellow marshal Andrea Cruz, played by Ash Santos. Grimes says the “will-they-won’t-they” is “meant to feel that way,” and that the pair are building a friendship first. He also admitted he doesn’t know where it’s going.

Santos has her own theory about why viewers are so invested. She believes slow-burn romance like this is rare on TV now, which explains the strong fan response. The story has also moved Andrea closer to Kayce’s world. She planned to transfer to Washington, D.C., at the end of season 1 but stayed in Montana, partly because of Kayce.
Another possible love interest has already been written out. Kayce’s earlier potential romance, Dolly Weaver, left in the season 2 premiere, when her father Tom was revealed as a villain.
#Yellowstone finale trailer I truly can’t wait. I’m intrigued beyond measure https://t.co/61yoIWyUQX
— Vine.Park 🇨🇦🎙️ (@VineParkMedia) December 9, 2024
The ‘Yellowstone’ fandom hasn’t reached a consensus. Some see Kayce and Andrea as a more logical match than Kayce and Dolly. Others object to romance among team members, dislike Andrea’s attitude, want Monica back, or say it’s too soon after Monica’s death.
The debate doesn’t seem to be hurting the show’s numbers. Season 2 premiered October 4 with 8.2 million viewers on CBS and 20 million across all platforms. New episodes air Sundays at 8 p.m. ET on CBS and Paramount+.

Grimes’ honesty shows how seriously he takes Kayce’s emotional journey. Instead of brushing past Monica’s loss, the show appears committed to letting it shape the character as he slowly figures out what comes next.
Do you think Marshals made the right decision by moving Kayce's story forward without Monica?
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!
