Hunter Schafer Drops a Telling Hint About Her Action Future Amid Mystique Buzz
Few casting questions in superhero fandom have lingered as long as who will pick up the shapeshifting mantle of Mystique. Rebecca Romijn played the character in the first ‘X-Men’ trilogy, and Jennifer Lawrence took over in the series that followed. Now that Marvel Studios is rebuilding its mutant roster, the search for a fresh Raven Darkhölme has become one of the internet’s favorite guessing games.
One name has floated to the top of that conversation again and again. Hunter Schafer was a popular fan pick for the role ever since her breakout in ‘Euphoria’, and the buzz has only grown since. Her screen résumé, which also includes ‘The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes’ and ‘Cuckoo’, has only fueled the speculation.
Her latest comments have now added another log to the fire. According to a post from DiscussingFilm, citing Metro, Schafer says she would be interested in playing Mystique in the MCU. When the topic came up, she kept things loose but optimistic, saying, “I hope I get to do more action in the future,” before adding that “whatever it is, I’m looking forward to it.”
It is not a confirmation, and it is certainly not a coy wink from a signed contract. But it fits a pattern of warmth toward the idea. When Entertainment Tonight asked about the Mystique fan casting in February 2025, Schafer acknowledged seeing the online campaign and responded positively. She even joked that her dad had texted her about it.
The rumor trail behind her has been long and bumpy. A scooper known as MTTSH first claimed in February 2025 that she was being eyed for the part, and the same account said in April 2026 that she was “still being considered.” Then, earlier this month, another insider, James Mack, claimed she had been in serious talks with Marvel Studios, pointing to a detail that Mystique “will be 5’10” tall in the MCU,” which happens to match Schafer’s height.
Not everyone is convinced the story adds up. At D23, Marvel named seven X-Men actors, and Mystique was not among them, though Kevin Feige said more casting is still to come. One critique of the rumor mill noted that the Schafer story rests on just two data points, both from a single account.
Meanwhile, the plot has thickened in the past few days. A new report claims ‘The Haunting of Bly Manor’ star Victoria Pedretti is in the running for the role, potentially replacing Schafer as the frontrunner in Jake Schreier’s ‘X-Men’. Like everything else in this saga, that remains unconfirmed.
What is clear is that fans have not been shy about their preferences. When Marvel revealed its first round of casting and Mystique was missing, social media flooded with Schafer edits, and TikTok users joined in too. Reaction to her rumored casting has been mostly positive, although some fans have pushed for other actors instead.
There is also a bit of irony in how the casting story has unfolded. Marvel’s only Mystique-adjacent move so far has been casting Inde Navarrette as Rogue, Mystique’s adopted daughter, even though she had publicly campaigned for Mystique herself. Romijn’s version of the character is also set to get a send-off in ‘Avengers: Doomsday’ in December, which could clear the stage for a new face.
For now, Marvel has confirmed nothing, so the Schafer-as-Mystique story stays firmly in the rumor category. Still, an actor openly hoping for more action roles, a studio with a major villain slot to fill, and a fandom that will not let go of a fancast make for a combination that is hard to ignore. Until Marvel finally reveals its Mystique, expect Schafer’s name to keep coming up.
