Movies Like ‘Paper Tiger’ for Viewers Drawn to Brotherhood and the Russian Mob
‘Paper Tiger’ opened in select theaters this month ahead of its nationwide release, and it has left many viewers looking for movies like ‘Paper Tiger’ to watch next. James Gray’s crime drama stars Adam Driver as former police officer Gary Pearl and Miles Teller as his brother Irwin, whose hopes for financial stability draw them into a business scheme tied to the Russian mafia.
The story unfolds in 1986 New York and follows an ordinary Queens family that runs afoul of the Russian mob. One critic said it recalls the great 1970s films that examined the flaws in the American Dream. That mix of family pressure, neighborhood crime and period atmosphere points toward Gray’s own earlier work, other Russian mob stories and several classic New York crime dramas.
‘Little Odessa’

Gray’s debut is the obvious place to start. Tim Roth plays Joshua, a hit man banished by his father who is forced back to Brighton Beach, a south Brooklyn neighborhood rebuilt by the Russian American Jewish community. The Cannes Film Festival described ‘Paper Tiger’ as a return to that same community, geography and set of themes around guilt and loyalty. The earlier film also won the Silver Lion at Venice.
‘The Yards’

Gray’s second feature works as a close companion piece. Leo Handler returns home after prison and gets pulled into the corrupt railway business, where the people closest to him are tied to a dangerous network of criminal activity. A review on RogerEbert.com notes it is one of two earlier Gray films involving Russian crime syndicate members in New York. Like ‘Paper Tiger’, it explores working class New York, family ties and questionable business arrangements.
‘We Own the Night’

Bobby Green manages a nightclub while his family has strong ties to law enforcement, and circumstances eventually push him into a difficult position involving the Russian mafia. The AV Club connected the abandonment Teller’s character feels in ‘Paper Tiger’ to the betrayal Joaquin Phoenix’s character carries after his family is targeted here. A separate retrospective described it as an expansion of the moods and themes in Gray’s first two films.
‘Eastern Promises’

For the Russian mob angle alone, this one belongs on any watchlist. David Cronenberg directed it, and it can be brutal, with a grim intensity built around violence and revenge. Anna, a London midwife, finds a young woman’s diary and is led toward a dangerous Russian criminal organization, while Nikolai, a mysterious driver, keeps his true loyalties in question.
‘A Most Violent Year’

Set in New York in 1981, the film follows Abel Morales, who tries to expand his heating oil company without giving up his principles in an increasingly corrupt environment. As in ‘Paper Tiger’, a business opportunity gradually turns dangerous for an ambitious man trying to protect his family, and the suspense stays restrained.
‘The French Connection’

Two New York detectives, Jimmy Doyle and Buddy Russo, pursue an international drug smuggling operation in a gritty urban setting grounded in realism. The film comes from the early 1970s, which suits the throwback quality critics noticed in ‘Paper Tiger’. It shares an interest in how seemingly unconnected people and businesses become part of much larger criminal operations.
‘Mean Streets’

Martin Scorsese’s drama follows Charlie, who tries to balance his place in Little Italy’s criminal community with hopes of a better future, while his unpredictable friend Johnny Boy keeps complicating those plans. Its character driven approach understands that criminal involvement rarely stays separate from family and everyday life.
‘Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead’

Two brothers plan a robbery at their parents’ jewelry shop to solve their financial problems, and the fallout reaches their family in ways neither anticipated. Sibling relationships sit at the center of the criminal storyline, just as they do in ‘Paper Tiger’, and both films show how money trouble and poor judgment can endanger a whole family.
‘Carlito’s Way’

Carlito Brigante is released from prison and wants a legitimate future, but his old connections make escaping his past far harder than he expected. The film shares the struggle between personal ambition, close relationships and criminal associations, and it carries the same reminder that good intentions do not erase earlier decisions.
Which of these films comes closest to the bond between Gary and Irwin Pearl, and did any of them leave you with the same dread that followed Irwin’s first misstep with the Russian mob?
