15 Actors Perfect for the Role of Plastic Man in the DCU

Plastic Man began as Eel O Brian in the pages of Quality Comics before joining DC, with a debut that goes back to the early forties. The character blends elastic powers with a con artist past, a fast mouth, and a talent for visual gags that play off wild shape shifting. Casting the part works best with performers who bring strong physical comedy, improvisation skill, and proven experience in voice work or stunt heavy projects.

The DCU is building out a new slate of films and shows, and Plastic Man fits well beside larger heroes because his stories often move between crime capers and full scale superhero action. Actors who have anchored sketch series, animated hits, or genre comedies usually come in with training that covers pratfalls, quick timing, and the ability to sell exaggerated movement on set or in the booth.

Jim Carrey

Jim Carrey broke out on ‘In Living Color’ and followed with a run of high energy hits that included ‘Ace Ventura Pet Detective’, ‘The Mask’, ‘Liar Liar’, and ‘The Truman Show’. He later added dramatic work with films like ‘Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind’ while keeping a reputation for extreme facial control and broad physical bits across decades.

He has played comic book and game based characters with roles such as the Riddler in ‘Batman Forever’ and Doctor Robotnik in ‘Sonic the Hedgehog’. Carrey also headlined the series ‘Kidding’, which mixed visual trickery with character work that relied on precise movement and timing.

Ben Schwartz

Ben Schwartz trained and performed at Upright Citizens Brigade and appeared on ‘Parks and Recreation’ and ‘House of Lies’. He won a Primetime Emmy for writing on the Academy Awards broadcast and has built a steady career that blends acting, writing, and live improv shows.

He voices Sonic in ‘Sonic the Hedgehog’ and has major animation credits that include ‘DuckTales’ and ‘Rise of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles’. Schwartz frequently records multiple characters in a single session, which shows range that translates well to exaggerated reactions and fast switches between tones.

Bill Hader

Bill Hader spent years on ‘Saturday Night Live’ creating characters that required quick physical shifts and precise vocal control. He co created and starred in ‘Barry’, earning awards for a series that balanced dark crime stories with tightly choreographed action.

His voice work covers films such as ‘Inside Out’, ‘Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs’, and ‘Monsters University’. Hader also contributed vocal effects to ‘The Force Awakens’, which reflects a technical comfort in the recording booth that supports animation heavy or effects driven projects.

Andy Samberg

Andy Samberg rose through ‘Saturday Night Live’ with The Lonely Island, building digital shorts that relied on timing and exaggerated visuals. He led films such as ‘Hot Rod’ and ‘Palm Springs’, both of which asked for committed physical bits alongside rapid fire dialogue.

He voices characters in ‘Hotel Transylvania’ and other animated projects and often records musical comedy that requires tight rhythmic delivery. Samberg brings experience with stunt coordination on comedy sets where falls, flips, and quick cuts are central to the joke structure.

Keegan Michael Key

Keegan Michael Key built a national following with ‘Key and Peele’, a sketch series that demanded major physical variety from scene to scene. He trained at The Second City and has worked across stage and screen with a focus on character voices and heightened movement.

His credits include animation like ‘Toy Story 4’ and family adventure releases that call for quick turns between broad humor and sincere beats. Key also starred in the musical comedy ‘Schmigadoon’, which demonstrates breath control and body awareness that support large gestures and elastic reactions.

Charlie Day

Charlie Day has produced, written, and starred on ‘It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia’ for many seasons, which requires high energy ensemble work and frequent physical bits. His film roles include ‘Pacific Rim’ and ‘Monsters University’, which mix genre scale with comedy timing.

He voices Benny in ‘The Lego Movie’ and plays Luigi in ‘The Super Mario Bros Movie’. Day often records overlapping dialogue with co stars, a setup that trains fast responses and clear articulation in chaotic scenes that mirror effects heavy sequences.

Jack Quaid

Jack Quaid plays Hughie on ‘The Boys’, which blends superhero scale with grounded reactions that have to land amid complex stunt setups. His film work includes ‘Scream’ and ‘Oppenheimer’, adding large production experience to a resume built on genre projects.

He voices Brad Boimler on ‘Star Trek Lower Decks’ and Clark Kent in ‘My Adventures with Superman’. Quaid’s animation work shows comfort with vocal exaggeration and quick emotional shifts, useful when scenes rely on body warps and sight gags that are added in post.

Daniel Radcliffe

Daniel Radcliffe led the ‘Harry Potter’ series from childhood through adulthood and then moved into eclectic films like ‘Swiss Army Man’. He has trained extensively for stage projects, which require clear projection, physical precision, and repeatable choreography.

He starred in the anthology series ‘Miracle Workers’ where each season changed setting and character type, demonstrating range with accents and movement styles. Radcliffe also took on action driven fare such as ‘Guns Akimbo’, which added weapons handling and frantic chase work to his skill set.

Jason Sudeikis

Jason Sudeikis performed on ‘Saturday Night Live’ and later headlined ‘Ted Lasso’, which draws on physical bits during training and match sequences along with long dialogue scenes. His film roles include ‘Horrible Bosses’ and ‘We’re the Millers’, both shot with large ensemble casts and set piece gags.

Sudeikis often serves as writer or producer on projects, which adds experience with planning visual jokes during pre production. He also works regularly in voice roles, including guest turns on animated series where flexible vocal delivery supports broad reactions.

Jason Mantzoukas

Jason Mantzoukas became widely known for ‘The League’ and has appeared on ‘The Good Place’ and ‘Big Mouth’. His live improv background includes long form shows that push quick pivots and outsized reactions while keeping scenes grounded in a clear game.

He has voice roles in ‘The Lego Batman Movie’, ‘Big Mouth’, and ‘Invincible’, where sessions often require rapid switches between shouting, whispers, and unusual sounds. Mantzoukas regularly records additional dialogue for action scenes, which fits the needs of effects heavy sequences.

Thomas Middleditch

Thomas Middleditch starred on ‘Silicon Valley’ and built a reputation for precise awkward physical beats that land cleanly on camera. He has led live improv specials and toured with shows that rely on audience prompts and sustained movement.

His credits include ‘Search Party’ and the stage and streaming project ‘Middleditch and Schwartz’. Middleditch also voices characters in ‘Solar Opposites’, which involves exaggerated reactions and elastic line readings that match animated action.

Adam Pally

Adam Pally broke through on ‘Happy Endings’ and added a long run on ‘The Mindy Project’, two series that feature overlapping dialogue and quick physical bits. He has appeared in large scale productions with action elements, including ‘Iron Man 3’.

Pally shows up in ‘Sonic the Hedgehog’ and related projects, which gave him time on sets where performers act to stand in effects and complex tracking. He trained and performed with Upright Citizens Brigade, which centers on bodily commitment and strong character game.

John Mulaney

John Mulaney wrote for ‘Saturday Night Live’ and created character driven sketches that relied on clean physical setups and precise rhythms. He tours as a stand up and has headlined specials that feature extended act outs that require controlled movement and breath.

He voices Andrew on ‘Big Mouth’ and has recurring roles on ‘Documentary Now’ and other shows that use mock documentary staging. Mulaney performs musical numbers on television and on stage, which supports body control and timing in scenes with big physical beats.

Alan Tudyk

Alan Tudyk starred in ‘Firefly’ and returned for ‘Serenity’, bringing experience with wire work and ensemble action to science fiction projects. He has a wide range of Disney voice roles including ‘Moana’, ‘Frozen’, and ‘Aladdin’, often providing unique sounds and character voices within the same film.

In DC projects he plays Mr Nobody on ‘Doom Patrol’ and multiple characters on ‘Harley Quinn’. Tudyk records creature sounds and comedic voices across series and games, which shows comfort with extreme vocal shapes that line up with elastic visual effects.

Rahul Kohli

Rahul Kohli co starred on ‘iZombie’, which mixed procedural stories with comedic set pieces and frequent stunt driven sequences. He later appeared in ‘The Haunting of Bly Manor’ and ‘Midnight Mass’, adding dramatic range in projects that require precise physical stillness and controlled movement.

He has voiced characters on ‘Harley Quinn’ and participates in game focused streams and projects that involve voice sessions and motion driven performances. Kohli’s work across horror, comedy, and animation places him on sets that balance quick tonal shifts with clear physical choices.

Share the name you would pick for Plastic Man in the comments so we can compare notes.