Amanda Seyfried’s Best Roles

Amanda Seyfried began her career as a model before transitioning to acting in television soap operas, but she became a household name with her scene-stealing role in a hit teen comedy. That memorable performance launched a career that has been defined by its impressive range and fearlessness. She quickly proved she was more than just a comedic talent, taking on roles in musicals, romantic dramas, and intense thrillers that showcased her versatility as a performer.

Over the years, Seyfried has established herself as one of her generation’s most compelling actresses, known for her expressive eyes and her ability to convey deep vulnerability and strength. She has worked with celebrated directors and has consistently chosen interesting and challenging projects that push her boundaries. From blockbuster musicals to quiet independent films and award-winning television series, she has built a rich and varied body of work.

‘Dear John’ (2010)

In this romantic drama, Amanda Seyfried plays Savannah Curtis, a compassionate college student on spring break. She meets John Tyree, a soldier on leave, and the two fall deeply in love over the course of two weeks. Their romance is tested when John reenlists after the September 11th attacks, and they must maintain their relationship through a series of letters.

The film is based on a novel of the same name and explores themes of love, duty, and the challenges of long-distance relationships. Seyfried’s character is the emotional heart of the story, as she navigates her life at home while waiting for the man she loves to return from war. Her performance captures the hope and heartbreak inherent in the film’s premise.

‘Letters to Juliet’ (2010)

Amanda Seyfried stars as Sophie Hall, a young American woman who works as a fact-checker for a magazine. While on a pre-honeymoon trip to Verona, Italy, with her distracted fiancé, she discovers a group of volunteers who respond to letters written to Shakespeare’s Juliet. Sophie finds an unanswered letter from 1957 and decides to write back to its author.

Her response inspires the letter’s now-elderly author to travel to Italy in search of her long-lost love, and Sophie joins her on the journey. The film is a lighthearted romantic adventure set against the picturesque backdrop of the Italian countryside. Seyfried’s character drives the narrative as her journalistic instincts and romantic spirit lead to a quest for true love.

‘Mamma Mia!’ (2008)

In this blockbuster movie musical, Amanda Seyfried plays Sophie Sheridan, a young woman preparing for her wedding on a beautiful Greek island. Raised by her single mother, Donna, Sophie has never known the identity of her father. After finding her mother’s old diary, she secretly invites three men from her mother’s past to the wedding, hoping to discover which one is her dad.

The film is based on the popular stage musical of the same name and features the music of the pop group ABBA. Seyfried performed all of her own singing for the role, showcasing her musical talents to a global audience for the first time. Her performance as the bright and curious Sophie is central to the film’s joyful and energetic story.

‘In Time’ (2011)

This science fiction action film is set in a future where time has become the ultimate currency. People are genetically engineered to stop aging at 25, but they must earn more time to stay alive, while the rich can essentially live forever. Amanda Seyfried plays Sylvia Weis, the daughter of an unimaginably wealthy man who has never had to worry about her time running out.

Her sheltered life is turned upside down when she is taken hostage by a man from the ghettos who is fighting against the corrupt system. She soon becomes his accomplice in a plan to redistribute wealth from the rich to the poor. Seyfried’s character transforms from a privileged heiress into a revolutionary fighting for survival and justice.

‘Alpha Dog’ (2006)

In this crime drama based on true events, Amanda Seyfried plays Julie Beckley. The story follows a group of young, privileged drug dealers in Southern California whose lives spiral out of control. When a deal goes wrong, they impulsively kidnap the younger brother of a rival, leading to a tense and tragic hostage situation.

Seyfried’s character is one of several teenagers who are drawn into the increasingly dangerous situation. She and her friends party with the kidnappers and their victim, seemingly unaware of the severity of the crime being committed. The role was an early opportunity for her to show her dramatic range as part of a large ensemble cast.

‘Mank’ (2020)

This black-and-white biographical drama centers on the screenwriter Herman J. Mankiewicz as he writes the screenplay for the classic film ‘Citizen Kane’. Amanda Seyfried portrays Marion Davies, a popular comedic actress from the 1920s and 30s and the longtime mistress of the powerful newspaper magnate William Randolph Hearst, who served as the inspiration for the film’s main character.

Seyfried’s performance captures Davies’s sharp intelligence, humor, and loyalty, challenging the historical narrative that she was merely a talentless socialite. The role required her to adopt the specific accent and mannerisms of the era. Her portrayal brought warmth and complexity to a figure who was often misunderstood by the public.

‘First Reformed’ (2017)

In this intense psychological thriller, Amanda Seyfried plays Mary Mensana. She is a pregnant parishioner at a small, historic church in upstate New York. She seeks counseling from the church’s pastor, a former military chaplain who is grappling with his own personal tragedies and a crisis of faith.

Mary is deeply concerned about her husband, a radical environmental activist who has fallen into despair about the future of the planet. Her presence forces the pastor to confront his own beliefs and the moral compromises of his church. Seyfried’s role is crucial to the film’s exploration of faith, hope, and environmental catastrophe.

‘Mean Girls’ (2004)

Amanda Seyfried had her breakout film role as Karen Smith in this iconic teen comedy. The story follows a new high school student who falls in with the A-list clique known as The Plastics. Karen is one of the three core members of the group, known for her cheerful demeanor and comical lack of awareness.

While a member of the popular but cruel clique, Karen is portrayed as the least malicious of the trio, often delivering absurdly funny lines with complete sincerity. Seyfried’s performance made the character a memorable and often-quoted part of the film, which has since become a cultural touchstone for a generation.

‘Big Love’ (2006–2011)

In this drama series, Amanda Seyfried played Sarah Henrickson, the eldest daughter in a fundamentalist Mormon family that practices polygamy. The show explores the family’s complex relationships and their efforts to live a seemingly normal suburban life while keeping their illegal and controversial lifestyle a secret.

Sarah’s character arc follows her as she grows from a teenager into a young woman, grappling with her family’s faith and the outside world. She often questions her parents’ beliefs and struggles with the social isolation that comes with her family’s situation. Seyfried was a main cast member for the first four seasons, and her role was central to the show’s exploration of family and faith.

‘The Art of Racing in the Rain’ (2019)

Amanda Seyfried stars as Eve Swift in this heartwarming drama told from the perspective of a dog named Enzo. The story follows Enzo’s life with his owner, Denny Swift, a race car driver. Eve enters their lives as Denny’s girlfriend and eventually becomes his wife and the mother of his child.

The film follows the family through life’s triumphs and tribulations, including Eve’s battle with a serious illness. Seyfried portrays a character who is loving, resilient, and the emotional anchor of her family. Her performance contributes to the film’s touching exploration of love, loyalty, and the powerful bond between humans and their pets.

‘Les Misérables’ (2012)

In this epic movie adaptation of the celebrated stage musical, Amanda Seyfried plays the adult Cosette. After a traumatic childhood, Cosette is rescued by the protagonist Jean Valjean and raised as his daughter. As a young woman, she falls in love with a student revolutionary named Marius, unaware of the dangers of her past.

Seyfried performed her songs live on set, a method the director chose to capture the raw emotion of the performances. Her classically trained singing voice was well-suited for the role’s demanding soprano parts. She beautifully portrayed Cosette’s innocence and her journey to finding love and happiness amid the turmoil of 19th-century France.

‘The Dropout’ (2022)

Amanda Seyfried stars as Elizabeth Holmes, the founder of the fraudulent health technology company Theranos. This limited series chronicles Holmes’s rise from a determined Stanford dropout to a self-made billionaire and her subsequent fall from grace when her revolutionary blood-testing technology is exposed as a massive deception.

To prepare for the role, Seyfried extensively studied Holmes’s public appearances and interviews to master her distinctive deep voice and unusual mannerisms. Her transformative performance captured the ambition, charisma, and delusion of the controversial figure. The role was widely acclaimed by critics and audiences alike.

‘The Crowded Room’ (2023)

In this psychological thriller miniseries, Amanda Seyfried plays Rya Goodwin. She is a clinical psychologist and professor who is tasked with interviewing a young man who has been arrested for a public shooting in New York City in 1979. The series is told through a series of conversations between her character and the suspect.

As Rya balances her demanding career with her life as a single mother, she works to uncover the complex mysteries of her patient’s past. Her character’s empathy and professional persistence are key to unlocking the truth behind the crime. Seyfried’s performance provides a steady and intelligent anchor for the show’s intricate and suspenseful narrative.

‘Veronica Mars’ (2004–2019)

Amanda Seyfried played the pivotal role of Lilly Kane in this neo-noir mystery series. The show centers on a high school student who moonlights as a private investigator. Lilly is the title character’s best friend, whose unsolved murder before the start of the series serves as the primary mystery of the first season.

Although her character is deceased, Lilly Kane appears frequently in flashbacks, home videos, and dreams. These appearances slowly reveal her vibrant personality and the dark secrets she kept, helping Veronica piece together the clues to her murder. Seyfried’s portrayal of the popular and rebellious Lilly was essential to the show’s emotional core.

‘Twin Peaks’ (2017)

In the revival of the surreal mystery series, Amanda Seyfried plays Becky Burnett. She is a young married woman living in the titular town, trapped in a difficult relationship with her drug-addicted husband. Her storyline is a significant part of the new material introduced in the series.

Becky’s character arc is a tragic one, reflecting some of the darker themes of the original show about innocence lost in a corrupt world. Her story involves love, betrayal, and substance abuse, adding a new layer of emotional depth to the familiar town of Twin Peaks. Seyfried’s performance was a standout in a series filled with memorable characters.

Share your favorite Amanda Seyfried performance in the comments below.