15 Apple TV+ Shows That Didn’t Take Off

Apple TV+ has carved out a reputation for bold, high-quality storytelling, with hits like ‘Ted Lasso’ and ‘Severance’ stealing the spotlight. But not every show finds its audience, and some slip away quietly despite their potential.

I’ve rounded up 15 Apple TV+ originals that didn’t catch fire as expected, leaving fans like me wishing they’d had more time to shine. From quirky comedies to ambitious sci-fi, these shows deserved a bigger stage. Let’s explore what made them special and why they didn’t stick around.

Schmigadoon! (2021-2023)

This musical comedy follows a couple trapped in a magical town where life’s a Broadway show. Cecily Strong and Keegan-Michael Key lead with charm, delivering catchy songs and sharp humor.

Despite critical love, it struggled to pull a broad audience. Canceled after two seasons, I was bummed to miss out on more of its whimsical vibe. It had the heart to go further.

Constellation (2024)

Noomi Rapace stars as an astronaut facing eerie changes after a space mission. This sci-fi thriller weaves multiverse themes with emotional depth, earning praise from fans like Stephen King.

Apple axed it after one season, likely due to its complex pacing. I found its haunting visuals gripping. It could’ve been a genre standout with more time.

Still Up (2023)

A British comedy about two insomniacs bonding over late-night calls, this show mixes humor with heartfelt moments. Antonia Thomas and Craig Roberts shine as friends navigating life’s chaos.

Canceled after one season for low viewership, it never got its due. I loved its cozy, relatable vibe. A second season might’ve built a loyal crowd.

Time Bandits (2024)

This fantasy adventure, based on the 1981 film, follows a boy and a band of time-traveling thieves. Lisa Kudrow’s quirky performance adds fun to its wild premise.

High production costs and mixed reviews led to its cancellation after one season. I enjoyed its playful energy. It had the makings of a family-friendly hit.

Sunny (2024)

Rashida Jones plays a grieving woman gifted a robot after her family’s disappearance. This sci-fi comedy blends dark themes with humor, set in a visually stunning Japan.

Despite a 90% Rotten Tomatoes score, it was axed after one season, possibly due to costs. I was hooked by its emotional depth. It deserved a bigger audience.

The Big Door Prize (2023-2024)

This quirky drama follows a town transformed by a mysterious machine predicting life’s potential. Chris O’Dowd leads with warmth, grounding its oddball premise.

Canceled after two seasons due to modest viewership, it left fans on a cliffhanger. I loved its blend of humor and heart. It could’ve grown into a cult favorite.

The Mosquito Coast (2021-2023)

Justin Theroux stars in this tense drama about a family on the run from the U.S. government. Based on the novel, it’s gritty and full of suspense.

It ended after two seasons, likely due to declining buzz. I was drawn to its intense family dynamics. A third season might’ve tied up loose ends.

Suspicion (2022)

Uma Thurman leads this crime thriller about a kidnapping tied to a media mogul’s son. Its twisty plot and strong cast kept things engaging.

Canceled after one season due to mixed reception, it didn’t find its footing. I enjoyed its fast-paced mystery. More time could’ve sharpened its edge.

Mr. Corman (2021)

Joseph Gordon-Levitt plays a teacher grappling with anxiety and dreams of music. This dramedy offers a raw look at mental health with a grounded tone.

Low viewership led to its cancellation after one season. I appreciated its quiet honesty. It had potential to resonate with a bigger crowd.

City on Fire (2023)

This crime drama follows students caught in a city-wide mystery after a shooting in Central Park. Its gritty storytelling and young cast brought energy.

Axed after one season for lackluster reviews, it didn’t catch on. I liked its raw New York vibe. A second season could’ve deepened the intrigue.

Shantaram (2022)

Charlie Hunnam stars as an Australian convict hiding in India’s underworld. This sweeping drama blends adventure and crime with rich visuals.

Canceled after one season due to production delays and low buzz, it left fans wanting. I was pulled in by its epic scope. It deserved another shot. And this comes from someone who really loved Roberts’ book.

The Afterparty (2022-2023)

This murder mystery comedy shifts genres each episode, with Tiffany Haddish as a detective unraveling a high school reunion death. Its clever format pops.

Despite strong reviews, it was canceled after two seasons. I loved its playful storytelling. It could’ve been a genre-bending hit with more episodes.

Swagger (2021-2023)

Inspired by Kevin Durant’s life, this drama follows a teen basketball prodigy navigating fame. Its heartfelt take on youth and ambition stood out.

Canceled after two seasons due to modest viewership, it didn’t reach its potential. I enjoyed its grounded sports story. More time could’ve built its fanbase.

Truth Be Told (2019-2023)

Octavia Spencer stars as a journalist diving into true crime cases. This drama tackles justice and race with a strong cast and emotional weight.

It ended after three seasons, with Spencer calling it a wrap. I admired its bold themes. A final season could’ve tied up its arcs neatly.

Dear Edward (2023)

Connie Britton and Taylor Schilling lead this drama about a boy surviving a plane crash. Its emotional storytelling pulls at the heartstrings.

Canceled after one season for low traction, it didn’t find its audience. I was moved by its tender moments. It had room to grow into something special.

Which of these Apple TV+ shows did you wish had found its spark, or is there another gem I missed? Share your thoughts in the comments!