15 Best Shows Like ‘Dexter: Resurrection’ You Need to Watch Next
If you’re hooked on the dark, thrilling world of ‘Dexter: Resurrection’, you’re probably craving more stories about complex antiheroes and twisted minds. This show brings back Dexter Morgan’s gripping mix of charm, danger, and moral gray areas, set against a gritty New York backdrop.
I’ve put together a list of 15 shows that capture similar vibes, from psychological thrillers to dark comedies. Each one offers compelling characters, intense plots, and that same addictive pull you love in Dexter’s latest chapter.
Your Honor (2020-2023)
This intense drama follows a respected judge whose life unravels when his son is involved in a hit-and-run. Desperate to protect his family, he makes choices that blur the line between right and wrong.
Bryan Cranston shines as the judge, delivering a performance full of tension and heartbreak. The show keeps you guessing as secrets pile up and consequences hit hard.
The Undoing (2020)
A wealthy New York therapist’s perfect life crumbles when her husband is linked to a brutal murder. This miniseries dives into deception and privilege with a glossy yet unsettling edge.
Nicole Kidman and Hugh Grant lead a stellar cast, pulling you into a web of lies. Each episode ramps up the suspense, making it tough to stop watching.
Sweetpea (2024-present)
Rhiannon, a quiet young woman, snaps under life’s pressures and finds empowerment in murder. This dark comedy blends humor with chilling moments as she navigates her new secret life.
Ella Purnell’s performance is magnetic, balancing vulnerability and menace. The show’s quirky tone and short episodes make it a fresh, bingeable pick.
The Sinner (2017-2021)
Each season of this anthology series follows a different crime, with a detective digging into why ordinary people commit shocking acts. It’s a deep dive into guilt and hidden truths.
Bill Pullman’s haunted detective anchors the show, while each case feels raw and unpredictable. The psychological focus keeps you hooked through every twist.
Marvel’s The Punisher (2017-2019)
A former Marine turns vigilante after his family’s murder, waging a brutal war on crime. This gritty Marvel series explores revenge and trauma with a relentless lead.
Jon Bernthal’s raw portrayal of Frank Castle makes you root for him despite the bloodshed. The action-packed story delivers thrills with a heavy emotional core.
The Mentalist (2008-2015)
A former fake psychic uses his sharp mind to solve crimes for the police while hunting the serial killer who destroyed his family. It’s a mix of wit and darkness.
Simon Baker’s charming yet troubled lead keeps the show engaging. The procedural cases are fun, but the ongoing quest for justice adds real weight.
The Following (2013-2015)
A former FBI agent tracks a charismatic cult leader who inspires followers to kill. This intense thriller dives into obsession and the pull of evil minds.
Kevin Bacon and James Purefoy face off in a cat-and-mouse game that’s both creepy and gripping. The cult dynamic adds a unique layer of dread.
Pushing Daisies (2007-2009)
A pie-maker with the power to revive the dead helps solve murders, all while juggling romance and secrets. This quirky fantasy blends humor with macabre charm.
Lee Pace’s whimsical lead and the show’s vibrant style make it a standout. It’s lighter than Dexter but still explores death with a clever twist.
Prodigal Son (2019-2021)
A profiler with a serial killer father uses his dark insight to catch murderers. This show mixes family drama with chilling cases and a touch of humor.
Tom Payne and Michael Sheen’s dynamic as son and father drives the story. The psychological depth and twisted crimes make it a great fit for Dexter fans.
Killing Eve (2018-2022)
A bored MI6 agent hunts a stylish assassin, sparking a dangerous obsession between them. This sleek thriller blends wit, tension, and complex female leads.
Sandra Oh and Jodie Comer’s chemistry is electric, making their cat-and-mouse game addictive. The show’s bold tone and sharp writing keep you glued.
Desperate Housewives (2004-2012)
Suburban women hide secrets and scandals behind perfect smiles. This soapy drama mixes dark humor with mystery, narrated by a woman who died by suicide.
The ensemble cast, led by Teri Hatcher and Eva Longoria, delivers juicy drama. It’s less violent than Dexter but nails the tension of hidden lives.
Barry (2018-2023)
A hitman stumbles into acting and tries to leave his violent past behind. This dark comedy balances laughs with raw emotion as he wrestles with his choices.
Bill Hader’s nuanced performance makes Barry both likable and unsettling. The show’s tight storytelling and surprising depth make it a must-watch.
True Detective (2014-present)
Each season follows different detectives tackling grim cases, often with a touch of the supernatural. The show’s moody atmosphere and deep character studies shine.
Stars like Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson elevate the anthology format. The mix of crime and existential dread feels right for Dexter fans.
You (2018-2025)
A charming bookstore manager becomes a obsessive stalker, using his smarts to control those he loves. This psychological thriller is darkly funny and tense.
Penn Badgley’s chilling yet charismatic lead makes you question who to root for. The show’s social media-driven plots feel fresh and unnerving.
Hannibal (2013-2015)
An FBI profiler works with a brilliant psychiatrist who’s secretly a cannibalistic killer. This stylish thriller explores the psyche of monsters with haunting visuals.
Hugh Dancy and Mads Mikkelsen’s complex dynamic is the show’s heart. The blend of beauty and horror makes it a perfect match for Dexter’s dark allure.
Which of these shows is your top pick to watch next, or did I miss a killer series you love? Drop your thoughts in the comments!