15 Best Shows Like First Kill You Need to Watch

Untitled design 2

Why trust us? Check out Fiction Horizon’s Editorial Policy.

First Kill is a series that has gotten a lot of fans hooked because it explores two genres that you don’t often see. This series is about a love story between two females, as one belongs to a vampire hunter clan while the other is a vampire. In that regard, it combines fantasy, drama, and LGBTQ romance in one story. So, if you were able to binge through First Kill quick enough and are looking for something similar to it, we have a list of the best shows like First Kill that you need to watch.

15. Moonlight (2007 – 2008)

Moonlight Series 1 Stills moonlight 2703499 2000 1333

Moonlight is a fantasy romance series that follows the story of a private investigator named Mick St. John, who was turned into a vampire by his bride on the night of their wedding. However, he ends up struggling to control his cravings for human women as he continues his life as a private investigator. As such, the story follows the conflicts between his new identity and that of his chosen profession in human society.

Why It’s Like First Kill: While Moonlight focuses on an adult setting, there are still a lot of things that make it similar to First Kill. The series focuses on the life of a vampire who needs to make sure that he is able to control his cravings while working in his chosen profession. In that regard, it shows his struggle between his feelings and cravings for women in a world where vampires don’t belong.

14. The Magicians (2015 – 2020)

themagicians s5 keyart show tile 1920x1080 1

The Magicians is a series that lasted for five seasons on Syfy and is actually quite popular in its own niche market, despite the fact it wasn’t able to gain the same kind of popularity that some of the series here have. Nevertheless, the story is quite enticing as it follows the story of a graduate student who discovers a school for magic. And he ends up discovering that magic is very real and very dangerous as the series blends fantasy and reality well enough in an intriguing story.

Why It’s Like First Kill: Even though The Magicians doesn’t focus on a vampire-human romantic story, it still is similar to First Kill because we are looking at two different shows that look have similar elements in terms of how they focus on fantasy. The Magicians is more in line with the magical element of the fantasy genre as it allows its audience to see how magic can be hiding under our noses in this Harry Potter-esque series.

13. The Order (2019 – 2020)

MV5BNzYyNjQzODYtMmQxYi00Y2I1LTkxZmYtZWIwMzZjNzYzMjU0XkEyXkFqcGdeQWFybm8@. V1

Of course, we are not yet done with shows that follow the magical genre as we look at The Order, which is also a series that follows a magic school. In this series, we follow the story of a young man who was determined to join an exclusive club in his school because he wanted to use his status as a member of this club to take revenge on his father. However, what he didn’t expect was that this club was actually a magical order as he ended up realizing that he bit off more than he could chew.


‘First Kill’ Review: Teen Vampires Are Ready To Make Love And Drink Blood

Why It’s Like First Kill: The Order is like First Kill despite the fact that they have different themes. They are both fantasy shows that focus on supernatural elements, even though there are differences between them. Nevertheless, The Order is the same as First Kill in the sense that it explores a magical order that is hiding underneath human society, just like how First Kill has vampires and vampire hunters hiding within human society.

12. Riverdale (2017 – Present)

riverdale season 4 2

There are a lot of things that people can say about Riverdale because of the fact that it took a weird turn in its latest season as it added powers to its characters. Nevertheless, this series can still be a fun show to watch if you are a fan of darker teenage drama stories. Riverdale is simply a darker (and more supernatural) take on the popular Archie comics. In that regard, it follows the story of a group of teenage friends in the fictional town of Riverdale.

Why It’s Like First Kill: Riverdale takes on a different type of fantasy when compared to the more outright fantasy themes that First Kill comes with. However, they are both similar in the sense that they follow a story that focuses on teen drama amidst the backdrop of a world of fantasy where magic, powers, and a lot of other supernatural elements exist.

11. Teen Wolf (2011 – 2017)

Teen Wolf Season 4 EDIT Cast Shot Photo Credit Jaimie Trueblood and MTV

One of the more underrated and underappreciated supernatural drama series is Teen Wolf, which basically explains itself. The series follows the story of a teenager that got bit by a wolf-like creature. This bite turned him into a werewolf as he now has to reconcile the fact that he has to live his life differently while learning how to control his urges. And he’s afraid of the possibility of his wolf side taking over his human side.

Why It’s Like First Kill: Of course, Teen Wolf and First Kill are very much alike in the sense that they follow teenage drama stories that are focused on supernatural elements. However, Teen Wolf focuses on werewolves, while First Kill focuses on vampires. Nevertheless, they are still very similar to one another, despite the fact that werewolves and vampires are nothing alike.

10. Fate: The Winx Saga (2021)

ie 62347

Winx has always been popular among young girls, as Fate: The Winx Saga is a live-action take on this magical story. The series follows the story of fairies attending a magical boarding school as they have to master their magical powers while navigating their way through the usual things that teenagers go through, such as love, rivalries, and even monsters. The series only lasted for a single season, but it was still a fun ride for different fans of the fantasy genre.

Why It’s Like First Kill: The reason why Fate: The Winx Sage is similar to First Kill is the fact that we are looking at teenage stories that are set against the backdrop of a world where magic and supernatural elements exist. In that regard, they both explore the stories of female teenagers that are looking to navigate their way through romance and other problems that teenagers normally face.

9. Dracula (2020)

image 4

One of the more popular Netflix series about vampires is Dracula, which is a retelling of the popular Dracula story that has been told over and over again. The series lasts for only three episodes that are all as long as movies. It focuses on Dracula’s story, which began during the 1800s but ended during the modern age. 

Why It’s Like First Kill: At first, Dracula and First Kill don’t have a lot of things in common. But fans of the vampire genre will love Dracula because, after all, it is the story of the most famous vampire in the history of literature. In that regard, you will enjoy Dracula if you love the vampire elements that are present in First Kill.

8. Heartstopper (2022)

Heartstopper.jpg copy

This is probably the only series we have on this list that doesn’t have anything related to supernatural elements. Nevertheless, Heartstopper is a fun and heartwarming series that tells the tale of young adult romance against the backdrop of two young teenagers who are beginning to fall for one another. In that regard, it is a sweet story that looks at young adult romance in a genuine and pure way.

Why It’s Like First Kill: While people often look at the vampire and supernatural themes that are followed in First Kill, many forget that this series also includes LGBT elements in the story. That is where Heartstopper becomes similar to First Kill as they both talk about young teenagers that are involved in an LGBT romantic relationship.

7. Legacies (2018 – Present)

p15533696 ce h10 aa

One of the most popular vampire-themed series in the world is The Vampire Diaries, which was able to earn itself two spin-off stories that are based in the same universe. The second spin-off story is Legacies, which is often regarded as arguably the best in the Vampire Diaries universe because it now tells the story of the generation that followed after the story of the original series. In that regard, we look at the stories of the legacies of the characters in TVD in this fun and entertaining narrative that combines drama, romance, and magic in one series.

Why It’s Like First Kill: Of course, the reason why Legacies and First Kill are similar to one another is the fact that they are both stories that focus on vampires and teenage drama. However, Legacies has a much bigger world where witches and other magical elements exist, as this world has already been established during the events of The Vampire Diaries.

6. The Originals (2013 – 2018)

the originals

As mentioned, The Vampire Diaries has two spin-off series, and the first one is The Originals. The story of The Originals is set in the same TVD universe but revolves around the characters who are regarded as the first vampires in existence. That is why the series is called The Originals, as it explores the story of the original vampires. And there is a lot of drama in this blood-soaked series.

Why It’s Like First Kill: Unlike First Kill, The Originals doesn’t explore a story that focuses on teenage drama. Nevertheless, it is still full of drama as it tells the story of the life of the original vampires. In that regard, their similarities can be seen in the fact that they both explore supernatural themes and vampires in a narrative that is full of drama and romance.

5. The Vampire Diaries (2009 – 2017)

p3563021 ce h9 ae

One of the most popular vampire series of all time is The Vampire Diaries, which is essentially a drama story that explores a world where vampires and other supernatural elements exist. The story focuses on a girl who falls in love with two vampires in a story that focuses on the love triangle between the two characters. It is essentially a huge series that spanned nearly a decade because of its popularity and world-building.

Why It’s Like First Kill: Basically, The Vampire Diaries is like First Kill on steroids because of how vast and big this series is. They both explore young love between characters who belong in different worlds. The only difference is that TVD doesn’t include LGBT romance between the main characters and that there is an epic love triangle going on in this all-time great vampire series.

4. True Blood (2008 – 2014)


True Blood is one of the biggest original series in HBO’s lineup as it is arguably the series that helped launch more and more HBO originals with large budgets. The story of this series focuses on a world where vampires have already revealed themselves to the public and are looking to live alongside humans in society. Meanwhile, a girl ends up falling for a vampire who had just moved into town as she eventually becomes entangled in a larger story that involves some of the most prominent vampires in the entire country.\


Is The Northman About Eric Northman from True Blood?

Why It’s Like First Kill: True Blood and First Kill are very much alike because of the fact that they involve vampire-human romantic relationships. However, True Blood takes it a step further by introducing a lot more supernatural elements like fairies and werewolves, among others. In that regard, it’s one of the biggest and most popular vampire-themed series of all time.

3. Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (2018 – 2020)

Sabrina FA.jpg

The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina is a darker retelling of the Sabrina series that was popular back in the day. Set in the same world as Riverdale, this series follows the story of a teenage witch named Sabrina Spellman, who now has to juggle between the magical and human worlds in a young adult series that allows us to see teenage drama and romance.

Why It’s Like First Kill: Like First Kill, there are plenty of young adult themes that are prominent in The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, as the series takes a good look at how Sabrina tries to juggle between her two different identities in a world that doesn’t know that the supernatural side of society exists.

2. A Discovery of Witches (2018 – Present)

18witches superJumbo v2

A Discovery of Witches is another one of the underrated gems that we have on this list, as it doesn’t come with the popularity of some of the shows we mentioned but is still one of the most enjoyable titles to watch. The series follows the story of an adult witch that ends up falling for a vampire, who has to prevent his urges from taking over him in this relationship. And the story ends up becoming complicated because of how the main vampire character tries to distance himself from her in an attempt to prevent his urges from getting the best of him.

Why It’s Like First Kill: The thing about A Discovery of Witches is that it is quite different from First Kill when you look at how it involves grown adults instead of young adults or teenagers. Nevertheless, there are similar themes because A Discovery of Witches also focuses on a strong female lead that’s trying to navigate her way through a supernatural world.

1. Shadowhunters (2016 – 2019)

1528795724 shadowhunters group

Shadowhunters is a series that’s based on the book series entitled The Mortal Instruments as the series follows the story of a girl who ends up learning that she is a descendant of an ancient order of demon hunters. As such, she now has to accept the fact that she is half-angel as she tries to include herself in a world that she has never been familiar with. Of course, there are also themes of forbidden love in this amazing young adult series that focus on action and romance.

Why It’s Like First Kill: While the main characters of Shadowhunters aren’t vampires, they both have characters that slay demonic entities for a living. Of course, there’s also the fact that the main character in Shadowhunters is engaged in a forbidden relationship that tends to make her life more complicated than it already is.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments