Controversy Erupts as Trans-Owned Bookshop Encourages Vandalism of JK Rowling’s ‘Harry Potter’ Books
A bookshop in Leeds has sparked debate after launching a fundraiser that involves defacing copies of a Harry Potter novel. The store, called The Bookish Type, is owned by a trans team and is asking customers to pay 25p to write or draw inside pages of Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. The idea is to later auction the altered book and donate the money to transgender healthcare.
According to the shop, the idea started as a lighthearted activity linked to one of their regular second-hand book events. They told PinkNews, “We came up with this idea a few weeks ago as a silly and cathartic way to.” They added that it was first planned for a future event but was introduced earlier after seeing strong interest from customers.
The shop says people can mark “as many pages” as they want. Some participants have used the space to leave personal messages, including direct criticism of author J.K. Rowling. One message written in the book reads, “You’ve ruined yourself, ruined the name of feminism and ruined the precious childhood of thousands of women and girls. F**** you.
The fundraiser comes amid ongoing criticism of Rowling’s views on gender identity. Over the past several years, she has become one of the most visible gender-critical voices in the UK. In a 2020 statement on her website, she explained her concerns about policies related to gender identity, writing, “When you throw open the doors of bathrooms and changing rooms to any man who believes or feels he’s a woman… then you open the door to any and all men who wish to come inside. That is the simple truth.”
Her comments have led to strong reactions from both supporters and critics. Several actors from the Harry Potter films have publicly disagreed with her. Daniel Radcliffe wrote in support of the trans community, saying that “transgender women are women.” Emma Watson also shared her support, stating, “Trans people are who they say they are and deserve to live their lives without being constantly questioned.” Rupert Grint echoed similar views, saying, “Trans women are women. Trans men are men.”
The Bookish Type told the Daily Mail that the project is meant to give people a way to deal with emotions in a difficult climate. “Existing as a trans person in this political climate is both exhausting and terrifying; it feels especially important to give the community a way to release some emotion,” they said. They also noted that the response has gone beyond their local area, with people from countries like Canada, Portugal, and New Zealand offering support or donations.
The shop says it plans to continue the fundraiser and auction the book once it is filled. They also mentioned that some people have offered to donate extra copies of the series for future events.
This story shows how deeply divided people are on this issue. Some see the project as a creative way to raise money, while others may view it as disrespectful to a well-known book series. What do you think about this idea? Share your thoughts in the comments.