Critic Calls Out Generative AI in ‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’
David Fincher’s follow-up to ‘Once Upon a Time … in Hollywood’ has mostly had a smooth critical rollout, but a new controversy has emerged over the use of generative AI in ‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’.
Critics say Quentin Tarantino’s writing and Fincher’s direction add up to rock-solid results, even if the story wanders a bit before it erupts in spectacular fashion. The film comes to IMAX theaters globally for an exclusive 2-week run starting Nov. 25, before debuting on Netflix on Dec. 23.
Fincher has long been seen as a technical perfectionist. Erik Messerschmidt, his frequent collaborator, shot the film and established its visual language for the late-1970s California setting. Jeff Cronenweth took over as cinematographer for reshoots when Messerschmidt was unavailable.
That attention to visual detail is now at the center of the conversation. Reviewing the film for Next Best Picture, Giovanni Lago called Fincher’s use of generative AI in key moments of the film “nothing but an eyesore.” He also described it as distracting.
The review doesn’t single out any specific scenes. It says only that the AI appears in “key moments” of the film. Lago argues that Fincher, a filmmaker known for pushing technology, was misled into thinking audiences want this kind of imagery and that it looks good.
new trailer for THE FURTHER MIS-ADVENTURES OF CLIFF BOOTH ❤️🔥 https://t.co/L2AjCCu3xt
— brad pitt updates (@pittstoppp) November 6, 2026
Despite the criticism, the review is far from negative overall. Next Best Picture gives the film 7/10, saying Brad Pitt seems more alive on screen than he has since ‘Babylon’ and calling Cliff Booth one of the defining roles of his career. Elizabeth Debicki’s Karen Crosby is singled out as the standout performance.
Lago still had other complaints. He found that the days-of-the-week structure sometimes meanders and that the visual effects are weak overall. He sees Fincher as consistently at the forefront of filmmaking technology, which makes the AI use feel like a misstep rather than a breakthrough.
The comments quickly spread across social media. One viewer posted that they walked out of the film gutted, saying the sequel was overshadowed by some of the most blatant AI use they had seen in a studio film. Another user, who said they work in VFX, called the amount of AI astounding.
A new trailer for David Fincher’s ‘THE FURTHER MIS-ADVENTURES OF CLIFF BOOTH’ has been released. Releasing on IMAX November 25. https://t.co/WmSOXTszkV
— Film Updates (@FilmUpdates) September 21, 2026
Not everyone is convinced, though. Writer Matt Jarbo pointed out that the review doesn’t identify a single scene or explain how the reviewer determined it was AI, and said he’d rather see what Fincher actually did before joining another round of AI panic. One fan pointed to specific timestamps, though other claims circulating online have come without evidence.
For now, the claims remain unverified. Nobody involved with the movie has publicly confirmed the alleged AI usage. The allegations come from the Next Best Picture review and from social media posts, and Netflix and Fincher have not responded.
Fincher has spoken about AI before, with mixed feelings. He has been skeptical that AI can capture the personal touch of art, but in a British GQ interview he called it a powerful tool, and he told the Los Angeles Times that he isn’t afraid of the unknown.

The timing makes the debate especially loud. Critics have been largely positive about the film, and Slant Magazine’s Eli Friedberg even called it a more haunting and mature film than ‘Once Upon a Time…in Hollywood’. Meanwhile, AI use in movies remains one of the most divisive topics in the industry.
Whether the AI moments become a footnote or a defining talking point may depend on what audiences notice once the film reaches wider viewership. Netflix subscribers will get their chance to judge for themselves when it starts streaming in December.
Do you think generative AI has a place in Hollywood films like ‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’?
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!
