DC’s R-Rated ‘Clayface’ Is About To Pass ‘Supergirl’ at the Global Box Office

Warner Bros. Pictures

Share:

It’s been a year of very different bets for DC Studios. The summer brought a big-budget superhero tentpole, and the fall brought ‘Clayface’, an R-rated body horror film about one of Batman’s oldest villains. Few people expected the smaller movie to end up ahead.

‘Supergirl’ set the tone for the year, and not in a good way. The DCU’s second movie severely underperformed with a domestic opening of $38 million, not an ideal start for a movie that cost over $170 million to produce. It received mixed reviews from critics and was a box-office bomb, grossing $126.4 million against a production budget of $170–186 million.

Now ‘Clayface’ is close to overtaking it. According to box office analyst Luiz Fernando, the film earned $3.3 million overseas in its 4th weekend, a 51.5% drop, bringing its international total to $57.7 million across 76 markets. Combined with $63.6 million in the US, the film’s worldwide total stands at $121.3 million.

RELATED:

Supergirl’s Box Office Losses Reportedly Rank Among the Worst in DC History

That leaves it only a few million dollars behind ‘Supergirl’s global run of about $126.5 million. Fernando expects ‘Clayface’ to pass the summer release next weekend. The longer-term outlook looks good too. According to industry trackers, ‘Clayface’ is on track to earn between $130 million and $150 million worldwide during its theatrical run.

The real difference between the 2 films is what they cost. ‘Clayface’ was intended to be produced on a “stripped down” budget of around $40 million. Estimates vary slightly, and Variety reported a $44 million budget, which doesn’t include marketing. That lower cost gave it a much easier path to profit. The James Watkins-directed horror thriller has broken even, a feat that few underrated superhero releases manage today.

The film’s run started strong. In the United States, ‘Clayface’ debuted at No. 1 with $24 million across 3,458 theaters, and worldwide it opened to a reported $43 million. Its debut was smaller than ‘Supergirl’s. That opening was roughly 63% of what ‘Supergirl’ debuted with last summer.

Audiences kept showing up. They gave ‘Clayface’ an “A-” CinemaScore, a high grade for a horror release. The film was helped by positive word of mouth and held up well following the Halloween period. It also held its ground as theaters cut showings, with a 38.8% US drop in its 3rd weekend despite losing 532 theaters.

The creative approach set it apart from typical superhero fare. ‘Clayface’ stars Tom Rhys Harries as Matt Hagen, an actor who transforms his body into clay after a gangster disfigured his face. The screenplay comes from Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini, based on a story by Flanagan.

DC Studios aimed for a dark tone from the start. Peter Safran said the film would not have a campy tone and instead compared it to the horror film ‘The Fly’. Industry watchers praised the risk. “‘Clayface’ is a great example of studios taking chances, with DC venturing into R-rated horror and body horror, something that’s certainly not your typical comic book movie,” said Paul Dergarabedian, head of marketplace trends for Rentrak.

The result gives DC Studios something to build on. It offered some stability and assured profitability to DC Studios following the disappointment of ‘Supergirl’. It also suggests that smaller, genre-driven stories can succeed alongside the bigger superhero films. If ‘Clayface’ passes ‘Supergirl’ as expected, the DCU’s lowest-budget film will finish the year ahead of one of its biggest.

Should DC Studios make more mid-budget, genre-focused movies like ‘Clayface’ after its box office success?

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!

Don't miss:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted