24 Gay Actors Who Auditioned for Straight Roles and Nailed the Irony

The entertainment industry has evolved significantly regarding the separation of an actor’s personal life from their on-screen persona. Many openly gay actors have delivered convincing performances as heterosexual characters and shattered stereotypes in the process. These talented individuals prove that acting is truly about the ability to embody a different person regardless of sexual orientation. Audiences often fall in love with these fictional romances without realizing the irony behind the casting. The following list highlights men who played straight roles with such conviction that they captivated viewers worldwide.

Neil Patrick Harris

Neil Patrick Harris achieved massive success playing the ultimate womanizer Barney Stinson in ‘How I Met Your Mother’. His character was famous for an obsession with suits and an endless pursuit of female conquests. Harris managed to make the sleazy tactics of Barney seem charming and hilarious for nine seasons. The actor came out publicly while the show was still in production and continued to play the ladies’ man seamlessly. He proved that personal orientation has no bearing on the ability to play a convincing playboy.

Matt Bomer

Matt Bomer won hearts as the charming con artist Neal Caffrey in the hit series ‘White Collar’. His character was a sophisticated ladies’ man who frequently used his allure to manipulate situations. Bomer shared intense on-screen chemistry with various female co-stars throughout the show’s run. He kept his private life quiet for years before publicly acknowledging his husband and family. His performance remains a prime example of a gay actor embodying a suave heterosexual icon.

Jim Parsons

Jim Parsons created one of the most iconic television characters of the modern era with Sheldon Cooper in ‘The Big Bang Theory’. Sheldon began as an asexual figure but eventually developed a deep romantic relationship with neurobiologist Amy Farrah Fowler. Parsons brought immense nuance to the character’s slow emotional awakening and eventual marriage. The actor identified as gay throughout the height of the show’s popularity without it affecting the audience’s perception of the role. His portrayal earned him four Emmy Awards and cemented his place in television history.

Jonathan Groff

Jonathan Groff took on the serious role of FBI Agent Holden Ford in the psychological thriller ‘Mindhunter’. His character navigates a complex romantic relationship with a sociology student while interviewing serial killers. Groff delivers a stoic and masculine performance that contrasts sharply with his musical theater background. He creates palpable tension with his female love interest that drives much of the character development. The actor has been open about his sexuality since his early career on Broadway.

Luke Evans

Luke Evans has built a career playing rugged and masculine figures in major action franchises. He portrayed the villainous Gaston in the live-action adaptation of ‘Beauty and the Beast’ who is obsessed with winning Belle’s hand. His resume includes playing the legendary vampire in ‘Dracula Untold’ and the skilled Archer Bard in ‘The Hobbit’. Evans brings a convincing intensity and physical presence to these traditionally alpha-male roles. He successfully separates his private life from the aggressive characters he portrays on screen.

Zachary Quinto

Zachary Quinto stepped into the legendary shoes of Spock in the rebooted ‘Star Trek’ film franchise. His interpretation of the Vulcan included a passionate romantic subplot with Lieutenant Uhura. Quinto balanced the character’s logical nature with an underlying emotional depth regarding his love interest. He came out publicly in 2011 but continued to play the straight character in subsequent sequels. His performance satisfied die-hard fans and introduced a new romantic dynamic to the canon.

Ian McKellen

Sir Ian McKellen is a titan of acting who has played powerful straight characters for decades. He portrayed the metal-manipulating mutant Magneto in the ‘X-Men’ franchise who had a tragic backstory involving a wife and daughter. His role as Gandalf in ‘The Lord of the Rings’ commanded respect and authority without relying on romance. McKellen has been out for a long time and uses his platform to advocate for LGBTQ+ rights. He consistently demonstrates that gravitas and masculinity are not defined by sexual orientation.

Wentworth Miller

Wentworth Miller became an international heartthrob as Michael Scofield in the drama ‘Prison Break’. His character was driven by brotherly love but also maintained a central romance with the prison doctor Sara Tancredi. Fans were invested in the intense chemistry between Michael and Sara for multiple seasons. Miller came out years after the show originally aired and later declined to play straight characters again. His work on the series remains a testament to his ability to lead a high-stakes action drama.

Lee Pace

Lee Pace captivated audiences as the pie-maker Ned in the whimsical series ‘Pushing Daisies’. The core of the show was the longing romantic connection between Ned and his childhood sweetheart Chuck. Pace brought a gentle and charming masculinity to the role that made the unrequited touch compelling. He also played the elven king Thranduil in ‘The Hobbit’ and the villain Ronan in ‘Guardians of the Galaxy’. Pace confirmed his queer identity later in his career after playing numerous straight leading men.

David Hyde Pierce

David Hyde Pierce played the fastidious psychiatrist Niles Crane on the sitcom ‘Frasier’ for eleven years. The character was defined by his agonizingly long and secret infatuation with the housekeeper Daphne Moon. Pierce delivered a masterclass in physical comedy and longing looks that made the eventual romance satisfying. He married his husband days before California banned same-sex marriage but played the heterosexual Niles until the series finale. His performance is often cited as one of the best in sitcom history.

Victor Garber

Victor Garber played the rugged and intimidating spy Jack Bristow in the action series ‘Alias’. His character was a devoted father and a man who deeply loved his estranged wife. Garber brought a stoic toughness to the role that grounded the fantastical elements of the show. He has lived with his partner for decades but often plays authoritative straight men in film and television. His portrayal of Thomas Andrews in ‘Titanic’ is another example of his dramatic range.

George Takei

George Takei is a science fiction legend known for playing Hikaru Sulu in the original ‘Star Trek’ series. Sulu was portrayed as a dashing helmsman who eventually had a daughter in the film canon. Takei kept his sexuality hidden for many years to protect his career in a less accepting era. He has since become a prominent activist while celebrating the legacy of his straight character. His deep voice and commanding presence made him a convincing officer on the Enterprise.

Rock Hudson

Rock Hudson was the quintessential Hollywood leading man during the Golden Age of cinema. He starred in romantic comedies like ‘Pillow Talk’ where he played charming bachelors wooing women like Doris Day. Studios actively manufactured a heterosexual image for him to maintain his status as a heartthrob. His ability to project the ideal American male fantasy while living as a gay man is a poignant part of Hollywood history. Hudson tragically became the face of the AIDS crisis later in life.

Richard Chamberlain

Richard Chamberlain made hearts flutter as the forbidden love interest Father Ralph in ‘The Thorn Birds’. His chemistry with Rachel Ward in the miniseries became the stuff of television legend. Chamberlain spent much of his career playing romantic leads who women adored. He stayed in the closet for the majority of his working life to preserve his leading man status. He eventually wrote a memoir discussing the burden of hiding his true self while playing these roles.

Tab Hunter

Tab Hunter was a product of the studio system that marketed him as the boy next door. He dated prominent actresses for publicity while starring in films like ‘Damn Yankees’ and ‘Battle Cry’. Hunter successfully played the role of the all-American jock and soldier that audiences craved. His clean-cut image contrasted with the reality of his private life in secret Hollywood circles. He later confirmed the rumors about his sexuality in a documentary about his life.

Colton Haynes

Colton Haynes played the street-smart archer Roy Harper in the superhero series ‘Arrow’. His character was the primary love interest for Thea Queen and engaged in a turbulent romance. Haynes embodied the brooding bad boy trope that is a staple of the CW network. He struggled with anxiety regarding his sexuality before coming out publicly. His performance convinced viewers he was a tough vigilante with a soft spot for his girlfriend.

BD Wong

BD Wong has played numerous straight professionals throughout his extensive career. He is well known for his role as Dr. George Huang in ‘Law & Order: Special Victims Unit’. The character often provided psychological insights and commanded respect from the detectives. Wong also played the scientist Dr. Wu in the ‘Jurassic Park’ franchise. He is openly gay and an advocate for parenting rights within the LGBTQ+ community.

John Barrowman

John Barrowman played the villainous Malcolm Merlyn in the Arrowverse shows. Merlyn was a grieving widower motivated by the loss of his wife to destroy the Glades. Barrowman played the character with a ruthless intensity and a twisted paternal love for his children. While his character Captain Jack Harkness is omnisexual, Merlyn was strictly heterosexual and driven by family tragedy. Barrowman is known for his flamboyant personality in real life which disappears completely in this dark role.

Dan Butler

Dan Butler is famous for playing the hyper-masculine sports radio host Bob “Bulldog” Briscoe on ‘Frasier’. Bulldog was an aggressive womanizer who constantly bragged about his conquests. Butler wrote and performed a one-man show about his life as a gay man while appearing on the sitcom. The contrast between the sensitive actor and the brutish character he played was immense. He nailed the irony of playing a man who embodied toxic masculinity.

Matt Dallas

Matt Dallas starred as the mysterious protagonist in the sci-fi series ‘Kyle XY’. His character Kyle navigated a sweet and innocent romance with the girl next door Amanda. The relationship was the emotional anchor of the show and drew in a large teen audience. Dallas announced his engagement to a man several years after the show concluded. He successfully portrayed the confusion and wonder of a boy falling in love with a girl for the first time.

Cheyenne Jackson

Cheyenne Jackson played the handsome fictional actor Danny Baker on the comedy ’30 Rock’. His character was brought in to be the new straight man and heartthrob of the sketch show within the show. Jackson played the role with a winning smile and a naive charm that appealed to the female writers. He has appeared in various straight roles across the ‘American Horror Story’ anthology as well. Jackson is a father of twins with his husband in real life.

Andrew Scott

Andrew Scott became an internet sensation as the “Hot Priest” in the second season of ‘Fleabag’. His character shared an intense and forbidden sexual chemistry with the female protagonist. The role required him to portray a man torn between his devotion to God and his attraction to a woman. Scott’s performance was praised for its raw intimacy and palpable tension. He identifies as gay and has spoken about the importance of actors playing roles different from themselves.

Ben Whishaw

Ben Whishaw portrayed the romantic poet John Keats in the biographical film ‘Bright Star’. The film focuses entirely on the deep and tragic love affair between Keats and Fanny Brawne. Whishaw brought a delicate and passionate energy to the role of the lovestruck writer. He entered a civil partnership with his husband in 2012 but continues to play straight characters. His ability to convey heterosexual longing is evident in his acclaimed filmography.

Kal Penn

Kal Penn is best known for playing the stoner Kumar Patel in the ‘Harold & Kumar’ film series. Kumar is a brilliant but lazy medical school applicant who is constantly chasing women. The character’s pursuit of romance and drugs defined the raunchy comedy of the franchise. Penn came out later in his career when he announced his engagement to his male partner. He completely sold the persona of a chaotic ladies’ man to audiences for years.

Tell us which of these performances surprised you the most by sharing your thoughts in the comments.