15 Hidden Gems Across Streaming Platforms (And Where to Watch Them)

Streaming platforms are bursting with content, but some of the best movies and shows get buried under the hype of big releases. These hidden gems offer unique stories, stellar performances, and fresh takes that deserve more attention than they’ve received.

I’ve handpicked 15 under-the-radar titles across various genres, from quirky comedies to gripping dramas, all available on major streaming services. Each one brings something special, whether it’s a bold narrative, unforgettable characters, or a vibe you can’t shake. Let’s explore these treasures and where you can find them.

15. The Vast of Night (2019)

This low-budget sci-fi gem follows two teens in 1950s New Mexico who stumble upon a strange radio signal during a high school basketball game. Sierra McCormick and Jake Horowitz deliver captivating performances as they unravel a creepy mystery. The film’s retro style and long, immersive takes create a haunting vibe.

Available on Amazon Prime Video, ‘The Vast of Night’ is a slow-burn thriller that blends nostalgia with eerie suspense. Its unique pacing and clever dialogue make it a standout for fans of thoughtful sci-fi.

14. Rectify (2013-2016)

Aden Young stars as Daniel, a man released from death row after 19 years, navigating life in his small hometown. This drama series explores redemption and family with raw emotion. The slow, reflective storytelling and Young’s nuanced performance make it deeply moving.

You can stream this poignant series on Netflix. Its quiet intensity and focus on human connection make it a hidden treasure for drama fans who enjoy character-driven stories.

13. Coherence (2013)

This mind-bending sci-fi thriller follows a group of friends at a dinner party where a comet’s passing causes reality to unravel. With a tiny budget and mostly improvised dialogue, the cast, including Emily Baldoni, creates a tense, disorienting experience. It’s a puzzle that keeps you guessing.

Available on Hulu, ‘Coherence’ is perfect for viewers who love smart, low-key sci-fi with a psychological edge. Its clever twists and intimate setting make it a must-see.

12. The Goes Wrong Show (2019-2021)

This British comedy series follows a hapless amateur theater troupe whose every performance goes hilariously awry. Think missed cues, collapsing sets, and actors soldiering through chaos. The ensemble’s impeccable timing and slapstick energy make every episode a riot.

Stream it on BritBox for a dose of laugh-out-loud chaos. It’s a perfect pick for fans of physical comedy and behind-the-scenes theater antics.

11. The Man in the High Castle (2015-2019)

Based on Philip K. Dick’s novel, this alternate history drama imagines a world where the Axis powers won World War II. Alexa Davalos and Rufus Sewell lead a gripping tale of resistance and intrigue. The show’s detailed world-building and moral dilemmas keep you hooked.

Available on Amazon Prime Video, this series blends political thriller elements with emotional depth. It’s a captivating watch for fans of speculative fiction.

10. Never Rarely Sometimes Always (2020)

Sidney Flanigan stars as Autumn, a teen traveling from Pennsylvania to New York for an abortion without parental consent. This quiet drama captures her journey with raw honesty, focusing on her bond with her cousin, played by Talia Ryder. The film’s understated power hits hard.

Stream it on Amazon Prime Video for a moving, intimate story. Its realistic portrayal of tough choices makes it a standout indie gem.

9. The OA (2016-2019)

Brit Marling plays Prairie, a woman who returns after years missing, now with strange abilities and a mission. This Netflix original blends sci-fi, mystery, and spirituality with bold storytelling. Its ambitious narrative and emotional core make it unforgettable.

You can watch both seasons on Netflix. Despite its cancellation, ‘The OA’ remains a unique, thought-provoking series for those who love unconventional stories.

8. One Day at a Time (2017-2020)

This sitcom reboot follows a Cuban-American family, led by Justina Machado and Rita Moreno, tackling life’s challenges with humor and heart. It dives into serious topics like mental health and identity while keeping the laughs flowing. The ensemble’s chemistry is electric.

Available on Netflix for its first three seasons, this show is a warm, funny gem. It’s perfect for fans of family comedies with real depth.

7. Green Room (2015)

Anton Yelchin and Imogen Poots star in this brutal thriller about a punk band trapped in a neo-Nazi club after witnessing a crime. The tension is relentless, with Patrick Stewart chilling as the gang’s leader. It’s gritty, fast-paced, and unforgettable.

Stream it on Netflix for a heart-pounding mix of horror and suspense. Its raw energy and stellar cast make it a must for thriller fans.

6. Terriers (2010)

This single-season gem follows two unlicensed private investigators, played by Donal Logue and Michael Raymond-James, solving cases with wit and grit. The show’s blend of humor, drama, and noir vibes, plus its sharp dialogue, makes it endlessly rewatchable.

Available on Hulu, ‘Terriers’ is a criminally overlooked detective series. It’s a perfect pick for fans of buddy-cop dynamics and clever mysteries.

5. Kubo and the Two Strings (2016)

This breathtaking stop-motion adventure follows Kubo, a young boy voiced by Art Parkinson, on a quest in feudal Japan to defeat his evil aunts, voiced by Rooney Mara. With a magical shamisen and loyal companions, Kubo’s journey is both thrilling and heartfelt. Charlize Theron and Matthew McConaughey add vocal star power.

Stream it on Netflix for a visually stunning experience. Its blend of action, myth, and emotion makes it a family-friendly gem that deserves more love.

4. Wellington Paranormal (2018-2022)

This New Zealand comedy series, a spin-off of ‘What We Do in the Shadows,’ follows two bumbling cops, played by Mike Minogue and Karen O’Leary, investigating supernatural oddities like haunted cars and rogue demons. The deadpan humor and quirky cases are pure fun.

Available on Max, this show is a hilarious treat for fans of mockumentaries and absurd comedy. Its low-key charm makes it a perfect light watch.

3. The Infiltrator (2016)

Bryan Cranston shines as a real-life U.S. customs agent infiltrating Pablo Escobar’s drug empire. This intense crime drama, with Diane Kruger and John Leguizamo, balances suspense with sharp character work. Cranston’s understated performance grounds the high-stakes story.

Watch it on Netflix for a gripping, underseen thriller. Its focus on real-world stakes and moral complexity makes it a standout for crime drama fans.

2. Search Party (2016-2022)

Alia Shawkat leads as Dory, a self-absorbed millennial drawn into a mystery when a college acquaintance vanishes. This dark comedy shifts from satire to thriller, with a stellar cast including John Reynolds and Meredith Hagner. Its biting humor and wild twists keep you glued.

Stream it on Max for a genre-blending ride. The show’s sharp take on millennial angst and suspense makes it a hidden gem worth binging.

1. The Leftovers (2014-2017)

This HBO drama, starring Justin Theroux and Carrie Coon, explores a world where 2% of the population vanishes in a mysterious event. The show dives into grief, faith, and human resilience with haunting performances and bold storytelling. Ann Dowd’s chilling role adds depth.

Available on Max, ‘The Leftovers’ is a profound, emotional journey. Its mix of mystery and raw humanity makes it a top pick for thoughtful viewers.

Which of these hidden gems is your favorite, or is there another under-the-radar movie or show you love? Share your picks in the comments!