‘I Play Rocky’ Is a Certified Crowd-Pleaser With a Rare CinemaScore
Some films win over critics, and others win over the crowd. Peter Farrelly’s ‘I Play Rocky’ looks like it belongs firmly in the second group. The film follows a young, unknown Sylvester Stallone as he fights to bring ‘Rocky’ to the big screen and star in it himself, with Anthony Ippolito playing the future icon.
It also has a strong ensemble around its lead. The cast includes AnnaSophia Robb, Toby Kebbell, P.J. Byrne, Jay Duplass, Matt Dillon and Tracy Letts, with Stephan James as Carl Weathers. The film was reportedly a major crowd-pleaser at the Toronto Film Festival, where it premiered in September and finished runner-up for the People’s Choice Award.
Now moviegoers have spoken, and the verdict is about as good as it gets. As the film expanded nationwide this weekend, audiences gave ‘I Play Rocky’ an A+ CinemaScore. That grade puts it above a long list of acclaimed biopics, including ‘Oppenheimer’, ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’, ‘King Richard’ and ‘Moneyball’, which all earned an A.
The comparisons don’t stop there. In the same viral post, ‘Elvis’, ‘Rocketman’ and ‘Killers of the Flower Moon’ are listed with an A-, while ‘House of Gucci’ received a B+. Its author called the result an all-time record for the business biopic genre.
Audiences have spoken!!! #1 As soon as I watched it at the #LFF, I knew #AmazonMGM’s #IPlayRocky would be an ALL TIMER crowd pleaser, and moviegoers seem to agree, giving the business biopic an SPECTACULAR, rare A+ #CinemaScore, an all time record for the genre! Over #Oppenheimer, #TheBoysInTheBoat, #Air, #KingRichard, #MoneyBall, #BohemianRhapsody, #BobMarleyOneLove, #WhitneyHouston: #IWannaDanceWithSomebody & #Respect’s A #KillersOfTheFlowerMoon, #MICHAEL, #TheIronClaw, #Elvis & #RocketMan’s A- #HouseOfGucci B+ #PrimeTime, #Christy B #TheSocialReckoning, #Napoleon, #TheSmashingMachine, #TheApprentice B-
— Luiz Fernando (@Luiz_Fernando_J) November 21, 2026
The grade is rarer than it might seem. World of Reel notes that for the past 4 years the A+ has gone almost entirely to 2 kinds of films: faith-based releases, mostly from Angel Studios, and music documentaries from Taylor Swift, Beyoncé and Elvis. Regular movies made for broad audiences hadn’t been part of that group.
It’s not a first for Farrelly, though. This is actually his second A+ CinemaScore, following ‘Green Book’ in 2018. The outlet argues the grade gives the film a significant boost in the Best Picture race.
Make the impossible possible. 🥊 I Play Rocky – now playing only in theaters. https://t.co/54MtCGAm6L
— Amazon MGM Studios (@AmazonMGMStudio) November 21, 2026
Reviews have been more mixed than audience reactions. After two weekends in limited release, the film sits at 87% with critics and 98% with audiences on Rotten Tomatoes. Screen Rant’s George Bate called it easily one of the year’s best movies so far.
Not everyone was won over. TheWrap called it a hollow crowdpleaser, and the Boston Globe described it as a well-acted yet empty biopic. Even skeptics, however, have praised Ippolito’s uncanny performance as Stallone.
Watch the first trailer for ‘I Play Rocky,’ starring Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone. In theaters this November. https://t.co/CYI8jY8pVR
— Rotten Tomatoes 🍅 (@RottenTomatoes) July 15, 2026
The film has been building momentum in theaters. In limited release, it earned $344K from just 7 theaters, nearly $50K per location. For the wide expansion, it was projected for about $10M, enough for second place behind ‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping’.
The timing is fitting. The wide release arrives roughly 50 years after ‘Rocky’ became a massive sleeper hit and took the Oscars by storm. An A+ CinemaScore should help strong word of mouth carry it through the holiday season.

Ippolito’s own story mirrors the film’s underdog theme. Rather than going ahead with a worldwide search for their lead, the producers found their star through a self-tape he filmed in his grandmother’s basement. Stallone reportedly had one request for Farrelly: he wanted an unknown to play him.
With a rare audience grade and awards buzz growing, ‘I Play Rocky’ is shaping up to be this season’s feel-good underdog success. Whether it can go the distance at the Oscars remains to be seen.
Do you think ‘I Play Rocky’ deserves its rare A+ CinemaScore?
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!
