‘I Play Rocky’ Review: Why Betting on Yourself Still Makes for Great Cinema
‘I Play Rocky’ arrives from Amazon MGM Studios, opening in limited release on November 6 before going wide on November 20, and it begs an obvious question. Do we need a movie about the making of ‘Rocky’, a film that already doubled as its star’s own life story in boxing gloves? Director Peter Farrelly, best known for ‘Green Book’, clearly thinks we do.
The story follows a young Sylvester Stallone, who still goes by Mike, as he struggles to get anyone to see past his build and his voice. He ends up sleeping on the street at one point and takes a softcore gig simply because it is acting work. Then a screenplay inspired by Chuck Wepner’s fight against Muhammad Ali changes everything, and the real battle becomes his refusal to sell it unless he plays the lead.
Here is where I land, and it starts with Anthony Ippolito. He has the voice and the physical presence, but what won me over was the wounded humor underneath, a man who is furious at his circumstances and tender about them at the same time. Without him this would be a tidy historical reenactment, and with him it feels like a living, breathing movie.
The people around him are a joy. AnnaSophia Robb gives Sasha real warmth and backbone, Matt Dillon growls through the role of Stallone’s discouraging father, and Jay Duplass brings a prickly, productive energy to director John G. Avildsen. Stephan James is a scene stealer as Carl Weathers, Tracy Letts gets some of the biggest laughs as a studio executive who cannot grasp why this unknown refuses a pile of money, and Toby Kebbell and P.J. Byrne make Robert Chartoff and Irwin Winkler feel like gamblers who truly believe.
The film is not flawless, and its biggest weakness is how little it can surprise you. Everyone walks in knowing how this ends, and many of the behind the scenes anecdotes will be old news to devoted fans. The humor also runs broad, a few emotional beats are pushed harder than they need to be, and the story loses some of its early snap once production begins.
It also winks at the original a few times too often, as if worried we might forget what we came to see. Yet those moments never sink it, because the central question of whether this man will hold his ground keeps pulling you forward. The film understands that the real suspense was never about the ending, it was about the nerve it took to say no.
By the time the famous run up the Philadelphia museum steps arrives, I was grinning like a kid who had just been handed a ticket to a sold out show. That is a hard feeling to manufacture, and the picture earns it honestly through character rather than trickery. It leaves you with a simple, sturdy message about trusting your own conviction when everyone around you says to cash the check.
I give ‘I Play Rocky’ 8 out of 10. It is familiar, a little loud, and occasionally too fond of its own legend, but Ippolito and a generous ensemble turn a story we already know into a crowd pleaser with real heart.
Did ‘I Play Rocky’ go the distance for you, or do you think the making of ‘Rocky’ deserved to stay behind the curtain, so tell me in the comments whether you agree with my verdict?
