If You Loved ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’, Watch These 10 Similar Shows on HBO Max
‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’ is a gripping true crime docuseries that dives into the unsolved 1991 murder of four teenage girls in Austin, Texas. Its focus on grief, flawed investigations, and the impact of media makes it a standout for fans of emotional and thought-provoking crime stories.
If you were hooked by its raw storytelling and complex themes, here are ten other HBO Max shows that explore similar true crime cases, human stories, and investigative twists. Each offers a mix of mystery, emotion, and real-world impact to keep you engaged.
‘I’ll Be Gone in the Dark’ (2020)
This series follows the hunt for the Golden State Killer, a serial predator who terrorized California for decades. It blends investigative journalism with the personal story of author Michelle McNamara, who dedicated her life to solving the case.
The show dives into the emotional toll on victims’ families and the relentless pursuit of justice, much like ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’. Its mix of archival footage and interviews keeps you hooked while exploring the human side of a chilling mystery.
‘The Undoing’ (2020)
This drama follows a therapist whose perfect life unravels when her husband becomes a suspect in a brutal murder. The story unfolds through courtroom drama and personal betrayals, keeping you guessing about the truth.
Like ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’, it examines how crime disrupts lives and communities. The strong performances and psychological depth make it a compelling watch for fans of character-driven crime stories.
‘Your Honor’ (2020)
This series centers on a judge who bends the law to protect his son after a hit-and-run accident ties them to a crime family. The moral dilemmas and tense plot explore how far people go to protect loved ones.
It shares ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’’ focus on flawed systems and personal loss. The show’s gritty storytelling and ethical questions make it a great pick for those who enjoy intense crime dramas.
‘The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst’ (2015)
This docuseries investigates the life of Robert Durst, a real estate heir linked to multiple murders. Through interviews and chilling confessions, it uncovers a web of deception and unsolved cases.
Its deep dive into a complex investigation and media influence echoes ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’. The shocking twists and real-life stakes make it a must-watch for true crime fans.
‘McMillion$’ (2020)
This docuseries uncovers a scam that rigged the McDonald’s Monopoly game, leading to millions in stolen prizes. It follows the FBI’s investigation and the colorful characters caught in the scheme.
Like ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’, it blends crime with human stories and flawed investigations. The mix of humor and suspense makes it a unique but engaging true crime watch.
‘The Vow’ (2020)
This series explores the NXIVM cult, detailing how its leader manipulated followers into a web of abuse and crime. It uses firsthand accounts to reveal the psychological grip of the organization.
It connects to ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’ through its focus on trauma and the search for truth. The chilling look at manipulation and betrayal keeps you invested in the victims’ stories.
‘Allen v. Farrow’ (2021)
This docuseries examines the allegations of abuse against Woody Allen, focusing on Dylan Farrow’s story and the family’s turmoil. It combines interviews, court documents, and media analysis to unpack a controversial case.
Its exploration of grief and media scrutiny mirrors ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’. The emotional weight and complex narrative make it a powerful choice for true crime fans.
‘The Crime of the Century’ (2021)
This documentary dives into the opioid crisis, exposing how pharmaceutical companies fueled addiction for profit. It uses insider accounts and data to reveal a systemic failure.
Like ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’, it tackles a tragedy with lasting community impact. The clear, hard-hitting storytelling makes it a compelling watch for those interested in real-world consequences.
‘The Way Down: God, Greed, and the Cult of Gwen Shamblin’ (2021)
This series investigates the Remnant Fellowship Church and its leader, Gwen Shamblin, whose weight-loss program hid a darker cult-like control. It explores the deaths and abuses tied to the group.
Its focus on trauma and manipulation aligns with ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’. The mix of personal stories and investigative depth makes it a gripping true crime series.
‘In the Footsteps of Killers’ (2021)
This docuseries revisits cold cases, following investigators and families seeking answers for unsolved murders. Each episode highlights the emotional and procedural challenges of long-running cases.
It shares ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’’ focus on unresolved crimes and their lasting effects. The heartfelt interviews and persistent search for justice make it a perfect follow-up watch.
What other true crime shows on HBO Max have you found that capture the same emotional depth as ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders’? Share your picks in the comments!