If You Loved ‘Untamed’, Watch These 10 Similar Shows on Netflix
If you’re hooked on the intense mystery and wild setting of ‘Untamed’, you’re probably craving more shows that deliver the same thrilling vibe. Netflix has a lineup of crime dramas and mysteries that capture the same tension, emotional depth, and stunning backdrops as the Yosemite-set series starring Eric Bana.
I’ve rounded up ten shows that will keep you glued to your screen, each with its own mix of suspense, complex characters, and atmospheric storytelling. From small-town secrets to chilling investigations, these picks are perfect for your next binge.
The Sinner (2017-2021)
Detective Harry Ambrose digs into disturbing crimes that unravel deep psychological layers. Each season brings a fresh case, blending raw emotion with dark mysteries in gritty settings.
Bill Pullman’s quiet intensity as Ambrose carries the show, making you feel the weight of each case. It’s a slow burn that hooks you with its focus on why people snap, much like the personal struggles in ‘Untamed’.
Mare of Easttown (2021)
Kate Winslet shines as Mare Sheehan, a detective in a small Pennsylvania town tackling a murder while juggling her messy personal life. The show’s grounded feel and tight community backdrop echo the emotional stakes of ‘Untamed’.
Every episode peels back layers of secrets, with Winslet’s raw performance pulling you in. It’s a masterclass in blending character drama with a gripping whodunit.
Top of the Lake (2013-2017)
Elisabeth Moss plays Robin Griffin, a detective diving into a missing girl’s case in a remote New Zealand town. The eerie landscapes and murky secrets give it a haunting vibe similar to ‘Untamed’.
Jane Campion’s direction makes every frame feel alive, with Moss delivering a fierce yet vulnerable lead. The show’s mix of personal trauma and mystery keeps you guessing.
Cardinal (2017-2020)
Set in the icy Canadian wilderness, this show follows Detective John Cardinal as he investigates brutal crimes in Algonquin Bay. The stark setting and Cardinal’s inner demons mirror the rugged intensity of ‘Untamed’.
Billy Campbell and Karine Vanasse bring depth to their partnership, with the cold landscapes amplifying the tension. It’s a chilling ride that doesn’t let up.
The Woods (2020)
This Polish thriller weaves two timelines, following prosecutor Paweł Kopiński as he investigates a murder tied to a traumatic summer camp from 1994. The dual narratives build suspense that feels close to ‘Untamed’s’ unraveling mystery.
Grzegorz Damięcki’s understated performance anchors the show, with the forest setting adding a creepy edge. It’s a tight six episodes perfect for a weekend binge.
The Chestnut Man (2021-)
A creepy chestnut figurine links a grisly murder to a missing child in this Danish series. Detectives race to catch a killer in a tense, atmospheric story that rivals ‘Untamed’s’ wilderness intrigue.
Danica Curcic and Mikkel Boe Følsgaard drive the show with their dogged pursuit. The Nordic noir vibe and shocking twists make it hard to look away.
Dark Winds (2022-)
Navajo Tribal Police officers Joe Leaphorn and Jim Chee tackle violent crimes in the 1970s American Southwest. The desert setting and personal struggles tie it closely to ‘Untamed’s’ rugged backdrop.
Zahn McClarnon and Kiowa Gordon deliver standout performances, blending cultural depth with gritty crime drama. It’s a fresh take that feels both vast and intimate.
Dear Child (2023)
A woman escapes captivity with her kids, sparking a police investigation into her decade-long disappearance. This German miniseries dives into trauma and secrets, much like ‘Untamed’s’ emotional core.
Kim Riedle’s haunting performance keeps you hooked, with the unraveling mystery feeling raw and real. The tight pacing makes it a quick, intense watch.
Dept. Q (2025-)
DCI Carl Morck leads a cold-case unit in Scotland, digging into old crimes with new twists. The moody setting and Morck’s troubled past echo ‘Untamed’s’ investigative drive.
Matthew Goode’s layered performance adds depth, and the Scottish landscapes amplify the tension. It’s a recent gem that’s already climbing Netflix’s charts.
Broadchurch (2013-2017)
In a quiet coastal town, detectives Alec Hardy and Ellie Miller investigate a young boy’s death, uncovering dark secrets. The tight-knit community and emotional weight feel akin to ‘Untamed’.
David Tennant and Olivia Colman’s chemistry grounds the show, with its slow-building mystery keeping you invested. The scenic cliffs add a haunting touch.
Which of these thrilling shows will you dive into next, or is there another Netflix gem you’d add to the list? Drop your thoughts in the comments!