LGBTQ+ Actors Who Were Discovered in the Most Unusual Ways

The entertainment industry is full of stories about stars being discovered in grocery stores or at bus stops. For many LGBTQ+ actors the path to fame involved unique circumstances and surprising coincidences. These performers found their way into the spotlight through drama camps and viral videos and production jobs. This list explores the unusual beginnings of some of the most recognizable men in Hollywood today.

Colton Haynes

The actor was scouted by a talent agent in a mall in Ohio when he was only fifteen years old. This unexpected meeting led to a successful modeling career before he transitioned into television. He gained significant fame for his roles in popular series like ‘Teen Wolf’ and ‘Arrow’ where he portrayed complex characters. His journey from a chance encounter in a shopping center to a Hollywood star is a classic discovery story.

Nico Tortorella

This actor was discovered while walking down a street in New York City by a modeling scout. The chance encounter quickly led to professional modeling work and eventually acting roles in television and film. He is widely recognized for his work in the series ‘Younger’ and ‘The Walking Dead World Beyond’ where he showcased his versatility. His career began purely by being in the right place at the right time.

Neil Patrick Harris

The actor was discovered during a drama camp in Las Cruces New Mexico by a screenwriter. He was only a teenager when he was cast in the film ‘Clara’s Heart’ alongside Whoopi Goldberg. This chance encounter led to his breakout role as the titular character in ‘Doogie Howser M.D.’ which made him a household name at a very young age. His career transitioned from child stardom to theater and eventually to a major sitcom lead.

Chris Colfer

While auditioning for the role of Artie on the show ‘Glee’ the actor impressed the creators so much that they decided to create a new character just for him. He did not get the original part he sought but his talent led to the development of Kurt Hummel. This role became a cultural touchstone and earned him multiple awards and international recognition. It is a rare example of a character being built around a performer during the casting process.

Wentworth Miller

Before he was a lead actor he worked as a production assistant in the film industry to learn how the business functioned. He spent several years behind the scenes before deciding to move in front of the camera for auditions. His breakout role in the series ‘Prison Break’ transformed him into an international star almost overnight. This background in production gave him a unique perspective on the industry before his acting career took off.

Gus Kenworthy

This actor was primarily known as a professional skier and Olympic medalist before he made his way into scripted television. He caught the attention of producers after his high profile success in sports and his advocacy for the LGBTQ+ community. He landed a significant role in ‘American Horror Story 1984’ without following a traditional acting path. His transition from the slopes to the screen highlights how athletic fame can lead to creative opportunities.

Harvey Guillén

The actor became obsessed with acting at the age of six after watching a musical and demanding that his mother find him a class. He began his career in local commercials and small theater productions after showing immense dedication as a child. This early passion led to his breakout role as Guillermo in the series ‘What We Do in the Shadows’ where he became a fan favorite. His lifelong commitment to the craft started with a very young and determined declaration of his career goals.

Joel Kim Booster

The comedian and actor found his way into the spotlight through the underground stand up comedy scene in Chicago and New York. His unique comedic voice and writing talent eventually caught the attention of television producers. He successfully transitioned from the stage to the screen in projects like ‘Fire Island’ and ‘Loot’ where he also serves as a writer. His discovery was the result of building a loyal following through live performance and digital content.

Bowen Yang

He originally started his career at ‘Saturday Night Live’ as a staff writer rather than a performer. His talent was so evident during the writing process that he was eventually promoted to the main cast. This move made him the first Chinese American cast member in the history of the long running show. His path from the writers room to the screen is a testament to his undeniable comedic presence.

Richard Gadd

The actor gained international fame after his autobiographical one man show at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival became a massive success. This stage performance was eventually adapted into the hit series ‘Baby Reindeer’ which he also wrote and starred in. His discovery came from his willingness to share deeply personal and challenging stories on a small theater stage. The transition from a fringe theater act to a global television phenomenon is a rare and impressive feat.

Daniel Newman

The actor was discovered by a modeling scout while he was walking on the street as a young man. This chance encounter led to high fashion modeling jobs before he moved into acting in television dramas. He is well known for his appearances in ‘The Walking Dead’ and ‘The Vampire Diaries’ where he played memorable characters. His path to fame began with a random street encounter that changed the trajectory of his life.

Ncuti Gatwa

The actor spent years performing in theater and was nearly homeless before he landed his life changing role. He was discovered during the casting process for the series ‘Sex Education’ which became a global hit. This breakout performance led to him being cast as the lead in the iconic series ‘Doctor Who’ and appearing in ‘Barbie’. His story is one of perseverance and a single audition that completely transformed his professional world.

Jonathan Bennett

He was scouted by an acting coach and agent while he was sitting in a mall and traveling through different cities. This chance meeting encouraged him to pursue professional acting work in New York City where he quickly found success. He became a household name after starring as Aaron Samuels in the cult classic film ‘Mean Girls’ alongside Lindsay Lohan. His career started with a simple conversation in a public space that led to a leading man status.

Kit Connor

The actor began his career in a local drama club at the age of eight before being scouted for professional work. He spent years working in small television roles and films before landing his massive breakout role. His performance in the series ‘Heartstopper’ catapulted him to international fame and made him a leading voice for a new generation. This early start in community theater provided the foundation for his rapid rise to stardom.

Billy Porter

He became known to the general public after winning the talent competition show ‘Star Search’ in the early nineties. This victory provided him with a platform to enter the world of professional recording and Broadway theater. After decades of work he reached a new level of fame with his role in the series ‘Pose’ where he made television history. His discovery through a televised competition was the first step in a long and storied career.

Brian Michael Smith

The actor was discovered through his work in regional theater and his involvement in community advocacy programs. He made history by being one of the first trans men to have a series regular role in a broadcast television show. His performance in ‘9-1-1 Lone Star’ has been praised for its authenticity and depth. His path to the screen was paved by a dedication to both his craft and his identity.

Keiynan Lonsdale

Originally a professional dancer and musician he was found through an audition for the Australian series ‘Dance Academy’. His background in performance and dance allowed him to stand out during the casting process for major American projects. He eventually gained fame for playing Wally West in the series ‘The Flash’ and ‘Legends of Tomorrow’ within the DC Universe. His career began with movement and rhythm before he became a prominent actor and activist.

Luke Evans

The actor was discovered while he was performing on the London stage in various musical theater productions. He spent many years in the theater world before a film scout noticed his commanding presence and vocal talent. This led to his first major film role in ‘Clash of the Titans’ and eventually his portrayal of Gaston in ‘Beauty and the Beast’. His transition from the West End to Hollywood blockbusters happened relatively late in his career.

Ben Whishaw

He was found by a director while he was performing in a youth theater production of the play ‘If This Is a Man’. His performance was so powerful that it led to him being cast in the lead role of a major feature film shortly after. He is now internationally recognized as the voice of ‘Paddington’ and for his role as Q in the James Bond franchise. His discovery in a youth theater group highlights the importance of local arts programs in finding new talent.

Russell Tovey

The actor was discovered by a talent agent at a local children’s drama club when he was still a young boy. He began working professionally in television and theater almost immediately after being signed by the agency. He is known for his roles in ‘Being Human’ and ‘The History Boys’ which showcased his range as a performer. His early entry into the industry allowed him to grow up on screen and develop a diverse filmography.

Andrew Scott

He was scouted as a child to appear in television commercials in Ireland after being noticed for his expressive face and natural talent. These early experiences in front of the camera led him to pursue a formal education in acting and theater. He gained worldwide fame for his incredible portrayal of Moriarty in the series ‘Sherlock’ and as the Priest in ‘Fleabag’. His career started with small commercial spots that eventually led to some of the most iconic roles in modern television.

Matt Lucas

The actor and comedian was discovered through the London comedy circuit where he performed unique character pieces. He gained significant attention for his work on the show ‘Shooting Stars’ where he played a giant baby who played the drums. This unusual character led to the creation of ‘Little Britain’ which became a massive cultural phenomenon in the United Kingdom. His path to fame was built on experimental comedy and a willingness to be completely eccentric.

Stephen Fry

He was discovered through the Cambridge Footlights comedy troupe while he was a student at the university. His collaboration with Hugh Laurie during this time led to their own television series and a lifelong creative partnership. He is now a celebrated actor and writer known for his work in ‘Wilde’ and the ‘Sherlock Holmes’ films. His academic background and university comedy ties were the primary drivers of his entry into entertainment.

Ian McKellen

The legendary actor began his journey in student theater productions at Cambridge University before being scouted by professional directors. He spent decades establishing himself as one of the greatest stage actors of his generation before finding global film fame. He is now beloved for his roles as Gandalf in ‘The Lord of the Rings’ and Magneto in ‘X-Men’. his discovery in the world of classical theater proved that a strong foundation in the arts can lead to lifelong success.

David Hyde Pierce

He was discovered through his extensive work in the New York theater scene after graduating from Yale University. His precise comedic timing caught the attention of television producers who were casting for a new sitcom. This led to his iconic role as Niles Crane in the series ‘Frasier’ for which he won multiple Emmy Awards. His path to stardom was defined by a transition from the prestigious stages of Broadway to the living rooms of millions.

Jim Parsons

The actor worked in many off Broadway plays and television commercials for years before finding his signature role. He was discovered by casting directors who were looking for a very specific energy for a new comedy pilot. His portrayal of Sheldon Cooper in ‘The Big Bang Theory’ became one of the most successful characters in television history. His discovery was a result of years of persistence in the New York acting scene.

Zachary Quinto

He developed his skills in regional theater and small television guest spots before his major breakout. He gained widespread recognition for his chilling performance in the series ‘Heroes’ which made him a sought after actor for complex roles. He eventually stepped into the iconic role of Spock in the ‘Star Trek’ film franchise. His career trajectory shows how a steady climb through theater and television can lead to major blockbuster opportunities.

Matt Bomer

The actor was discovered through his work in professional theater companies in Texas while he was still a student. He eventually moved to New York City and found success in soap operas before transitioning to prime time television. He is best known for his lead role in ‘White Collar’ and his acclaimed performance in ‘The Normal Heart’. His journey began in the regional theater circuit before he became a prominent leading man in Hollywood.

Jonathan Groff

He found his big break in a summer stock theater production before moving to New York to pursue Broadway. He quickly became a stage star in the musical ‘Spring Awakening’ which led to television and film roles. He is widely known for his work in ‘Glee’ and for voicing Kristoff in the ‘Frozen’ films. His discovery in the world of musical theater helped him bridge the gap between the stage and the screen.

Ben Platt

The actor was discovered during a regional theater production which eventually led to his film debut in ‘Pitch Perfect’. He became a household name after his Tony Award winning performance in the Broadway musical ‘Dear Evan Hansen’. His career has spanned across theater and music and television with significant success in each area. His early start in musical theater provided the platform for him to become a major star in various mediums.

Jeremy Jordan

He gained significant attention through a musical theater showcase while he was still in college. This led to his casting in major Broadway productions like ‘Newsies’ and ‘Bonnie and Clyde’. He successfully transitioned to television with a lead role in the series ‘Smash’ and a regular part in ‘Supergirl’. His discovery was the result of a single showcase that proved his immense vocal and acting talent.

Tituss Burgess

The actor was discovered through various Disney theme park productions where he performed as a singer. This work led him to Broadway where he appeared in shows like ‘The Little Mermaid’ and ‘Guys and Dolls’. He found mainstream fame for his role as Titus Andromedon in the series ‘Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt’. His path from theme park performer to Emmy nominated actor is one of the more unique stories in the industry.

Andrew Rannells

He was found through his work in national touring companies and Broadway shows such as ‘Hairspray’. He gained major recognition for his lead role in the original cast of the musical ‘The Book of Mormon’. This success led to prominent roles in television series like ‘Girls’ and ‘The New Normal’. His discovery through the theater world allowed him to showcase his comedic and vocal range to a wide audience.

Jesse Tyler Ferguson

He was discovered after his standout performance in the Broadway musical ‘The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee’. This role caught the eye of television producers who were casting for a new family sitcom. He went on to star as Mitchell Pritchett in the hit series ‘Modern Family’ for over a decade. His background in ensemble theater helped him become part of one of the most successful casts in television history.

Victor Garber

Originally a member of a folk singing group called The Sugar Shoppe the actor performed on variety shows in the late sixties. He transitioned into stage acting and found massive success in both musicals and dramas on Broadway. He is known for his roles in the film ‘Titanic’ and the television series ‘Alias’ and ‘Legends of Tomorrow’. His discovery as a singer was the first step in a career that has spanned over five decades.

BD Wong

The actor was discovered through his groundbreaking performance in the play ‘M. Butterfly’ on Broadway. He made history by being the only actor to win the Tony and Drama Desk and Outer Critics Circle awards for the same role. He transitioned to film and television with significant roles in ‘Jurassic Park’ and ‘Law and Order Special Victims Unit’. His discovery in a high profile play established him as a major talent in the industry.

Cheyenne Jackson

He was found through his work in regional and community theater productions in the Pacific Northwest. He eventually moved to New York and became a leading man on Broadway in shows like ‘All Shook Up’. He transitioned to television with recurring roles in ’30 Rock’ and ‘American Horror Story’. His path to fame shows that talent in regional theater can lead to a successful career on the national stage.

Rupert Everett

The actor was discovered by a talent scout while he was working as a professional model in London. This led to his breakout role in the play and film ‘Another Country’ which established him as a major star. He is well known for his roles in ‘My Best Friend’s Wedding’ and ‘The Importance of Being Earnest’. His career began with his physical presence in modeling before he proved his depth as a classical actor.

Murray Bartlett

He found his early success in Australian soap operas like ‘Neighbors’ before moving to the United States to pursue a career. After many years of character work he gained international fame for his role in the first season of ‘The White Lotus’. This performance earned him an Emmy Award and led to major roles in ‘The Last of Us’. His discovery was a slow build that culminated in a massive late career breakthrough.

Billy Eichner

The actor was discovered through his high energy street comedy videos that went viral on the internet. His show ‘Billy on the Street’ became a cult hit and led to voice roles in ‘The Lion King’ and acting roles in ‘American Horror Story’. He also wrote and starred in the romantic comedy ‘Bros’ which was a major milestone for LGBTQ+ cinema. His path to fame was entirely self made through digital content and unique public performances.

Randy Rainbow

He became a viral sensation after posting parody videos on social media that combined musical theater and political commentary. His unique blend of humor and vocal talent caught the attention of major celebrities and media outlets. He has since performed sold out tours and received multiple Emmy nominations for his digital content. His discovery occurred in his own living room where he created the videos that launched his career.

Jordan Gavaris

The actor was discovered through an open casting call in Canada for the series ‘Orphan Black’. His performance as Felix Dawkins was so convincing that many viewers did not realize he was not actually British. This role became a fan favorite and earned him several awards for his acting. His discovery through a traditional audition process for an independent production led to a major international following.

Ezra Miller

The actor was discovered at the age of six while performing as a singer in a contemporary opera. This early exposure to the arts led to professional acting roles in independent films like ‘We Need to Talk About Kevin’. He eventually joined major franchises as the Flash in the DC Universe and Credence in ‘Fantastic Beasts’. His career started with a specialized musical performance that showcased his talent at a very young age.

Anthony Rapp

He began his career as a child actor after winning a role in a local play through an open audition. He eventually moved to New York and became a part of the original cast of the landmark musical ‘Rent’. This role defined his career and led to work in major films and the series ‘Star Trek Discovery’. His early discovery in community theater was the foundation for his long standing presence on stage and screen.

Wilson Cruz

The actor was discovered during a stage reading in Los Angeles by a producer who was casting for a new teen drama. This led to his historic role as Rickie Vasquez in ‘My So Called Life’ which was the first gay teenager character on network television. He has since become a prominent actor and advocate for the LGBTQ+ community. His discovery in a small reading resulted in one of the most important roles in television history.

Haaz Sleiman

He was scouted while performing in a local theater production after moving to the United States from Lebanon. This led to his breakout role in the film ‘The Visitor’ which received critical acclaim and an Academy Award nomination. He has since appeared in numerous television series and played a major role in the film ‘Eternals’. His discovery happened after he took a risk to move across the world to pursue his dreams.

Conrad Ricamora

The actor was primarily known for his work in the New York theater scene before he was cast in a major television drama. He gained widespread recognition for his role as Oliver Hampton in the series ‘How to Get Away with Murder’. He has successfully balanced his time between filming for television and performing in major Broadway musicals. His discovery in theater proved that stage talent can easily translate to compelling television performances.

Dominic Burgess

He was found through his work in the British theater scene and small television roles in the United Kingdom. After moving to Los Angeles he began landing roles in major series like ‘Feud Bette and Joan’ and ‘The Good Place’. He is known for his character work and his ability to transform into diverse roles. His path to Hollywood began with a solid foundation in British stage performance and a move to the American market.

Luke Macfarlane

The actor was discovered during a Juilliard showcase which is a performance for industry professionals to see graduating students. This showcase led to his first major television roles and eventually his starring part in ‘Brothers and Sisters’. He has since become a staple of television films and starred in the major theatrical release ‘Bros’. His discovery was the direct result of his formal training and a high stakes performance in front of talent scouts.

Share your thoughts on these unique paths to stardom in the comments.