‘Paper Tiger’ Movie Review: What Does Wanting Just a Little More Really Cost?
Set in the fall of 1986 in Queens, ‘Paper Tiger’ opens on a family that is doing fine and would like to do a little better. James Gray’s new crime drama follows engineer Irwin Pearl (Miles Teller), his wife Hester (Scarlett Johansson), and their two teenage sons, Scott and Ben. After premiering in competition at Cannes, the film now arrives in theaters through Neon.
The temptation shows up wearing a sharp suit. Irwin’s older brother Gary (Adam Driver), a former cop turned consultant, drops by with a steakhouse dinner and a pitch about helping new Russian business owners handle the polluted Gowanus Canal. With college bills looming, Irwin says yes to a job that every instinct should have told him to refuse.
What impressed me first is how fast the movie stops being polite. One nighttime visit to the canal with his boys turns a warm family comedy into something genuinely frightening, and Gray never lets the dread fully lift afterward. That sustained unease is the best thing about ‘Paper Tiger’, and it kept me gripped long after the credits started.
Driver is the engine. Gary’s swagger is a kind of armor, and watching it crumble in front of men who hold real power is the most compelling thing on screen. Teller plays Irwin as a decent, slightly goofy father whose best qualities are exactly what get him in trouble, and the quiet moments where he realizes how far out of his depth he is hit harder than any shouting match. Victor Ptak makes the Russian boss Semion Bogoyavich quietly chilling, which only sharpens the stakes.
Gray and cinematographer Joaquín Baca-Asay shoot on 35 mm film, and the grain and amber light give the whole picture a dreamlike glow that feels one step from nightmare. A shootout in tall grass near an airport is superbly staged, and a nighttime intrusion in the Pearl home is the kind of sequence that makes you dread every dark doorway afterward. The violence is rare, and that restraint is exactly why it works.
Not every thread pays off, though. Hester’s illness gives Johansson some of her most affecting moments, yet it runs on a parallel track and never fully locks into the central story. The stretches between the big set pieces can also feel slower than they should, and the broad shape of this tale, brothers and crime and compromise, is territory Gray has walked before.
Still, there is real feeling behind the familiar outline. The story began as a possible follow up to ‘Armageddon Time’, and that personal root shows in how the camera now sits with the parents rather than the child, treating their fears and failures with tenderness. It turns a tense thriller into a family portrait with a pulse.
Weighing the nerve-shredding set pieces and the superb performances against the uneven pacing and a side plot that drifts, I came away deeply impressed and a little shaken. ‘Paper Tiger’ is a patient, painful, beautifully made crime tragedy, and I give it 9 out of 10.
Did ‘Paper Tiger’ earn that score in your eyes, or do you think the brothers’ fate was sealed far too early, so tell me in the comments?
