10 Scenes From ‘You’ That Shocked Everyone

The psychological thriller ‘You’ has kept audiences on edge with its chilling narrative and shocking moments. Centered on Joe Goldberg, a charismatic yet deeply disturbed bookstore manager, the series explores obsession, manipulation, and morality in a way that’s both gripping and unsettling. Since its debut, the show has built a reputation for delivering jaw-dropping scenes that spark endless discussions.

Penn Badgley’s portrayal of Joe, a man who blends charm with menace, anchors the series, while the talented ensemble cast brings depth to his victims and accomplices. Across its seasons, ‘You’ (2018-2025) weaves a dark tapestry of surprises that challenge expectations and keep viewers guessing. Here are ten scenes that stunned everyone, ranked from least to most shocking, each leaving an indelible mark.

10. Joe’s Cage Reveal in Season 1

The moment Joe’s secret glass cage is revealed in the bookstore’s basement sent chills down my spine. When Mooney locks Beck inside, we see the depths of Joe’s obsessive control, a place where his victims are trapped both physically and psychologically.

This scene, from ‘You’ (2018-2025), sets the tone for Joe’s twisted methods, showing his calculated nature. The cold, sterile cage contrasts with his outwardly charming persona, making it a haunting introduction to his darker side.

9. Candace’s Return in Season 2

Candace’s unexpected reappearance in Season 2, alive after Joe believed her dead, was a gut punch. Played by Ambyr Childers, she confronts Joe at his new bookstore, unraveling his carefully crafted fresh start in Los Angeles.

Her survival flips the narrative, proving Joe’s past can’t be buried. This moment in ‘You’ (2018-2025) shocked me with its bold twist, setting up a season of reckoning for Joe’s crimes.

8. Delilah’s Tragic Fate in Season 2

Delilah’s murder in the cage, discovered by Joe after he blacks out, hit hard. Her lifeless body, throat slashed, marks a brutal end to a character who seemed poised to expose Joe’s secrets.

In ‘You’ (2018-2025), this scene stunned me with its raw violence and the mystery of Joe’s lost time. It deepens the tragedy of his orbit, where even those who get close meet grim ends.

7. Beck’s Heartbreaking Discovery in Season 1

When Beck finds Joe’s hidden box of trophies—items from his victims, including her own belongings—the truth crashes down. Her realization in the bookstore basement that Joe is a stalker and killer is pure dread.

This pivotal moment in ‘You’ (2018-2025) left me shaken as Beck’s world collapses. Elizabeth Lail’s performance captures her terror, making the scene a devastating turning point.

6. Love’s Killer Instinct in Season 2

Love Quinn revealing herself as a murderer by killing Candace to protect Joe was a jaw-dropping twist. Victoria Pedretti’s character, initially sweet, mirrors Joe’s darkness, stabbing Candace in a chilling act.

This scene from ‘You’ (2018-2025) shocked me with its sudden violence and upended expectations. Love’s transformation into Joe’s equal in depravity redefines the season’s dynamic.

5. Forty’s Death in Season 2

Forty’s shooting by Officer Fincher outside the bookstore was a brutal shock. Just as he’s about to expose Joe, a stray bullet ends his life, leaving Joe and Love stunned.

In ‘You’ (2018-2025), James Scully’s chaotic yet tragic Forty made this moment hit hard. The randomness of his death underscored the collateral damage of Joe’s world.

4. Joe’s Imprisonment in Season 3

When Love locks Joe in the glass cage, turning the tables on her own husband, the tension skyrockets. Her betrayal, using the cage Joe built, reveals her cunning and desperation to control him.

This scene in ‘You’ (2018-2025) left me floored by its irony and intensity. It marks a shift where Joe, usually the predator, becomes the prey, highlighting Love’s dangerous unpredictability.

3. The Murder-Suicide Pact in Season 3

Love’s plan to kill Joe and herself in their suburban home, only for Joe to outmaneuver her with a hidden syringe, was a heart-pounding climax. Her death, orchestrated by Joe, seals their toxic love story.

In ‘You’ (2018-2025), this moment stunned me with its high-stakes betrayal. The quiet menace of Joe’s victory over Love’s rage made it unforgettable.

2. Joe’s Direct Address in Season 4

Joe staring into the camera and saying ‘It’s you’ in Season 4, breaking the fourth wall, felt like a personal accusation. Set to ‘Creep’ by Radiohead, it pulls viewers into his twisted psyche.

This bold move in ‘You’ (2018-2025) caught me off guard, blurring the line between observer and accomplice. It’s a chilling reminder of Joe’s manipulative charm, making my skin crawl.

1. Beck’s Death in Season 1

Beck’s murder by Joe in the cage, after she nearly escapes, remains the most shocking moment. Her desperate fight for survival ends in tragedy as Joe strangles her, cementing his monstrous nature.

In ‘You’ (2018-2025), this scene left me reeling with its cold finality. Elizabeth Lail’s raw performance and the betrayal of hope made it a gut-wrenching blow that lingers.

Which scene from ‘You’ left you stunned, or is there a moment I missed? Drop your thoughts in the comments!