Series Where LGBTQ+ Side Characters Vanished After Season One

Television narratives often involve a rotating cast of supporting players who help flesh out the world of the central protagonists. In many instances, LGBTQ+ side characters are introduced with significant story arcs only to disappear or be written out after the conclusion of the first season. Whether due to plot-driven deaths, creative shifts, or the nature of anthology storytelling, these departures can leave fans wondering what happened to characters who initially showed great promise. Exploring these instances reveals patterns in how supporting queer identities have been integrated and occasionally discarded in modern TV history.

‘Bridgerton’ (2020–Present)

In the first season of this Regency-era drama, Sir Henry Granville is introduced as a talented artist who befriends Benedict Bridgerton. He introduces Benedict to an underground artistic community where he lives more openly with his lover, Lord Wetherby. While Granville serves as a pivotal mentor figure, his character does not appear in subsequent seasons. The show shifts its focus to different siblings and their respective social circles, leaving Granville’s story behind.

‘Chilling Adventures of Sabrina’ (2018–2020)

Luke Chalfant is a warlock introduced in the first season as a potential romantic interest for Ambrose Spellman. The two share several scenes that explore the complexities of magical relationships within the Church of Night. However, the character is abruptly killed off-screen between the first and second parts of the series. His death is used primarily as a plot device to further Ambrose’s individual story arc.

‘Empire’ (2015–2020)

India is introduced as Tiana Brown’s secret girlfriend during the first season of this musical drama. Her presence creates a public relations challenge for the Lyons family as they attempt to manage Tiana’s rising pop career. Despite the initial focus on their relationship and the queer representation it provided, India disappears entirely after the first season. Tiana’s romantic storylines in later years focus almost exclusively on male counterparts.

‘How to Get Away with Murder’ (2014–2020)

Aiden Walker appears in the first season as the ex-fiancé of Connor Walsh, a law student and series regular. The storyline explores their past history and the tension Aiden’s presence creates between Connor and Oliver Hampton. Aiden is ultimately revealed to be struggling with his own identity within the context of his political aspirations. Following the resolution of this arc, the character is never mentioned or seen again for the remainder of the series.

‘Ugly Betty’ (2006–2010)

Vincent is the first serious love interest for Alexis Meade, a transgender woman and high-ranking executive at ‘Mode’ magazine. Their relationship provides a grounded look at Alexis’s personal life following her transition and return to New York. However, the character’s presence is limited to the first season and does not carry over into future narratives. Alexis eventually moves on to other romantic interests before her own eventual departure from the show.

‘Brothers and Sisters’ (2006–2011)

Chad Barry is a closeted actor who enters into a complicated relationship with Kevin Walker during the first season. Their arc focuses on the difficulties of navigating a high-profile Hollywood career while maintaining a secret personal life. After Kevin decides he cannot be in a relationship with someone who is not out, Chad eventually exits the show. The character does not return in later seasons as Kevin pursues more stable long-term partners.

‘True Blood’ (2008–2014)

Eddie Gauthier is a vampire who reluctantly becomes a source of blood for Lafayette Reynolds in the debut season. He is depicted as a gentle soul who stands in stark contrast to many of the more aggressive vampires in the series. His narrative ends tragically when he is kidnapped and subsequently killed by Amy Burley and Jason Stackhouse. This loss marks the end of his character’s journey, and he is not seen again in the show’s mythology.

‘Scream Queens’ (2015–2016)

Sam, often referred to by her nickname “Predatory Lez,” is a pledge of the Kappa Kappa Tau sorority in the first season. She is characterized by her cynical attitude and her burgeoning interest in fellow pledge Hester Ulrich. Sam becomes one of the many victims of the Red Devil killer during the middle of the season. When the series moved to a hospital setting for the second season, many original characters were omitted, including those who had survived.

‘Quantico’ (2015–2018)

Elias Harper is an analyst trainee at the FBI academy who frequently clashes with Simon Asher during the first season. Their relationship is defined by intellectual rivalry and Elias’s suspicion regarding Simon’s past and motivations. Elias is eventually revealed to be a reluctant accomplice in the season’s central terrorist plot. He dies by suicide after confessing his involvement, ensuring he would not appear in subsequent seasons.

‘American Horror Story’ (2011–Present)

Chad Warwick is one of the ghostly residents of the central haunted house in the debut season, ‘Murder House’. He is the partner of Patrick, and the two are depicted in flashbacks as they struggle to save their failing relationship before their deaths. As an anthology series, the show shifts to a new story and cast for each subsequent season. While several actors from the first season return in new roles, Chad remains a fixture of the ‘Murder House’ story specifically.

‘Orange Is the New Black’ (2013–2019)

Tricia Miller is a young inmate at Litchfield Penitentiary known for her braids and her struggle with addiction. In the first season, she is involved in a secret relationship with fellow inmate Mercy Valduto. Tricia’s storyline explores her vulnerability and the harsh realities of the prison system’s failure to provide support. Her character dies of a drug overdose late in the first season, preventing her from appearing in later arcs.

‘Killing Eve’ (2018–2022)

Bill Pargrave is Eve Polastri’s close friend and colleague at MI5 who is depicted as a bisexual man with a family. He provides emotional support and professional guidance to Eve as she begins her obsession with the assassin Villanelle. Bill travels to Berlin to assist in the investigation but is murdered by Villanelle in a crowded nightclub. His death serves as the primary catalyst for Eve’s personal vendetta throughout the rest of the series.

‘Gossip Girl’ (2007–2012)

Asher Hornsby is a student at St. Jude’s who dates Jenny Humphrey as a cover for his secret relationship with Eric van der Woodsen. The storyline culminates in Asher being publicly outed at a party, which leads to his immediate social exile and departure from the series. While Eric continues as a recurring character for several seasons, Asher is never seen or mentioned again. This arc served as one of the show’s early explorations of LGBTQ+ themes within its high-society setting.

‘Scream: The TV Series’ (2015–2019)

Rachel Murray is introduced in the first season as a quiet, artistic girl who is secretly dating Audrey Jensen. Her death early in the season serves as a major emotional blow to Audrey and propels much of the season’s mystery. Rachel is murdered by the Brandon James killer, who stages her death to look like a suicide. Her character does not reappear, though her absence continues to influence Audrey’s character development throughout the second season.

‘House of the Dragon’ (2022–Present)

Joffrey Lonmouth is introduced as the “Knight of Kisses” and the secret lover of Ser Laenor Velaryon during the first season. Their relationship is depicted as a deeply committed bond that exists beneath the surface of royal expectations and duty. However, Joffrey’s story comes to a violent end during the wedding festivities of Laenor and Rhaenyra Targaryen. He is brutally killed by Ser Criston Cole in the middle of the Great Hall, ensuring the character would not appear in subsequent seasons.

‘The Last of Us’ (2023–Present)

Bill and Frank are featured in a standalone narrative during the first season that explores their decades-long relationship in the post-apocalyptic world. Their story is told through a series of flashbacks, showcasing how they built a life together amidst the chaos of the Cordyceps outbreak. The episode concludes with their joint decision to end their lives peacefully on their own terms as they age and face health challenges. Because their arc is self-contained and takes place entirely in the past relative to the main timeline, they do not return for the second season.

‘The White Lotus’ (2021–Present)

Armond is the fastidious and increasingly unhinged resort manager whose downward spiral anchors the first season of this anthology series. His interactions with the guests, particularly his sexual encounters and drug use, lead to a chaotic and ultimately fatal climax in the season finale. As the show follows a completely new group of travelers and staff in each subsequent season, Armond’s story remains confined to the original Hawaii setting. The character serves as a central point of conflict for the initial installment.

‘Cruel Summer’ (2021–2023)

Vince Fuller is a loyal friend to Jeanette Turner whose blossoming romance with Ben Hallowell is depicted across three years in the first season. Their storyline highlights the challenges of being queer in a small Texas town during the 1990s. Because the show adopted an anthology format for its second season, the entire original cast was replaced. As a result, Vince and Ben’s story remains confined entirely to the debut season of the series.

‘You’ (2018–2024)

Peach Salinger is a wealthy socialite and the best friend of Guinevere Beck during the first season of this thriller. She is characterized by her intense and possessive feelings for Beck, which often put her at odds with the protagonist, Joe Goldberg. After discovering Joe’s true nature, Peach is involved in a violent confrontation that ends in her death. Following her departure from the show, Joe moves to different cities, and the narrative focuses on new obsessions.

‘The Politician’ (2019–2020)

River Barkley is the charismatic opponent and former lover of the protagonist, Payton Hobart, in the first season. Despite dying in the pilot episode, he appears throughout the season as a manifestation of Payton’s conscience and emotional struggle. Their romantic history and intellectual connection form the emotional backbone of the initial narrative. However, when the setting moves to New York for the second season, River’s presence is significantly diminished as Payton pursues new political ambitions.

Please share your thoughts on these character departures in the comments.