20 Shows That Turned Villains into Heroes Because Fans Asked

Television history is filled with characters who were introduced as antagonists but stuck around long enough to become the hero. Writers often plan for a villain to have a short arc or a definitive death until audience reaction changes the trajectory of the story. Viewers sometimes latch onto a charismatic performance or a compelling backstory which forces the creators to rethink the character’s future. This phenomenon has led to some of the most complex redemption arcs in media history. The following series demonstrate how fan engagement can fundamentally alter the fate of a show’s bad guy.

‘Buffy the Vampire Slayer’ (1997–2003)

Spike was originally introduced as a short-term villain who was supposed to die at the hands of the slayer. James Marsters delivered such a charismatic performance that fans immediately clamored for his character to remain on the show. The writers eventually integrated him into the main cast and gave him a complex redemption arc that involved him fighting for a soul. His evolution from a bloodthirsty vampire to a self-sacrificing hero became one of the most celebrated storylines in the series.

‘Stranger Things’ (2016–2025)

Steve Harrington began the series as a stereotypical high school bully who served as an antagonist to the main group. The creators originally planned for him to remain unlikable or potentially die during the first season. Joe Keery brought a surprising amount of charm and nuance to the role which convinced the Duffer Brothers to rewrite his character trajectory. Steve eventually transformed into a brave protector and a beloved father figure for the younger kids in the cast.

‘Dragon Ball Z’ (1989–1996)

Vegeta arrived on Earth as a ruthless conqueror who had no qualms about destroying planets or killing innocents. His immense popularity with the fanbase persuaded the creator Akira Toriyama to keep him alive despite the initial plan for his demise. The Saiyan Prince slowly transitioned from a deadly enemy to a reluctant ally and finally a devoted family man. He now stands alongside Goku as one of the primary defenders of Earth against cosmic threats.

‘The Vampire Diaries’ (2009–2017)

Damon Salvatore spent the first season of the show terrorizing the town of Mystic Falls and serving as the primary antagonist to his brother Stefan. Ian Somerhalder played the role with a mix of danger and wit that made him an instant favorite among viewers. The writers responded to this reception by exploring his tragic past and softening his malicious tendencies over time. Damon eventually became a romantic lead and a hero who was willing to sacrifice everything for the people he loved.

‘Lost’ (2004–2010)

Ben Linus entered the narrative as a mysterious and manipulative leader of the Others who tormented the survivors of Oceanic Flight 815. Michael Emerson was only booked for a handful of episodes before his chilling performance earned him a permanent spot in the cast. The character remained morally ambiguous throughout the series but eventually aligned himself with the protagonists to save the island. His journey concluded with him serving as a humble advisor and seeking redemption for his past crimes.

‘The Walking Dead’ (2010–2022)

Negan burst onto the screen as a brutal tyrant who executed beloved characters to assert his dominance. His charisma and the complex performance by Jeffrey Dean Morgan kept viewers invested in his survival despite his horrific actions. The showrunners slowly integrated him into the core group of survivors after years of imprisonment and reflection. He eventually proved his loyalty by protecting the children of the very people he once terrorized.

‘Once Upon a Time’ (2011–2018)

Regina Mills began the series as the Evil Queen who cursed an entire kingdom to misery just to satisfy her need for revenge. Fans adored the complexity Lana Parrilla brought to the role and rooted for her happiness despite her villainous origins. The writers crafted a long redemption arc that saw her move from a primary antagonist to the savior of the magical realms. She ultimately earned the title of the Good Queen and ruled with compassion rather than fear.

‘Mighty Morphin Power Rangers’ (1993–1995)

Tommy Oliver debuted as the Green Ranger who was brainwashed by Rita Repulsa to destroy the Power Rangers. The character became so popular with the young audience that the producers decided to bring him back after his initial evil arc concluded. He returned as the White Ranger and eventually became the leader of the team. Tommy remains the most iconic Ranger in the franchise history due to this legendary transition from foe to friend.

‘Game of Thrones’ (2011–2019)

Jaime Lannister pushed a child out of a tower in the very first episode and established himself as a despicable knight without honor. His journey took a turn when he lost his hand and formed an unlikely bond with Brienne of Tarth. Viewers began to sympathize with his internal struggle as he tried to define himself apart from his manipulative family. He spent much of the later seasons fighting for the living before his complex story came to an end.

‘Avatar: The Last Airbender’ (2005–2008)

Prince Zuko spent the majority of the series hunting the Avatar to restore his honor and regain his father’s approval. The audience resonated with his internal conflict and his relationship with his wise uncle Iroh. This support bolstered the writers’ plan to have him switch sides and teach Aang firebending. His transformation from a banished prince to the Fire Lord who ended the war is often cited as a masterclass in character development.

‘Heroes’ (2006–2010)

Sylar was introduced as a terrifying serial killer who hunted superpowered individuals to steal their abilities. Zachary Quinto made the villain so compelling that the writers kept finding reasons to keep him in the story. The character oscillated between good and evil multiple times as the show attempted to redeem him. He eventually found a measure of peace and worked alongside the protagonists to save the world.

‘True Blood’ (2008–2014)

Eric Northman started as a cold and calculating vampire sheriff who viewed humans as little more than food or entertainment. Alexander Skarsgård played the character with a magnetic intensity that quickly won over the audience. The series gradually peeled back his layers to reveal a fierce loyalty and a capacity for deep love. He became a central hero in the narrative and often put his own life at risk to protect Sookie Stackhouse.

‘Supernatural’ (2005–2020)

Crowley appeared initially as a crossroads demon and a self-serving antagonist who constantly created problems for the Winchester brothers. Mark Sheppard made the King of Hell so witty and entertaining that he became a series regular. His relationship with the brothers evolved into a dysfuctional alliance where he often helped them against greater threats. He ultimately sacrificed his own life to seal a rift and save the world from destruction.

‘Gossip Girl’ (2007–2012)

Chuck Bass was presented in the pilot episode as a predatory and manipulative bad boy with few redeeming qualities. His chemistry with Blair Waldorf and Ed Westwick’s performance turned him into a fan favorite almost immediately. The writers focused heavily on his growth and his attempts to overcome his toxic upbringing. He ended the series as a successful businessman and a devoted husband who had moved past his villainous youth.

‘Veronica Mars’ (2004–2019)

Logan Echolls was the obligatory privileged bully who made life difficult for the title character. Jason Dohring brought a surprising depth to the role that revealed the abuse he suffered at home. The chemistry between him and Veronica was undeniable and prompted the writers to pair them up romantically. Logan transformed from a hated antagonist into a reliable protector and the primary love interest of the series.

‘Xena: Warrior Princess’ (1995–2001)

Xena first appeared as a ruthless warlord in ‘Hercules: The Legendary Journeys’ who sought to kill the titular hero. The character proved so popular with viewers that the producers created a spinoff series focused entirely on her redemption. She spent the duration of her own show traveling the world to atone for the sins of her past. Xena is now recognized as one of the greatest television heroes of all time.

‘Teen Wolf’ (2011–2017)

Derek Hale started the series as a mysterious and somewhat menacing werewolf who intimidated the main character Scott McCall. Tyler Hoechlin’s portrayal garnered a massive fanbase that wanted to see more of his backstory. The show explored his tragic history and his desire to build a new pack based on loyalty. He evolved into a mentor figure who guided the younger werewolves and fought to protect Beacon Hills.

‘She-Ra and the Princesses of Power’ (2018–2020)

Catra began the series as the best friend turned bitter enemy of the main heroine Adora. Her emotional turmoil and complex motivations resonated deeply with fans and critics alike. The creators carefully built a narrative that allowed her to confront her trauma and make amends for her destructive choices. She ended the show by saving the universe alongside Adora and confirming their romantic connection.

‘The O.C.’ (2003–2007)

Julie Cooper was the materialistic and manipulative mother who constantly schemed against the protagonist Ryan Atwood. Melinda Clarke made the character delightfully wicked yet surprisingly human which prevented fans from truly hating her. Over four seasons she went through a significant transformation that saw her earn her own degree and repair her relationship with her daughter. She finished the series as a grounded and independent woman who finally prioritized her family.

‘Gotham’ (2014–2019)

Oswald Cobblepot started as a low-level snitch who was mocked by the criminal underworld of Gotham City. Robin Lord Taylor delivered a breakout performance that made the Penguin the most fascinating character on the show. The writers expanded his role significantly and turned him into a central figure in the city’s power struggles. While he remained a criminal he often acted as a necessary evil and a strange ally to Jim Gordon when the city faced destruction.

Tell us which of these villainous transformations surprised you the most by sharing your opinion in the comments.