The 25 Best Hallmark Channel Actors, Ranked

From cozy small town romances to seasonal favorites, certain performers have become fixtures of Hallmark storytelling. These actors anchor long running series, headline event trilogies, and bring reliable charm to dozens of originals each year. Here is a countdown of fan favorite faces who consistently lead Hallmark movies and series, along with the key projects that made them staples of the channel.

25. Victor Webster

Victor Webster has headlined multiple mysteries and seasonal romances across the network. He co stars in the long running ‘MatchMaker Mysteries’ franchise. Viewers also know him from holiday titles like ‘A Christmas Cookie Catastrophe’. His Hallmark work spans contemporary rom coms and light mysteries that showcase an easygoing leading man style.

24. Aimee Teegarden

Aimee Teegarden has led modern Hallmark romances that lean into careers and second chances. She starred in ‘My Christmas Family Tree’ and ‘Christmas Class Reunion’. She often plays capable professionals navigating unexpected relationships. Her projects highlight heartfelt connections with a grounded tone.

23. Marcus Rosner

Marcus Rosner appears frequently as the romantic lead in seasonal movies and wedding themed stories. Credits include ‘The Love Club’ entries and ‘Notes of Autumn’. He brings a mix of entrepreneur and outdoorsy characters to contemporary settings. His filmography covers both spring romances and holiday premieres.

22. Heather Hemmens

Heather Hemmens has fronted multiple recent originals across Hallmark and Hallmark Movies and Mysteries. She starred in ‘A Pinch of Portugal’ and ‘Christmas in Vienna’ appearances alongside ensemble casts. Her roles often feature ambitious creatives and chefs. She also brings music and dance elements into several projects.

21. Wes Brown

Wes Brown is a frequent Hallmark lead known for small town charmers and scenic settings. His titles include ‘Under the Autumn Moon’ and ‘Christmas in Mississippi’. He often plays ranchers, writers, or hometown heroes returning to their roots. His films emphasize family traditions and community ties.

20. Rachel Boston

Rachel Boston anchors fall harvest and holiday stories with creative or entrepreneurial characters. She starred in ‘A Christmas Carousel’ and ‘The Last Bridesmaid’. Many of her films pair art restoration, event planning, or music with romance. She often collaborates with returning co stars across seasonal lineups.

19. Holly Robinson Peete

Holly Robinson Peete headlines the ‘Morning Show Mysteries’ series as a television chef turned sleuth. She also stars in holiday films like ‘Christmas in Evergreen’ entries. Her projects frequently highlight family, food, and community service. She brings a warm investigative energy to mystery formats.

18. Chris McNally

Chris McNally is a core cast member on ‘When Calls the Heart’ as Lucas Bouchard. He also leads standalone romances such as ‘Sailing Into Love’. His Hallmark work often features refined professionals who find love in frontier or coastal settings. He appears in both period and contemporary productions.

17. Pascale Hutton

Pascale Hutton stars on ‘When Calls the Heart’ as Rosemary Coulter. She headlines modern romances like ‘You Had Me at Aloha’. Her filmography mixes comedic energy with heartfelt storylines. She frequently teams up with longtime co star Kavan Smith across multiple titles.

16. Kevin McGarry

Kevin McGarry portrays Nathan Grant on ‘When Calls the Heart’. He also leads films like ‘My Grown Up Christmas List’. His roles often center on first responders, teachers, or military service members. He brings steady presence to both series arcs and single film romances.

15. Alison Sweeney

Alison Sweeney anchors the ‘Hannah Swensen Mysteries’ franchise as a baker turned detective. She also stars in contemporary romances like ‘The Wedding Veil Journey’ appearances. Her Hallmark projects often weave culinary themes with investigative plots. She is involved in producing several of her films.

14. Kristoffer Polaha

Kristoffer Polaha co leads the ‘Mystery 101’ franchise as a detective alongside a criminology professor. He also stars in romances such as ‘Dater’s Handbook’ and ‘A Winter’s Dream’ style titles. His characters frequently balance wit with sincerity. He appears across seasonal schedules including fall and winter premieres.

13. Taylor Cole

Taylor Cole headlines travel and destination romances across the network. Notable titles include ‘One Winter Weekend’ and ‘Ruby Herring Mysteries’. She often portrays journalists, photographers, or entrepreneurs. Her films highlight scenic resorts, ski towns, and coastal escapes.

12. Ryan Paevey

Ryan Paevey is a go to lead for Christmas romances and summer originals. His credits include ‘Two Tickets to Paradise’ and ‘Coyote Creek Christmas’. He frequently plays architects, writers, and adventure guides who find love while traveling. Many of his films pair scenic island or mountain locales with meet cutes.

11. Autumn Reeser

Autumn Reeser stars in event trilogies and heartfelt seasonal films. She co leads ‘The Wedding Veil’ trilogy entries with an emphasis on art history and friendship. Other titles include ‘Always Amore’ and travel centric romances. She often plays driven professionals who rediscover balance through love.

10. Kimberley Sustad

Kimberley Sustad is known for clever high concept romances and dynamic chemistry with co stars. Her titles include ‘Christmas by Starlight’ and ‘A Christmas Cookie Catastrophe’. She often develops or co writes projects behind the scenes. Her characters balance quick wit with tender family stories.

9. Brennan Elliott

Brennan Elliott headlines mystery and romance projects across both Hallmark channels. He co stars in ‘Crossword Mysteries’ and appears opposite frequent collaborator Lacey Chabert. His roles span doctors, reporters, and small business owners. He brings steady leading man presence to multi film franchises.

8. Paul Campbell

Paul Campbell combines comedic timing with heartfelt storytelling in top performing originals. He co wrote and starred in ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’. Other titles include workplace and travel romances like ‘The Santa Stakeout’ appearances. He frequently collaborates with Andrew Walker and Tyler Hynes.

7. Nikki DeLoach

Nikki DeLoach leads emotional contemporary romances with music and family themes. Her films include ‘Two Turtle Doves’, ‘Five More Minutes’, and ‘The Perfect Catch’. She often works with screenwriters on personal stories that resonate with viewers. Many of her projects center on grief, second chances, and community.

6. Luke Macfarlane

Luke Macfarlane is a longtime Hallmark favorite with memorable holiday premieres. Notable titles include ‘A Shoe Addict’s Christmas’, ‘Chateau Christmas’, and ‘Taking a Shot at Love’. He brings musical and athletic backgrounds into several roles. His filmography covers both heartfelt dramas and lighthearted rom coms.

5. Candace Cameron Bure

Candace Cameron Bure led the popular ‘Aurora Teagarden Mysteries’ as a librarian turned sleuth. She also headlined numerous Christmas titles that became network staples. Her projects often highlight family traditions and small town charm. Her long tenure helped shape the channel’s mystery and holiday strategy.

4. Erin Krakow

Erin Krakow is the heart of ‘When Calls the Heart’ as Elizabeth Thatcher. She also stars in seasonal romances like ‘It Was Always You’. Her Hallmark portfolio emphasizes teacher and caregiver roles rooted in community. She anchors ensemble storytelling set on the frontier and in contemporary towns.

3. Tyler Hynes

Tyler Hynes fronts many of the network’s most watched recent originals. Standouts include ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’, ‘Always Amore’, and ‘An Unexpected Christmas’. He often plays marketing pros, chefs, and authors in urban to small town settings. His schedule regularly features new premieres across fall and holiday lineups.

2. Andrew Walker

Andrew Walker is among the most prolific Hallmark leads with a wide range of roles. He stars in ‘Three Wise Men and a Baby’ and culinary themed romances like ‘Maple Valley Christmas’ appearances. His characters often run family businesses or launch new ventures. He frequently pairs with returning co stars across event slates.

1. Lacey Chabert

Lacey Chabert is the face of Hallmark romance and a key producer on several projects. She leads ‘The Wedding Veil’ trilogy entries and holiday films like ‘Christmas Waltz’ appearances. Her work spans fashion, art, and bakery themed stories with recurring collaborators. She continues to headline marquee premieres for both seasonal and non seasonal slots.

Tell us who you would add to this list in the comments.