‘The Social Reckoning’ Keeps Sliding on Rotten Tomatoes as Sorkin’s Facebook Follow-up Divides Critics

More than 15 years after ‘The Social Network’ became a cultural touchstone, Aaron Sorkin has returned to the story of Facebook. The 2010 film earned 3 Oscars, including one for Sorkin’s screenplay, and still holds a near-perfect 96% on Rotten Tomatoes.

His new companion piece, ‘The Social Reckoning’, shifts focus to Facebook’s role in society, following Wall Street Journal reporter Jeff Horwitz’s work on ‘The Facebook Files’. Sorkin wrote and directed the R-rated drama, which runs 1 hour and 52 minutes and stars Mikey Madison as whistleblower Frances Haugen, Jeremy Allen White as Horwitz, and Jeremy Strong as Mark Zuckerberg.

Now that the film is playing in theaters, its critical standing has taken a noticeable dip. As of October 9, ‘The Social Reckoning’ holds a 59% score on Rotten Tomatoes from 144 reviews, slipping below the “fresh” threshold that it comfortably cleared just days earlier.

When the review embargo lifted, the film debuted at 70% from 43 reviews. Prediction-market traders on Kalshi had forecast a Tomatometer score around 69%, so the opening number landed close to expectations.

As more critics weighed in, however, the score kept falling. It dropped to 67%, then 65% and 63% as the review count grew, before reaching 61% by Thursday evening and settling at its current mark.

Aaron Sorkin’s ‘THE SOCIAL RECKONING’ now holds a 59% score on Rotten Tomatoes. Now playing in theaters. https://t.co/QDFYWFSdxw

— Film Updates (@FilmUpdates) October 9, 2026

Screen Rant noted that even the opening score made it one of Sorkin’s lowest-rated films. The Popcornmeter audience score has yet to appear, with fewer than 50 verified ratings so far.

The performances have been the film’s biggest strength. ComingSoon gave it 6 out of 10, praising Madison and Strong while suggesting the film’s message is more compelling than its execution.

Several reviewers also credited Sorkin’s knack for making complex material easy to follow. Consequence highlighted the importance of the topics the film tackles, while The Film Verdict argued Sorkin directs his own script with more energy than in his earlier efforts.

Many critics, however, kept returning to one comparison: David Fincher. The original film drew much of its power from Fincher’s visual style and Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross’s score, while the new film plays out more straightforwardly as a procedural drama.

Slant Magazine’s Jake Cole argued Sorkin struggles to capture the rhythm of his own dialogue as a director. TheWrap’s William Bibbiani was also unimpressed, questioning whether the film truly earns its title.

A new trailer for Aaron Sorkin’s ‘THE SOCIAL RECKONING’ has been released. In theaters October 9. https://t.co/nSfGUKS0YQ

— Film Updates (@FilmUpdates) August 26, 2026

Others took issue with its tone. The Daily Beast felt the film reduces Zuckerberg to a one-note villain, while Yahoo’s Brett Arnold suggested Sorkin set out to make an Important Movie rather than letting audiences decide.

The film has also drawn criticism beyond traditional reviews. Fox News reported that commentators on both sides of the political spectrum have taken aim at its messaging and its portrayal of Facebook’s role in American politics.

Even some reviews counted as positive on Rotten Tomatoes were described as lukewarm. That mixed reception helps explain why the score has continued to drift downward. ‘The Social Reckoning’ marks Sorkin’s fourth film as a director. While his reputation as a screenwriter remains strong, several outlets suggested his directing career continues to be a mixed bag.

Columbia Pictures released the film nationwide on October 9 following Thursday preview screenings. Its opening weekend will now show whether audiences connect with it more than critics have. With the Popcornmeter still pending, the audience verdict could yet shift the conversation. For now, the follow-up remains far from the acclaim of its celebrated predecessor.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!