These 15 Superhero Flops Deserved Way More Love

Superhero stories have taken over pop culture, delivering epic battles and unforgettable heroes. But not every project gets the love it deserves, with some fading into obscurity despite their potential.

I’ve dug into the world of underappreciated superhero gems—movies, shows, anime, and games that didn’t hit big but still shine. Here’s my take on 15 that deserve more attention.

15. ‘Jonah Hex’ (2010)

This Western-infused superhero flick follows a scarred bounty hunter with supernatural abilities. Despite a gritty premise and Josh Brolin’s intense performance, it struggled to find an audience.

The mix of comic book flair with dusty saloons felt fresh, but its rushed pacing and uneven tone turned viewers away. I think its unique vibe and Brolin’s grit make it worth revisiting for fans of darker heroes.

14. ‘The Marvels’ (2023)

This MCU team-up brings together Carol Danvers, Monica Rambeau, and Kamala Khan in a cosmic adventure. Its vibrant energy and fun character dynamics didn’t translate to box office success.

Superhero fatigue and a complex plot relying on prior MCU knowledge left audiences confused. I love the charm of the leads and the bold action scenes, making it a hidden gem for Marvel fans.

13. ‘Max Steel’ (2016)

Based on a toy line, this film follows a teen discovering his alien-powered suit. It aimed for a younger audience but got lost in a crowded superhero market.

Its low-budget charm and coming-of-age heart didn’t connect widely. I find its earnest take on heroism and cool suit designs make it a fun watch for fans of lighthearted sci-fi.

12. ‘Green Lantern’ (2011)

Ryan Reynolds stars as Hal Jordan, a pilot gifted a cosmic ring to fight evil. Despite its ambitious scope, it faced criticism for its effects and uneven story.

I appreciate its attempt to bring a lesser-known hero to life with a bold intergalactic setting. Reynolds’ charisma keeps it engaging, deserving a second look from comic fans.

11. ‘Superman Returns’ (2006)

This sequel to the classic Superman films sees Clark Kent return to a changed world. Brandon Routh’s heartfelt performance didn’t win over audiences expecting a modern reboot.

Its nostalgic tone and emotional depth felt out of step with the times. I think its quiet heroism and stunning visuals make it a worthy chapter in Superman’s legacy.

10. ‘The New Mutants’ (2020)

This X-Men spin-off blends superhero thrills with horror, following young mutants in a creepy facility. Its release during a tough time for theaters hurt its chances.

The cast, including Anya Taylor-Joy, delivers, but the marketing failed to capture its unique vibe. I love its dark edge and character focus, perfect for fans of moody superhero tales.

9. ‘Wonder Woman 1984’

Gal Gadot’s Diana Prince faces new foes in this vibrant sequel. Its retro aesthetic and bold themes didn’t click with everyone, partly due to its release timing.

The action and Gadot’s charm shine, but the plot felt overstuffed. I find its heart and ambitious ideas make it a standout for those who love Diana’s optimism.

8. ‘Elektra’ (2005)

Jennifer Garner’s Elektra, a deadly assassin, gets her own spin-off from Daredevil. It aimed for gritty action but struggled with a thin script and lackluster direction.

I think Garner’s fierce performance and the martial arts sequences give it an edge. It’s a flawed but fun watch for fans of female-led superhero stories.

7. ‘The Flash’ (2023)

Ezra Miller’s Barry Allen races through time in this DC adventure. Despite high expectations, it stumbled with audiences due to offscreen controversies and a crowded plot.

The multiverse angle and Michael Keaton’s Batman cameo are highlights. I believe its heartfelt moments and wild energy make it worth a second chance.

6. ‘Catwoman’ (2004)

Halle Berry’s take on a feline antihero was a bold departure from Batman’s world. It flopped due to its loose connection to the comics and campy tone.

Berry’s charisma and the stylish action still hold appeal. I think it’s a guilty pleasure for those who enjoy quirky superhero experiments.

5. ‘Higurashi: When They Cry’ (2006-2007)

This anime blends horror and mystery with supernatural elements, following teens in a cursed village. Its dark tone and complex story didn’t catch on widely in the West.

The chilling atmosphere and emotional twists keep me hooked. It’s a must-watch for anime fans who love intense, layered narratives.

4. ‘Dredd’ (2012)

Karl Urban’s Judge Dredd patrols a dystopian city in this gritty reboot. Despite its sleek action and faithful comic vibe, it didn’t draw crowds.

The relentless pace and Urban’s stoic performance are top-notch. I think its cult status proves it’s a gem for fans of hard-hitting superhero tales.

3. ‘Yona of the Dawn’ (2014-2015)

This anime follows Princess Yona as she becomes a warrior to reclaim her kingdom. Its rich fantasy world didn’t grab a huge audience outside Japan.

The character growth and epic battles are captivating. I love its blend of heart and action, making it a standout for anime enthusiasts.

2. ‘Hellboy II: The Golden Army’ (2008)

Guillermo del Toro’s sequel dives deeper into Hellboy’s mythical world. Despite stunning visuals, it didn’t match the first film’s buzz.

Ron Perlman’s charm and the lush fantasy elements shine. I think its creativity makes it a must-see for fans of unique superhero stories.

1. ‘Batman: Mask of the Phantasm’ (1993)

This animated Batman tale explores Bruce Wayne’s past and a mysterious vigilante. Tied to the beloved animated series, it still flopped in theaters due to its format.

The emotional depth and tight mystery are masterful. I believe it’s one of Batman’s best stories, perfect for fans of heartfelt heroics.

Which superhero flop do you think deserves more love, or did I miss a hidden gem? Drop your thoughts in the comments!