5 Things About ‘The Skeleton Crew’ That Made Zero Sense and 5 Things That Made Perfect Sense

I recently watched ‘Star Wars: Skeleton Crew’ (2024-2025), a fresh addition to the Star Wars universe that dives into a kid-centric adventure. It’s got that nostalgic ‘Goonies’ vibe, following four children—Wim, Fern, KB, and Neel—as they stumble upon a mysterious ship and get lost in a galaxy full of pirates and secrets.

The show, created by Jon Watts and Christopher Ford, blends fun with danger, and Jude Law’s shady Jod Na Nawood steals the spotlight. While I loved the energy, some moments left me confused, while others clicked perfectly. Here’s my take on five things that didn’t add up and five that worked brilliantly, alternating between the two.

Made Zero Sense: The Supervisor’s Hidden Identity

The mysterious Supervisor of At Attin, voiced by Stephen Fry, stays unseen in a tower, controlling the planet’s secretive society. Why the secrecy? The show hints at a big reveal, possibly tying to pirate Tak Rennod, but never explains why they hide or how they maintain such iron control without showing their face.

It feels like a plot device to keep the mystery going without earning it. A leader this powerful should have a clearer motive or presence, especially with only eight episodes to flesh things out. The vague setup left me frustrated, wanting more than just a shadowy figure.

Made Perfect Sense: The Goonies-Inspired Adventure

The show’s Amblin-inspired tone, reminiscent of ‘The Goonies’ (1985), is spot-on. The kids’ discovery of the Onyx Cinder and their wild journey through a dangerous galaxy capture that 80s sense of wonder and camaraderie that Star Wars often nails for younger audiences.

Each planet they visit, from Lanupa to At Achrann, feels alive with unique challenges, like trash crabs or pirate lairs. This setup makes their adventure feel thrilling yet relatable, grounding the sci-fi in a heartfelt coming-of-age story that I couldn’t stop watching.

Made Zero Sense: Jod’s Sudden Jedi Backstory

Jod Na Nawood, played by Jude Law, drops a bombshell in the finale: he was trained by a Jedi before Order 66. This comes out of nowhere, with no earlier hints of his Force sensitivity beyond a vague line about the Force flowing through everyone.

For a character so central, this backstory feels tacked on to justify his lightsaber use. It’s a stretch to believe a street kid turned pirate was secretly Jedi-trained without any prior clues, making the reveal feel forced and unconvincing.

Made Perfect Sense: Jude Law’s Charismatic Performance

Jude Law as Jod Na Nawood is a highlight. His charm as a cunning, morally gray pirate captain carries every scene, whether he’s conning his crew or threatening the kids with a lightsaber. Law’s ability to shift from likable rogue to menacing villain keeps you guessing.

His performance adds depth to Jod, making him more than a stereotype. I found myself rooting for him even when he was double-crossing everyone, proving Law was the perfect pick for this complex role.

Made Zero Sense: KB’s Cybernetic Implant Issues

KB’s cybernetic visor and brain implant, tied to a past accident, malfunction in episode six, creating drama about her survival. But the show never explains the accident or why her tech is so fragile, especially for a kid on a high-tech planet like At Attin.

This feels like a cheap way to add stakes without buildup. A clearer explanation of her condition or its limits would’ve made her struggle more impactful instead of a sudden plot hurdle.

Made Perfect Sense: KB’s Emotional Growth

KB, played by Kyriana Kratter, shines in episode six, ‘Zero Friends Again’ (2024-2025), as she confronts her fears of losing friends due to her stoic nature and disability. Her arc, especially standing up to Fern, feels authentic and empowering, showing her growth from a quiet follower to a confident voice.

The show handles her disability with care, using it to explore vulnerability and strength. I connected with her journey, as it mirrors real struggles of feeling different while finding your place among friends.

Made Zero Sense: The Onyx Cinder’s Convenient Features

The Onyx Cinder, the kids’ ship, has odd quirks like shedding its hull like a snake or a self-destruct button that doesn’t destroy it but releases its outer casing. These features feel random, thrown in for cool visuals or to solve plot problems without explanation.

How does a ship detect treasure in acid or molt like a creature? These unexplained mechanics break the immersion, making the ship feel like a plot device rather than a believable part of the Star Wars universe.

Made Perfect Sense: The Kids’ Dynamic Chemistry

The four kids—Wim, Fern, KB, and Neel—have a natural, bickering chemistry that feels like a real friend group. Their arguments, like Wim and Fern’s ‘claimsies’ spat over the Onyx Cinder, blend humor with tension, making their bond the heart of the show.

Each kid’s personality, from Fern’s bossy leadership to Neel’s quiet loyalty, shines through. I laughed and felt their pain as they grew closer, proving the young cast, especially Ravi Cabot-Conyers and Ryan Kiera Armstrong, nailed their roles.

Made Zero Sense: The X-Wings as Misunderstood Heroes

The kids initially think X-Wing pilots are ‘bad guys’ because Jod lies to them, but the reveal that they’re New Republic heroes feels mishandled. Why would the kids, from a planet with no galactic contact, trust Jod’s word so easily without questioning?

The misunderstanding drags on too long, and the resolution feels rushed. A quicker reveal or more skepticism from the kids would’ve made this plot twist less confusing and more believable.

Made Perfect Sense: The Visual World-Building

The show’s visuals, from the snowy trash pits of Lanupa to the lush, secretive At Attin, are stunning. Details like the giant crab Tet’niss or the Onyx Cinder’s sleek design expand the Star Wars galaxy in a way that feels fresh yet familiar.

Every planet has a distinct vibe, enhancing the adventure. I was drawn into each setting, as the high production quality—backed by Disney’s budget—made every frame pop, rivaling the best of ‘The Mandalorian’ (2019-).

What’s your take on ‘Star Wars: Skeleton Crew’—which moments puzzled you, or which ones won you over? Share your thoughts in the comments!