Tobey Maguire, 50, Raises Eyebrows After Flirting With 20‑Year‑Old Model at Super Bowl
Tobey Maguire, 50, has sparked dating rumors after he was spotted getting cozy with 20-year-old model Mishka Silva at the Super Bowl on Sunday. The Spider-Man star and Silva were seen chatting closely while enjoying the game from a VIP suite at Levi’s Stadium in Santa Clara, California, according to photos shared online.
In one image, Silva appeared playful, smiling and twirling her hair while stretching her legs out in front of Maguire. Despite being caught on the stadium’s jumbotron, the pair seemed completely at ease, sharing laughs and enjoying each other’s company.
Even Tobey Maguire is happy for Bad Bunny 🫶 #SuperBowl pic.twitter.com/Td3jiEvMU4
— lebaza 𓅓 (@jonathanlebaza) February 9, 2026
The VIP area included several other high-profile celebrities, including Jessica Alba, Cardi B, Travis Scott, Dylan Sprouse, and Kevin Costner.
Silva, who has modeled for brands like Guess, Steve Madden, Too Faced, and Smashbox, later shared snapshots from her Super Bowl weekend on Instagram. “Super bowl weekend was so good I forgot to take photos, thank you @raisingcanes,” she captioned a carousel of images, including one of her wearing a fringed brown suede jacket with Levi’s Stadium in the background.
The jacket’s designer, Kaeya Winter, later reposted an article about Silva’s appearance with the caption: “Love it when my jacket becomes famous at the Super Bowl lol @mishkasilva.”
Maguire’s love life has often made headlines. He was married to jewelry designer Jennifer Meyer from 2007 to 2020, and they share two children: Ruby, 19, and Otis, 16. After the divorce, he dated model Tatiana Dieteman, 33, for three years, ending their relationship in 2022. He was then briefly linked to actress and model Lily Chee in 2024, who was 20 at the time.
When social media users commented on the age gap between Maguire and Chee, one X user wrote: “Spider-Man was released a year BEFORE she was born this is crazy,” gaining over 13,000 likes.
Jennifer Meyer defended her ex in two Instagram exchanges, according to Reddit screenshots. She explained that when Maguire was seen with Chee in 2024, he was simply helping her to her car. “And now he has [been] blasted online for dating someone he is not. But thank you for your rude comment. I hope it made you feel better today. Wishing you love and light,” Meyer wrote.
The actor now finds himself at the center of similar gossip after being seen with Silva, whose age is just one year older than his daughter Ruby. Fans and media outlets have quickly circulated photos of the pair together, fueling speculation about their relationship.
While neither Maguire nor Silva has commented directly on the rumors, their Super Bowl appearance has already made waves online. Many are talking about the 30-year age difference, while others focus on the relaxed, playful energy the pair shared during the game.
This isn’t the first time Maguire’s personal life has been under the microscope. His long career in Hollywood and his previous relationships have made him a frequent subject of media attention. Now, the spotlight is back on him, with fans debating whether his latest rumored romance is serious or just a friendly encounter.
What do you think about Tobey Maguire being seen with Mishka Silva? Do you think there’s more than friendship there, or is it just a casual Super Bowl hangout? Share your thoughts in the comments.