5 Ways ‘Gladiator’ Aged Poorly (And 5 Ways It Aged Masterfully)

Gladiator (2000) is a beloved epic that thrilled audiences with its intense battles and gripping story. Over two decades later, it remains a landmark film, but not every element holds up under modern scrutiny.

Some aspects feel dated or problematic today, while others shine even brighter with time. Here are five ways Gladiator hasn’t aged well and five ways it still feels masterful.

Dated CGI (Aged Poorly)

The film’s use of CGI, especially in the Colosseum scenes, was groundbreaking at the time. However, modern eyes can spot the artificial textures and awkward digital crowds, which break immersion.

Compared to today’s seamless visual effects, these moments feel clunky. The tiger sequence, in particular, looks stiff and unnatural now.

Timeless Story of Revenge (Aged Masterfully)

The core narrative of Maximus seeking vengeance for his family’s murder remains powerful. It’s a universal theme that connects with audiences across generations.

Russell Crowe’s raw emotion drives the story, making every betrayal and triumph feel real. This focus on personal stakes keeps the film compelling.

Stereotyped Villains (Aged Poorly)

The antagonists, like Commodus, lean heavily on exaggerated traits, bordering on caricature. His over-the-top cruelty feels less nuanced compared to modern complex villains.

Supporting characters, like the scheming senators, also lack depth. Today’s audiences often prefer layered antagonists with clearer motivations.

Epic Battle Choreography (Aged Masterfully)

The gladiator arena fights remain breathtaking. The close-quarters combat and brutal swordplay feel authentic and intense.

The film’s commitment to practical stunts and minimal reliance on CGI in these scenes creates a gritty realism. These moments still rival modern action sequences.

Simplistic Female Characters (Aged Poorly)

Lucilla, the main female character, is underdeveloped and serves mostly as a plot device. Her role feels limited compared to today’s demand for strong, complex women in film.

Other female characters, like the slaves and spectators, are barely fleshed out. This lack of depth stands out in modern storytelling.

Russell Crowe’s Iconic Performance (Aged Masterfully)

Russell Crowe’s portrayal of Maximus is unforgettable. His mix of strength, grief, and determination carries the film.

Even today, his performance feels raw and authentic. It’s a masterclass in balancing intensity with vulnerability that actors still study.

Outdated Portrayal of Slavery (Aged Poorly)

The film glosses over the harsh realities of slavery in ancient Rome. Enslaved characters, like Juba, are shown as loyal sidekicks rather than fully realized individuals.

Modern audiences expect more nuanced depictions of historical oppression. This shallow treatment feels out of touch now.

Stunning Costume Design (Aged Masterfully)

The film’s costumes, from Roman armor to senator robes, are meticulously crafted. They bring ancient Rome to life with vivid detail.

Even today, the attention to historical accuracy in the wardrobe stands out. It adds authenticity that elevates every scene.

Exaggerated Historical Inaccuracies (Aged Poorly)

Gladiator takes liberties with Roman history, like Commodus’ fictionalized death in the arena. These inaccuracies feel more glaring as audiences value historical fidelity today.

Details like the Colosseum’s structure and political events are also skewed. This can distract viewers familiar with actual Roman history.

Emotional Depth of Themes (Aged Masterfully)

The film’s exploration of honor, loyalty, and sacrifice remains moving. Maximus’ journey resonates because it taps into timeless human struggles.

The final scene, with its vision of the afterlife, still brings tears. This emotional weight ensures Gladiator’s lasting impact.

What’s your take on how Gladiator has held up over the years? Share your thoughts in the comments!