Ranking Every Spider-Man Actor from Worst to Best
Spider-Man swings through pop culture like few other heroes, and the actors who’ve brought him to life have shaped how we see the web-slinger. From classic cartoons to blockbuster films, each version of Peter Parker or his multiverse variants carries a unique vibe.
I’ve ranked every Spider-Man actor based on their contributions, from live-action movies to animated series and video games. The list draws on their performances, the projects’ cultural weight, and how they’ve defined the character for fans.
18. Ted Schwartz
Ted Schwartz voiced Spider-Man in the animated series ‘Spider-Man’ (1981). His earnest delivery suited the show’s simple, action-driven stories.
The series had a modest footprint compared to later adaptations. Schwartz’s work remains a nostalgic piece of Spider-Man’s early animated history.
17. Sam Riegel
Sam Riegel lent his voice to Spider-Man in the video games ‘The Amazing Spider-Man’ (2012) and ‘The Amazing Spider-Man 2’ (2014). His quippy, confident take felt lively.
Tied to Andrew Garfield’s films, the games didn’t capture the same magic. Riegel’s energetic performance still added flair to Spider-Man in gaming.
16. Rino Romano
Rino Romano voiced Spider-Man in ‘Spider-Man Unlimited’ (1999-2001) and four video games. His bold take fit the show’s futuristic, alternate-universe vibe.
The series’ unique premise didn’t fully land with audiences, and its short run limited its reach. Romano’s spirited delivery gave it a distinct edge.
15. Robbie Daymond
Robbie Daymond voiced Spider-Man in ‘Spider-Man’ (2017-2020) and the 2017 game ‘Marvel vs. Capcom Infinite’. His youthful, tech-savvy Peter Parker felt modern.
The series blended fresh visuals with classic themes but didn’t outshine other adaptations. Daymond’s lively performance kept Spider-Man engaging.
14. Benjamin Diskin
Benjamin Diskin voiced Spider-Man in ‘Lego Marvel Super Heroes: Avengers Reassembled’ (2015). His playful take matched the lighthearted Lego universe.
The special was fun but small in scope, aimed at younger fans. Diskin’s enthusiastic delivery added charm to a quirky, minor role.
13. Nicholas Hammond
Nicholas Hammond played Spider-Man in the live-action series ‘The Amazing Spider-Man’ (1977-1979) and TV movies like ‘Spider-Man Strikes Back’ (1978). His grounded Peter Parker felt authentic for its time.
The show’s dated effects and budget constraints haven’t aged well, but Hammond’s sincerity made it a bold early step for live-action Spider-Man.
12. Neil Patrick Harris
Neil Patrick Harris voiced Spider-Man in ‘Spider-Man: The New Animated Series’ (2003) and the 2010 game ‘Spider-Man: Shattered Dimensions’. His witty, sharp take brought fresh energy.
The CGI series had a striking look but a brief run. Harris’s charisma made his Spider-Man a standout for early 2000s fans.
11. Dan Gilvezan
Dan Gilvezan voiced Spider-Man in ‘Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends’ (1981-1983). His warm, friendly performance fit the show’s team-up dynamic with Iceman and Firestar.
A hit for its era, the series blended action and 80s charm. Gilvezan’s voice is a nostalgic favorite for fans of classic cartoons.
10. Paul Soles
Paul Soles voiced Spider-Man in the first animated series, ‘Spider-Man’ (1967-1970). His quick-witted, earnest take set the standard for the character on TV.
The show’s iconic theme and retro animation remain beloved. Soles’s pioneering work built the foundation for Spider-Man’s animated legacy.
9. Drake Bell
Drake Bell voiced Spider-Man in ‘Ultimate Spider-Man’ (2012-2017), ‘Avengers Assemble’ (2013-2015), and games like ‘Disney Infinity: Marvel Super Heroes’ (2014). His youthful energy suited the teen-focused series.
The show’s long run and crossover appeal made it a staple for younger fans. Bell’s lively performance kept Spider-Man’s humor and heart central.
8. Chris Pine
Chris Pine voiced a tragic Peter Parker in ‘Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse’ (2018). His brief, poignant role added emotional depth to the multiverse story.
The film’s groundbreaking style and critical acclaim boosted Pine’s impact. His understated performance anchored the movie’s heart.
7. Josh Keaton
Josh Keaton voiced Spider-Man in ‘The Spectacular Spider-Man’ (2008-2009) and five video games. His balanced take captured Peter’s nerdy charm and heroic spirit.
The series is a fan favorite for its sharp writing and faithful adaptation. Keaton’s dynamic voice work made his Spider-Man one of animation’s best.
6. Christopher Daniel Barnes
Christopher Daniel Barnes voiced Spider-Man in ‘Spider-Man’ (1994-1998). His performance mixed wit with Peter Parker’s deeper struggles, resonating with 90s audiences.
The series defined animated Spider-Man for a generation with its mature storytelling. Barnes’s iconic voice became a cornerstone of the character’s legacy.
5. Yuri Lowenthal
Yuri Lowenthal voiced Spider-Man in the 2018 game ‘Spider-Man’ and ‘Marvel Super Hero Squad Online’ (2011). His mature, heartfelt Peter Parker brought depth to gaming.
The 2018 game was a massive hit, lauded for its story and gameplay. Lowenthal’s emotional range made his Spider-Man a gaming standout.
4. Jake Johnson
Jake Johnson voiced Peter B. Parker in ‘Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse’ (2018). His scruffy, relatable take on an older Spider-Man connected deeply with fans.
The film’s innovative animation and storytelling made it a cultural phenomenon. Johnson’s grounded, humorous performance added a fresh layer to Spider-Man.
3. Andrew Garfield
Andrew Garfield starred as Spider-Man in ‘The Amazing Spider-Man’ (2012), ‘The Amazing Spider-Man 2’ (2014), and ‘Spider-Man: No Way Home’ (2021). His raw, emotional Peter Parker brought a modern edge.
Despite mixed film reviews, Garfield’s chemistry with Emma Stone and his heartfelt ‘No Way Home’ return won fans over. His nuanced take remains beloved.
2. Tobey Maguire
Tobey Maguire defined Spider-Man in ‘Spider-Man’ (2002), ‘Spider-Man 2’ (2004), ‘Spider-Man 3’ (2007), and ‘Spider-Man: No Way Home’ (2021). His soulful, earnest Peter Parker shaped superhero films.
Sam Raimi’s trilogy, especially ‘Spider-Man 2’, set a genre benchmark. Maguire’s emotional depth and nostalgic return keep him iconic.
1. Tom Holland
Tom Holland brought Spider-Man to the MCU in ‘Captain America: Civil War’ (2016), ‘Spider-Man: Homecoming’ (2017), ‘Avengers: Infinity War’ (2018), ‘Avengers: Endgame’ (2019), ‘Spider-Man: Far From Home’ (2019), and ‘Spider-Man: No Way Home’ (2021). His youthful, awkward charm made Peter Parker feel fresh.
Holland’s films are box-office giants, blending Spider-Man into the MCU’s epic scope. His heartfelt, acrobatic performance captures the hero’s essence perfectly.
Who’s your favorite Spider-Man actor, or did I miss a standout performance? Share your pick in the comments!