10 Amazon Prime Original Series That Are So Good You Have to Watch Them Twice

Amazon Prime Video has carved out a special place in our streaming lives with its bold lineup of original shows. From gripping dramas to laugh-out-loud comedies, these series hook us with rich stories and unforgettable characters that linger long after the credits roll.

Whether you’re into epic fantasy, gritty crime, or heartfelt coming-of-age tales, Amazon’s catalog has something that demands a second watch to catch every detail. Here are ten standout Prime Originals that we can’t help but revisit, each packed with moments that hit harder the second time around.

10. The Summer I Turned Pretty (2022-2025)

This heartfelt coming-of-age drama follows Belly Conklin as she navigates love, friendship, and family during her summers at Cousins Beach. Based on Jenny Han’s beloved trilogy, the show blends romance with the bittersweet ache of growing up, centered around Belly’s tangled feelings for brothers Conrad and Jeremiah.

The emotional depth and subtle character arcs make this series a gem for rewatching. Each episode reveals new layers in Belly’s choices and the family’s dynamics, especially as the beach house faces an uncertain future in Season 3, which wrapped up the story in July 2025.

9. Harlem (2021-2025)

This vibrant comedy-drama tracks four ambitious Black women in their 30s chasing dreams and love in New York City’s Harlem neighborhood. With sharp humor and raw honesty, it explores friendship, career struggles, and personal growth through characters like Camille, a quirky professor, and Tye, a bold tech entrepreneur.

Rewatching ‘Harlem’ lets us savor the witty banter and emotional stakes that deepen with each season. The third season, released in January 2025, pushes the women into new challenges like motherhood and messy family ties, making every rewatch a fresh dive into their stylish world.

8. The Legend of Vox Machina (2022-present)

This animated fantasy series brings the Dungeons & Dragons campaign of Critical Role to life, following a ragtag group of misfit adventurers saving the realm of Exandria. Packed with bawdy humor, gory battles, and surprising heart, it’s a love letter to tabletop gaming.

The fast-paced action and layered character backstories reward multiple viewings. Each episode, especially in the ongoing third season, unveils clever nods to the game’s lore and emotional beats that hit harder when you know the stakes, making it a must for fantasy fans.

7. Invincible (2021-present)

This animated superhero saga follows teenager Mark Grayson as he inherits his father’s powers and faces the brutal realities of being a hero. Based on Robert Kirkman’s comic, it blends visceral action with gut-punching family drama and moral dilemmas.

Rewatching ‘Invincible’ uncovers subtle foreshadowing and emotional nuances in Mark’s journey. The third season, released in 2025, dives deeper into his struggle against his father’s legacy, making every betrayal and battle more gripping the second time around.

6. The Wheel of Time (2021-2025)

Set in a sprawling fantasy world, this epic follows Moiraine, a powerful Aes Sedai, as she guides a group of young people, one of whom may be the Dragon Reborn, destined to save or destroy the world. The show’s lush visuals and intricate lore draw us in.

A second watch reveals the depth of its prophecy-driven plot and character motivations. Season 3, released in 2025, ramps up the stakes with divided factions and looming threats, making it easy to get lost in the Two Rivers all over again.

5. Reacher (2022-present)

This action-packed thriller stars Alan Ritchson as Jack Reacher, a hulking drifter with a knack for solving crimes and cracking skulls. Based on Lee Child’s novels, it delivers gritty mysteries and no-nonsense justice in small-town settings.

Rewatching ‘Reacher’ lets us appreciate the clever clues and Reacher’s sharp wit. Season 3, based on ‘Persuader’ and released in 2025, dives into a dark criminal underworld, with every fight and twist hitting harder when you know what’s coming.

4. The Boys (2019-present)

This dark superhero satire follows a ragtag team fighting corrupt, fame-obsessed “supes” in a world where heroes are corporate pawns. Known for its bold humor and shocking violence, it skewers power and celebrity culture with biting wit.

A second viewing highlights the show’s layered commentary and character arcs, like Hughie’s moral struggles or Butcher’s rage-fueled vendetta. With Season 5 set to conclude the series in 2026, rewatching primes us for every explosive showdown.

3. The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (2022-present)

This ambitious fantasy epic explores Middle-earth’s Second Age, thousands of years before ‘The Lord of the Rings.’ It follows Galadriel and others battling Sauron’s rise, with stunning visuals and deep Tolkien lore.

Rewatching unveils intricate details in the forging of the Rings and Sauron’s schemes. Season 3, announced for 2025, promises more epic battles, making it worth revisiting to catch every elven glance and dwarven grudge.

2. Fallout (2024-present)

Set in a retro-futuristic wasteland, this adaptation of the video game series follows vault-dweller Lucy, knight Maximus, and bounty hunter Ghoul navigating a post-apocalyptic world. Its mix of dark humor, sharp satire, and Americana vibes is addictive.

A second watch reveals clever world-building and character connections, especially in the Ghoul’s tragic past. With Season 2 hitting New Vegas in December 2025, rewatching sets up the next wild ride through the nuclear ruins.

1. Fleabag (2016-2019)

Phoebe Waller-Bridge’s sharp comedy-drama follows a witty, messy young woman navigating life, love, and family in London. With its fourth-wall-breaking humor and raw emotional core, ‘Fleabag’ balances hilarity and heartbreak.

Rewatching lets us catch every sly glance and subtle clue in Fleabag’s chaotic journey. The tight two-season run, ending in 2019, feels fresh each time, with every quip and tear hitting harder as we root for her messy, beautiful life.

Which Amazon Prime Original series do you keep rewatching, or did we miss your favorite? Drop your thoughts in the comments!