Gay Celebrities with Surprising Heterosexual Pasts

Many prominent figures in the entertainment industry lived very different lives before sharing their authentic selves with the public. It is not uncommon for gay celebrities to have navigated heterosexual relationships or marriages due to societal pressure or personal discovery. These stars spent years in public romances with the opposite sex before coming out as part of the LGBTQ+ community. Their stories highlight the complex journey of self-acceptance and the courage it takes to live openly.

Elton John

The legendary musician was famously married to German recording engineer Renate Blauel for four years during the 1980s. Elton John has since expressed great respect for his ex-wife and described their divorce as a heartbreaking but necessary step toward his truth. He struggled with his sexuality for years before fully embracing his identity as a gay man. The singer later found lasting love with David Furnish and became a fierce advocate for LGBTQ+ rights.

Ricky Martin

This Puerto Rican superstar dated television host Rebecca de Alba for over a decade during the height of his fame. Ricky Martin frequently spoke about his love for her and the possibility of marriage before they eventually separated. He later came out publicly in 2010 on his official website and described himself as a fortunate homosexual man. His journey from a heterosexual heartthrob image to an out father and husband inspired many fans worldwide.

Portia de Rossi

The ‘Arrested Development’ actress was married to documentary filmmaker Mel Metcalfe for three years in the late 1990s. Portia de Rossi initially entered the marriage believing it was the right thing to do while suppressing her attraction to women. She later admitted that she was terrified of being exposed as a lesbian during that time in Hollywood. She eventually found the courage to live openly and became one half of a power couple with Ellen DeGeneres.

Meredith Baxter

Known as the quintessential television mother on ‘Family Ties’, this actress was married to men three times. Meredith Baxter raised five children within these heterosexual unions before coming out later in life. She realized her attraction to women after her third divorce and started exploring her identity in her sixties. Her candid memoir details the challenges of realizing her sexual orientation after spending decades in traditional marriages.

Wanda Sykes

The celebrated comedian was married to record producer Dave Hall for seven years during the 1990s. Wanda Sykes has spoken about how she tried to conform to societal expectations during that period of her life. She eventually divorced Hall and embraced her identity as a lesbian before coming out publicly at a rally in 2008. She is now happily married to Alex Niedbalski and uses her platform to advocate for equality.

Barry Manilow

The iconic crooner was married to his high school sweetheart Susan Deixler for a brief period in the 1960s. Barry Manilow kept his sexuality private for decades out of fear that coming out would disappoint his predominantly female fanbase. He lived with his manager and future husband Garry Kief for nearly forty years before confirming the relationship publicly. He later stated that his brief marriage to Deixler was loving but he was not yet ready to settle down or fully understand himself.

Lance Bass

As a member of the boy band NSYNC, the singer was in a high-profile relationship with ‘Boy Meets World’ actress Danielle Fishel. Lance Bass famously attended prom with Fishel and the two remained close friends long after their breakup. He kept his sexuality a secret during the peak of the band’s popularity to avoid alienating their teenage audience. He came out on the cover of a major magazine in 2006 and has since married Michael Turchin.

Neil Patrick Harris

Before becoming a gay icon, the ‘How I Met Your Mother’ star dated actress Christine Taylor. Neil Patrick Harris realized during their relationship that he did not feel the romantic chemistry he expected to feel. He subsequently navigated his journey of self-discovery while maintaining a successful acting career. He came out publicly in 2006 and has become one of the most visible gay actors in Hollywood.

Kelly McGillis

The ‘Top Gun’ actress was married to two different men and had two daughters before coming out. Kelly McGillis spent years trying to suppress her feelings for women and living according to traditional norms. She eventually embraced her sexuality in 2009 during an interview with an online magazine. She has since stepped away from major Hollywood roles to live a quieter and more authentic life.

Sarah Paulson

This acclaimed actress was once engaged to playwright Tracy Letts before she began dating women publicly. Sarah Paulson has dated both men and women but has been in a long-term relationship with Holland Taylor for many years. She prefers not to label her sexuality strictly but is widely recognized as a prominent member of the LGBTQ+ community. Her past relationships with men were significant chapters before she found her current partnership.

Cynthia Nixon

The ‘Sex and the City’ star was in a relationship with schoolteacher Danny Mozes for fifteen years. Cynthia Nixon and Mozes had two children together before they separated in 2003. She later began dating education activist Christine Marinoni and identified her sexual orientation as a choice she made to be with a woman. She has since clarified that for her, being queer is simply a description of her current reality.

George Michael

The pop superstar dated women early in his career and often spoke about his attraction to both sexes. George Michael struggled with the public perception of his image as a heterosexual sex symbol during the Wham! era. He eventually came out after a highly publicized arrest in 1998 forced his private life into the spotlight. His later years were defined by his openness about his sexuality and his relationships with men.

Jane Lynch

The comedic actress spent many years dating men before she fully accepted her lesbian identity. Jane Lynch has described feeling different from a young age but trying to fit into the heteronormative mold. She did not come out publicly until she was well established in her career. She is now considered a trailblazer for gay women in comedy and television.

Peter Marc Jacobson

The co-creator of ‘The Nanny’ was married to the show’s star Fran Drescher for over twenty years. Peter Marc Jacobson and Drescher maintained a strong creative partnership even as their marriage ended. He came out to her after their divorce and the two have remained best friends and collaborators. They later created the show ‘Happily Divorced’ based on their unique real-life experience.

Joel Grey

The Oscar-winning actor was married to actress Jo Wilder for twenty-four years. Joel Grey raised two children with Wilder before coming out as a gay man at the age of 82. He spoke about the relief of finally sharing his true self after decades of keeping it private. His coming out was met with widespread support from the theater and film communities.

Sara Gilbert

The actress known for ‘Roseanne’ dated her co-star Johnny Galecki during the show’s original run. Sara Gilbert realized she was gay while they were dating and confided in Galecki about her feelings. He kept her secret and supported her as she navigated her sexuality in private. She later became a vocal advocate for LGBTQ+ rights and a creator of ‘The Talk’.

Clay Aiken

The ‘American Idol’ runner-up dated women during his time on the show and in the years immediately following. Clay Aiken faced intense speculation about his sexuality but maintained a heterosexual public image for some time. He came out in 2008 following the birth of his son and stated he wanted to be honest with his child. He has since pursued a career in politics and activism.

Sean Hayes

The ‘Will & Grace’ star kept his personal life very private during the initial success of the sitcom. Sean Hayes dated women in his younger years before accepting his identity as a gay man. He faced criticism for not coming out sooner but has stated he needed to process it on his own timeline. He is now married to Scott Icenogle and hosts a popular podcast.

Wentworth Miller

The star of ‘Prison Break’ was linked to several women in Hollywood before coming out. Wentworth Miller denied rumors about his homosexuality for years out of fear it would harm his acting career. He eventually declined an invitation to a film festival in Russia as a protest against the country’s anti-LGBTQ laws. His letter formally announcing his sexuality was praised for its bravery and eloquence.

Matt Bomer

The ‘White Collar’ actor dated girls throughout high school and college before embracing his true self. Matt Bomer kept his marriage and family life private for years to protect his career momentum. He publicly acknowledged his husband and children during an acceptance speech in 2012. He has since played several iconic gay roles and produced LGBTQ+ content.

Colton Haynes

The ‘Teen Wolf’ actor dated women publicly and was advised by management to hide his sexuality. Colton Haynes struggled with anxiety and the pressure to maintain a heartthrob image for his young fanbase. He came out in 2016 and spoke candidly about the toll that living in the closet took on his mental health. He continues to be an advocate for mental health awareness and authenticity.

Rock Hudson

One of the biggest movie stars of the 1950s was married to his agent’s secretary Phyllis Gates. Rock Hudson lived a double life for decades to maintain his status as a heterosexual romantic lead. His marriage was largely arranged by his studio to quell rumors about his private life. He eventually became the first major celebrity to die from AIDS-related complications which changed the public conversation about the disease.

Robert Reed

The actor who played the quintessential American father Mike Brady on ‘The Brady Bunch’ was a closeted gay man. Robert Reed married a woman named Marilyn Rosenberger in the 1950s and they had a daughter together. He kept his sexuality a closely guarded secret throughout his life to protect his career and his television family. His co-stars later expressed their sadness that he felt he could never live openly.

Jonathan Knight

The New Kids on the Block member dated pop star Tiffany during the height of the group’s fame. Jonathan Knight kept his sexuality hidden while performing for millions of screaming female fans. He was inadvertently outed by Tiffany in a television interview years later before confirming it himself. He is now married and stars in a home renovation show.

Anthony Perkins

The star of ‘Psycho’ was married to photographer Berry Berenson for nearly twenty years. Anthony Perkins had relationships with men throughout his life but maintained a traditional marriage until his death. He and Berenson had two sons and remained together until he passed away from AIDS-related complications. His complex personal life was only fully understood by the public after his passing.

Tab Hunter

This 1950s heartthrob was marketed as the ideal boyfriend for teenage girls and dated stars like Debbie Reynolds. Tab Hunter lived a secret life as a gay man while the studios manufactured romances for him to sell magazines. He wrote a bestselling memoir later in life detailing how he navigated the studio system while closeted. His story shed light on the extreme measures taken to protect the heterosexual image of stars in that era.

Richard Chamberlain

The star of ‘The Thorn Birds’ was a massive romantic idol who dated women to deflect rumors. Richard Chamberlain lived in fear that being outed would destroy his career as a leading man. He finally came out in his memoir at the age of 69 after decades of hiding his long-term relationships with men. He has expressed regret for not doing it sooner but found peace in his honesty.

Clive Davis

The legendary music executive was married twice to women and had children before coming out as bisexual. Clive Davis revealed his sexuality in his 2013 memoir after leading a very public heterosexual life. He described finding love with a man after the end of his second marriage. While he identifies as bisexual, he is a prominent figure who transitioned from traditional marriages to a same-sex partnership later in life.

Robin Roberts

The ‘Good Morning America’ anchor dated men in her younger years before meeting her life partner. Robin Roberts kept her romantic life extremely private for most of her broadcasting career. She acknowledged her long-term relationship with Amber Laign publicly in a Facebook post in 2013. Her announcement was celebrated for its understated nature and she remains a role model for visibility.

David Hyde Pierce

The actor famous for playing Niles Crane on ‘Frasier’ dated women before settling down with a man. David Hyde Pierce kept his personal life out of the tabloids during the height of the show’s popularity. He married his longtime partner Brian Hargrove in 2008 shortly before Proposition 8 passed in California. He has since been a vocal supporter of Alzheimer’s research and LGBTQ+ rights.

Tell us which of these celebrity stories surprised you the most by leaving a message in the comments.