25 Best Psychological Thrillers on Paramount+ Right Now
Psychological thrillers hook you with their mind-bending twists and deep dives into human fears, desires, and secrets. Paramount+ has a killer lineup of these films, blending suspense, complex characters, and stories that keep you guessing until the end.
I’ve selected 25 of the best psychological thrillers streaming on Paramount+ right now, from creepy classics to fresh 2025 releases. These movies deliver tension, shocking reveals, and unforgettable performances, perfect for a night of edge-of-your-seat viewing. Each entry explores what makes the film a standout and why it’s worth your time.
25. The Stepfather (1987)
Terry O’Quinn plays a man obsessed with creating the perfect family, but his dark side emerges when things go wrong. This chilling film is a tense look at hidden evil.
O’Quinn’s creepy performance carries the low-budget thriller, blending charm with menace. It’s a lean, unsettling watch for fans of domestic suspense.
24. The Gift (2000)
Cate Blanchett stars as a psychic helping solve a small-town murder, uncovering secrets that put her in danger. Sam Raimi directs this moody Southern gothic tale.
Blanchett’s quiet intensity and the eerie atmosphere make it gripping, though some twists feel familiar. It’s a solid pick for supernatural thriller fans.
23. The Talented Mr. Ripley (1999)
Matt Damon plays Tom Ripley, a young man hired to retrieve a rich playboy, only to spiral into deception and murder. Based on Patricia Highsmith’s novel, it’s a stylish thriller.
Damon’s chilling charm and the lush Italian setting keep you hooked. It’s a slow-burn study of envy and identity that rewards attention.
22. Fatal Attraction (1987)
Glenn Close stars as a woman whose affair with a married man, played by Michael Douglas, turns obsessive and deadly. Adrian Lyne’s film defined the erotic thriller genre.
The intense performances and escalating tension make it a classic, even if the ending sparked debate. It’s a wild ride into passion gone wrong.
21. Snake Eyes (1998)
Nicolas Cage plays a corrupt cop caught in a murder conspiracy at a boxing match. Brian De Palma’s thriller is packed with flashy camera work and twists.
Cage’s manic energy and the intricate plot keep it engaging, though it leans on style over substance. It’s a fun, chaotic watch for suspense fans.
20. The Machinist (2004)
Christian Bale stars as a factory worker tormented by insomnia and guilt, unraveling as he sees visions. This dark indie thriller is raw and haunting.
Bale’s extreme transformation and the oppressive mood make it unforgettable, even if the plot gets murky. It’s a deep dive into a fractured mind.
19. Frailty (2001)
Bill Paxton directs and stars as a father who believes he’s on a divine mission to kill demons, dragging his sons into his madness. It’s a chilling Texas tale.
The creepy family dynamic and Paxton’s unhinged performance hit hard. It’s a lesser-known gem that blends faith and horror with psychological depth.
18. The Invitation (2015)
Logan Marshall-Green attends a dinner party hosted by his ex-wife, where strange vibes hint at a sinister plan. Karyn Kusama’s indie thriller builds dread slowly.
The claustrophobic setting and subtle clues keep you paranoid, with a gut-punch ending. It’s perfect for fans of slow-burn psychological tension.
17. Enemy (2013)
Jake Gyllenhaal plays a man who discovers his exact double, leading to a surreal spiral of identity and obsession. Denis Villeneuve directs this eerie puzzle.
The dreamlike visuals and Gyllenhaal’s dual performance make it a head-scratcher. It’s a bold, unsettling watch that lingers long after.
16. The Others (2001)
Nicole Kidman stars as a mother in a haunted mansion, protecting her light-sensitive kids from ghostly presences. Alejandro Amenábar’s film is a gothic chiller.
The moody atmosphere and Kidman’s raw performance drive the suspense, with a killer twist. It’s a haunting exploration of fear and loss.
15. 10 Cloverfield Lane (2016)
Mary Elizabeth Winstead wakes up in a bunker with John Goodman, who claims the world outside is gone. Dan Trachtenberg’s thriller keeps you guessing.
The tight setting and Goodman’s menacing performance create relentless tension. It’s a claustrophobic gem that toys with trust and reality.
14. A Simple Plan (1998)
Bill Paxton and Billy Bob Thornton find a crashed plane with millions in cash, sparking greed and betrayal. Sam Raimi’s film is a dark morality tale.
The snowy setting and strong performances ground the escalating chaos. It’s a gripping look at how far people go for money.
13. Primal Fear (1996)
Edward Norton plays a young man accused of murder, defended by Richard Gere’s slick lawyer. This courtroom thriller is packed with shocking twists.
Norton’s breakout performance and the layered plot keep you hooked. It’s a smart, intense ride for fans of legal drama and deception.
12. Misery (1990)
James Caan plays a writer held captive by his obsessive fan, played by Kathy Bates, in this Stephen King adaptation. Rob Reiner directs a tense nightmare.
Bates’ terrifying performance won an Oscar, and the confined setting amps up the dread. It’s a masterclass in psychological horror.
11. The Ring (2002)
Naomi Watts stars as a journalist investigating a cursed videotape that kills viewers in seven days. Gore Verbinski’s remake of a Japanese horror classic is chilling.
The creepy visuals and relentless pace make it a modern horror staple. It’s a heart-pounding thriller with a supernatural edge.
10. Disturbia (2007)
Shia LaBeouf plays a teen under house arrest who suspects his neighbor is a killer. D.J. Caruso’s film is a modern twist on Rear Window.
The relatable setup and LaBeouf’s charm keep it engaging, though it leans on teen drama. It’s a fun, suspenseful watch for a younger crowd.
9. The Cell (2000)
Jennifer Lopez plays a psychologist entering a serial killer’s mind to save a victim. Tarsem Singh’s thriller is a visual feast with a dark core.
The surreal dreamscapes and Vincent D’Onofrio’s chilling killer make it stand out. It’s a bold, trippy dive into madness.
8. Jacob’s Ladder (1990)
Tim Robbins stars as a Vietnam vet haunted by visions and conspiracies. Adrian Lyne’s film blends war trauma with psychological horror.
The disorienting visuals and Robbins’ raw performance create a nightmarish vibe. It’s a haunting look at guilt and reality’s edges.
7. Shutter Island (2010)
Leonardo DiCaprio plays a U.S. Marshal investigating a disappearance at a remote asylum. Martin Scorsese’s thriller is packed with twists and paranoia.
DiCaprio’s intensity and the moody island setting keep you on edge. It’s a gripping puzzle that demands a rewatch to catch every clue.
6. Zodiac (2007)
David Fincher’s film follows the hunt for the Zodiac Killer, with Jake Gyllenhaal as a journalist obsessed with the case. It’s based on real events.
The meticulous pacing and stellar cast, including Robert Downey Jr., make it a slow-burn masterpiece. It’s a deep dive into obsession and truth.
5. Strange Darling (2025)
Kyle Gallner and Willa Fitzgerald star in this serial killer thriller about a twisted romance gone wrong. It’s a fresh, unpredictable 2025 release.
The nonlinear storytelling and Fitzgerald’s standout performance keep you guessing. It’s a bold, bloody gem that’s gaining cult status.
4. Gone Girl (2014)
Ben Affleck plays a man whose wife, Rosamund Pike, vanishes, sparking a media frenzy. David Fincher’s thriller, based on Gillian Flynn’s novel, is a dark marriage tale.
Pike’s chilling performance and the clever twists make it a standout. It’s a sharp, unsettling look at love and deception.
3. Se7en (1995)
Brad Pitt and Morgan Freeman hunt a serial killer whose murders mimic the seven deadly sins. David Fincher’s gritty thriller is a genre classic.
The dark atmosphere and shocking finale stick with you long after. It’s a masterfully crafted descent into evil that never lets up.
2. The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
Jodie Foster stars as FBI trainee Clarice Starling, interviewing Anthony Hopkins’ Hannibal Lecter to catch another killer. Jonathan Demme’s film is a chilling masterpiece.
The tense cat-and-mouse game and Hopkins’ iconic performance make it unforgettable. It’s a rare thriller that won multiple Oscars for a reason.
1. Fight Club (1999)
Brad Pitt and Edward Norton star in David Fincher’s wild tale of a man spiraling into chaos through an underground fight club. Based on Chuck Palahniuk’s novel, it’s a cultural icon.
The anarchic energy, sharp dialogue, and mind-blowing twist make it a top pick. It’s a rebellious, thought-provoking ride that defines the genre.
Which of these psychological thrillers kept you up at night, or is there another Paramount+ gem I missed? Share your thoughts in the comments!