Every A24 Horror Movie Ranked from Worst to Best

A24 has carved a unique niche in the horror world, delivering films that push boundaries and challenge what scares us. From creepy folk tales to gory slashers, their catalog is packed with bold, unforgettable stories that linger long after the credits roll.

I’ve watched every A24 horror movie and ranked them from the least chilling to the absolute creepiest. This list dives into what makes each film tick, from their unique vibes to standout performances, all based on their impact and execution.

28. Tusk (2014)

This bizarre horror-comedy follows a podcaster, Wallace Bryton, who travels to Canada for an interview but ends up in the hands of a madman obsessed with turning him into a walrus. It’s a wild premise born from Kevin Smith’s podcast, but the execution feels like a long, uneven joke.

The mix of body horror and humor never quite gels, with the tone swinging wildly between silly and grotesque. Justin Long and Michael Parks give it their all, but the film’s oddity overshadows its scares, making it a tough watch for most.

27. False Positive (2021)

Ilana Glazer stars as Lucy, a woman whose dream pregnancy turns sinister under the care of a shady fertility doctor, played by Pierce Brosnan. The film aims for a ‘Rosemary’s Baby’ vibe but stumbles with a muddled message and a weak ending.

Despite strong performances, especially from Glazer and Brosnan, the story feels derivative and lacks the sharp edge of A24’s best. It tries to tackle big themes like sexism but doesn’t land the punch, leaving viewers wanting more.

26. Life After Beth (2014)

In this zombie comedy, Dane DeHaan’s character mourns his girlfriend Beth, played by Aubrey Plaza, only to find her back from the dead—but not quite herself. The concept of a zombie girlfriend soothed by smooth jazz sounds fun, but the script wanders aimlessly.

Plaza’s quirky charm keeps things watchable, but the horror and humor never blend smoothly. It feels like a missed chance to lean into its weird premise, resulting in a forgettable entry in A24’s lineup.

25. Slice (2018)

Set in a town where ghosts, witches, and werewolves coexist, ‘Slice’ follows a pizza shop dealing with a string of delivery driver murders. Chance the Rapper and Zazie Beetz lead a fun cast, but the film’s quirky horror-comedy vibe doesn’t fully connect.

The supernatural whodunit is creative, with a bouncy score by Ludwig Göransson, but it lacks depth and feels more like a playful sketch than a cohesive movie. It’s lighthearted but not memorable.

24. Woodshock (2017)

Kirsten Dunst plays a woman spiraling into grief and hallucinations after taking a reality-altering drug. Directed by fashion designers Kate and Laura Mulleavy, ‘Woodshock’ leans heavily on surreal visuals but forgets to tell a gripping story.

Dunst’s performance is haunting, but the thin plot and slow pace make it hard to stay engaged. It’s more of a mood piece than a horror film, which holds it back in this ranking.

23. The Front Room (2024)

Brandy stars as a pregnant woman whose life unravels when her creepy mother-in-law, played by Kathryn Hunter, moves in. The film tries to blend psychological horror with family drama but feels flat compared to A24’s stronger offerings.

Hunter’s unsettling performance is the highlight, but the story lacks the depth or scares to make it stand out. It’s a decent watch but doesn’t leave a lasting mark.

22. Lamb (2021)

This Icelandic folk horror follows a couple, led by Noomi Rapace, who adopt a mysterious half-human, half-lamb baby. The premise is bizarre, and the quiet, eerie tone keeps you hooked, but the payoff feels underwhelming.

Rapace shines as a grieving mother, and the film’s visuals are striking, but it stays too subdued to deliver big scares. It’s a unique slow burn that doesn’t fully ignite.

21. The Monster (2016)

A mother and daughter, played by Zoe Kazan and Ella Ballentine, are trapped in a car on a dark road with a creature lurking nearby. This lean creature feature uses shadows and tension effectively, but its simple story feels a bit too familiar.

Kazan’s raw performance as a flawed mom adds emotional weight, making the film more than just a monster flick. Still, it lacks the originality to climb higher on this list.

20. Climax (2018)

Gaspar Noé’s chaotic tale of a dance troupe descending into madness after drinking drugged sangria is a wild ride. The film’s vibrant visuals and intense choreography pull you in, but the thin plot holds it back.

Sofia Boutella leads a talented cast, and the escalating horror is gripping, but the shock value feels forced at times. It’s a bold experiment that doesn’t always land.

19. The Hole in the Ground (2019)

A mother, played by Seána Kerslake, suspects her son isn’t himself after he encounters a strange sinkhole. This Irish horror builds a creepy atmosphere with its rural setting and unsettling tone.

Kerslake’s performance carries the film, but the familiar ‘creepy kid’ trope keeps it from standing out. It’s a solid, chilling effort that doesn’t break new ground.

18. Men (2022)

Jessie Buckley plays a woman retreating to a countryside manor, only to encounter a series of men, all played by Rory Kinnear, with dark intentions. Alex Garland’s visually stunning film dives into themes of toxic masculinity but feels vague at times.

Buckley and Kinnear are phenomenal, and the body-horror climax is unforgettable, but the metaphor-heavy story can feel disjointed. It’s ambitious but not always clear.

17. MaXXXine (2024)

The final chapter of Ti West’s ‘X’ trilogy follows Mia Goth’s Maxine chasing Hollywood fame while a killer stalks her. It’s a bloody, stylish slasher with a great ‘80s vibe, but it lacks the raw edge of its predecessors.

Goth’s magnetic performance keeps it engaging, and the star-studded cast, including Kevin Bacon, adds flair. It’s fun but doesn’t match the trilogy’s earlier highs.

16. In Fabric (2018)

A haunted red dress brings chaos to its owners in this surreal horror-comedy by Peter Strickland. The blend of dark humor and eerie visuals is unique, but the slow pace might test some viewers’ patience.

Marianne Jean-Baptiste shines, and the film’s quirky tone is a refreshing departure from typical horror. It’s a strange, stylish gem that won’t click for everyone.

15. The Blackcoat’s Daughter (2015)

Two girls, played by Kiernan Shipka and Lucy Boynton, face sinister forces while stranded at their boarding school. Oz Perkins’ debut builds dread slowly, leading to a shocking finale.

Shipka’s chilling performance and the film’s eerie atmosphere make it a standout. Its understated approach might not grab everyone, but it’s a haunting slow burn.

14. X (2022)

Ti West’s slasher follows a 1970s adult film crew facing deadly consequences on a Texas farm. Mia Goth’s dual performance and the gritty retro vibe deliver bloody thrills.

The film’s mix of sleaze, humor, and brutal kills makes it a fun yet savage throwback. It’s a lean, mean horror gem.

13. Bodies Bodies Bodies (2022)

A group of rich twenty-somethings, including Amandla Stenberg and Pete Davidson, play a deadly party game during a hurricane. This horror-comedy nails its sharp satire of Gen Z culture with a fun, twisty plot.

The cast’s chemistry and clever script make it a blast, though it leans more on laughs than scares. It’s a fresh, entertaining take on the slasher genre.

12. The Killing of a Sacred Deer (2017)

Colin Farrell plays a surgeon whose life unravels after meeting a strange teenager, played by Barry Keoghan. Yorgos Lanthimos’ unsettling film blends psychological horror with a dark, mythic tone.

Keoghan’s creepy performance and the film’s oppressive atmosphere stick with you. It’s slow to start but builds to a chilling, unforgettable climax.

11. Saint Maud (2019)

Morfydd Clark stars as a devout nurse obsessed with saving her patient’s soul, spiraling into madness. Rose Glass’ debut is a gripping mix of faith, horror, and psychological tension.

Clark’s intense performance and the film’s bold visuals create a haunting experience. It’s a powerful, unsettling look at devotion gone wrong.

10. It Comes at Night (2017)

A family, led by Joel Edgerton, faces paranoia and danger in a post-apocalyptic world. Trey Edward Shults’ film thrives on tension and ambiguity, making you question who the real threat is.

The cast, including Kelvin Harrison Jr., delivers raw emotion, and the claustrophobic setting amps up the dread. It’s a heartbreaking, terrifying gem.

9. Under the Skin (2013)

Scarlett Johansson plays an alien seducing men in this eerie sci-fi horror. Jonathan Glazer’s film is unsettling and hypnotic, with a minimalist story and haunting visuals.

Johansson’s otherworldly performance and the film’s stark atmosphere make it unforgettable. It’s not traditional horror but leaves you deeply uneasy.

8. Green Room (2015)

A punk band, led by Anton Yelchin, fights for survival against neo-Nazis, headed by Patrick Stewart, in a gritty, brutal thriller. Jeremy Saulnier’s film is relentless and raw.

Yelchin and Stewart shine, and the intense, bloody action keeps you glued to the screen. It’s a visceral, heart-pounding ride.

7. Enemy (2013)

Jake Gyllenhaal plays dual roles in Denis Villeneuve’s psychological thriller about a man unraveling after encountering his identical double. The surreal, spider-infused narrative keeps you guessing.

Its moody Toronto backdrop and creeping dread build a tense, enigmatic vibe. It’s a mind-bending puzzle that lingers long after.

6. Talk to Me (2022)

Teens use an embalmed hand to contact spirits, leading to chaos in this chilling debut from Danny and Michael Philippou. Sophie Wilde’s raw performance as Mia drives the film’s emotional core.

The mix of grief, addiction, and supernatural horror is gripping, with practical effects adding to the terror. It’s a fresh, intense standout.

5. Pearl (2022)

Mia Goth stars as a farm girl in 1918 with deadly dreams of stardom in this ‘X’ prequel. Ti West’s vibrant direction and Goth’s unhinged performance make it a bloody, tragic masterpiece.

The film balances horror and drama, with a colorful retro aesthetic that pops. It’s a captivating character study with shocking moments.

4. Midsommar (2019)

Florence Pugh shines as a grieving woman drawn into a Swedish cult’s sunny yet sinister rituals in Ari Aster’s folk-horror epic. The vibrant visuals mask a chilling descent into madness.

The film’s unsettling daylight horror, emotional depth, and Pugh’s raw performance make it a haunting exploration of grief and manipulation. It’s disturbingly captivating.

3. The Lighthouse (2019)

Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe descend into madness as isolated lighthouse keepers in Robert Eggers’ claustrophobic fever dream. Shot in stark black-and-white, the film’s mythic intensity and unhinged performances grip tightly.

The blend of psychological horror, surreal folklore, and salty dialogue creates a disorienting, unforgettable nightmare. It’s a bold, deranged masterpiece.

2. The Witch (2015)

Set in 1630, a Puritan family faces supernatural horrors in Robert Eggers’ chilling debut. Anya Taylor-Joy’s breakout role and the film’s authentic, eerie vibe make it unforgettable.

The slow-burn dread and Black Phillip’s sinister presence build to a haunting climax. It’s a masterclass in atmospheric horror.

1. Hereditary (2018)

Toni Collette delivers a powerhouse performance as a mother unraveling after her family’s tragedies reveal dark secrets. Ari Aster’s debut is a gut-wrenching blend of grief and demonic horror.

The film’s shocking twists, meticulous details, and Collette’s raw emotion make it A24’s scariest and most impactful horror film. It’s a modern classic.

Which A24 horror movie keeps you up at night, or did I miss a hidden gem? Drop your thoughts in the comments!