Fans Rank the Top 10 Marvel Superheroes of All Time

Marvel Comics feature an incredible array of characters, making it difficult to rank them by popularity or any other measure. To get meaningful results, you’d need a large sample of fans to weigh in.

With over a million votes on the list of superheroes, here’s a strong insight into which Marvel heroes truly stand out. Let’s take a look at the results.

10. Scarlet Witch

Even before the MCU, Scarlet Witch was already one of the most popular superheroes, though her role in comic history hasn’t always been on the right side. She has it all: a complex backstory, immense power, emotional depth, and a key role in iconic storylines like House of M. It’s no surprise Wanda ranks so highly.

9. Black Panther

One of Marvel’s first major Black superheroes, Black Panther made his debut in Fantastic Four #52 in 1966. Created by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby, he marked a groundbreaking moment in comic book history and has become a powerful symbol of Black empowerment and pride. Beyond his role as a social icon, Black Panther has also established a rich lore centered around Wakanda and African culture in the comics.

8. Doctor Strange

Doctor Strange is one of the most renowned and powerful magic users in the comics. He made his debut in Strange Tales #110 in 1963 but only gained significant prominence a few years later. Created to introduce something new and exciting to the Marvel Universe, Strange initially faced some uncertainty from Stan Lee. However, he has since become a key figure in major storylines and crossovers, anchoring the magical and supernatural aspects of the Marvel Universe.

7. Captain America

You might be surprised to see Captain America not higher on this list. Created during World War II, Captain America embodies American ideals such as bravery, justice, and patriotism. His iconic shield and costume were designed to symbolize the fight against tyranny and oppression, with his first villain being none other than Adolf Hitler.

Throughout the decades, Captain America has frequently mirrored contemporary social and political issues, tackling themes like civil rights, governmental accountability, and the moral complexities of heroism. And let’s not forget—he’s also undeniably badass.

6. Hulk

Initially, The Incredible Hulk series struggled with sales and was canceled after just six issues. Despite this, the character continued to feature in other Marvel titles like The Avengers and Tales to Astonish.

Hulk gained significant popularity with college students thanks to the live-action TV show The Incredible Hulk, which aired from 1977 to 1982. Today, Hulk stands as one of Marvel’s most prominent characters, largely due to various writers who expanded his backstory and introduced psychological and moral complexity to his development.

5. Thor

The inspiration behind Thor is fairly straightforward. The character was created to expand the Marvel Universe with mythological and cosmic elements, introducing a new kind of superhero to Marvel’s growing lineup. By the early 1960s, Marvel had already introduced popular characters like the Fantastic Four, the Hulk, and Spider-Man, all of whom had scientific or human origins. Stan Lee wanted to diversify the types of heroes they were creating.

Norse mythology was relatively uncharted territory at the time, and Thor’s success helped cement his place in the Marvel Universe. Given his lasting impact, I personally agree with Thor’s ranking.

4. Iron Man

Iron Man is one of the most popular Avengers and one of the smartest characters in comics. Stan Lee often mentioned that Iron Man was created as a personal challenge. In the early 1960s, as the counterculture movement gained momentum and anti-war and anti-establishment sentiments grew, especially among younger audiences, Tony Stark—Iron Man’s alter ego—embodied a character that might initially seem unappealing.

As a billionaire industrialist and weapons manufacturer, Stark represented the very symbol of the military-industrial complex. Iron Man’s creation was influenced by a mix of factors, including the Cold War, advancing technology, and a desire to delve into more complex and flawed heroes.

3. Wolverine

The first and only true-blue X-Man on this list, Wolverine has not only topped the popularity charts among X-Men but has also secured a spot in the top 3 of Marvel Comics characters overall.

Wolverine was specifically created as a Canadian hero to appeal to readers in Canada, where Marvel was expanding its presence. His nationality helped set him apart from the predominantly American Marvel heroes. And yes, he was intentionally modeled after the wolverine animal, known for being small yet fearsome and taking on creatures much larger than itself—take that, Hugh Jackman fans!

2. Deadpool

Well, this is the first “superhero” I have some reservations about. Personally, I don’t believe Deadpool should be on the list at all, but fans have made their preference clear! Deadpool’s creation was heavily influenced by the early 1990s trends, especially the rise of anti-heroes in comics. Despite what Liefeld might claim, the similarities between Deadpool and Slade Wilson, aka DC’s Deathstroke, are hard to ignore.

Initially written as a villain, Deadpool’s popularity quickly surged, and he evolved into more of an anti-hero. While he is undeniably popular, I wouldn’t place him at the number 2 spot in terms of complexity, overall significance, and legacy.

1. Spider-Man

It’s always Spider-Man. Created by Stan Lee and Steve Ditko, Spider-Man made his debut in Amazing Fantasy #15 in August 1962. His introduction marked a significant shift from traditional superhero tropes, presenting a relatable, flawed, and human character who has since become one of the most beloved superheroes of all time.

The goal was to craft a new type of superhero—one that teenagers and readers could connect with on a personal level—and they achieved that brilliantly. Six decades later, Spider-Man remains at the top of the popularity charts and continues to be a major asset for the Marvel franchise.

You can check out the full list on Ranker.

Do you agree with this list? Share your thoughts in the comments below!